Bethany Real Estate

Bethany Real Estate

Bethany is a charming town nestled in Genesee County, New York. With its picturesque landscapes and close-knit community, this city offers a peaceful and serene living environment for residents.

Located in the heart of upstate New York, Bethany boasts a rich history dating back to its founding in 1812. The town is named after Bethany, a village in Connecticut, and has since grown to become a beloved community for families and individuals alike.

Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the abundance of outdoor recreational opportunities available in Bethany. The town is home to several parks and nature preserves, offering residents the chance to explore beautiful trails, go hiking, or enjoy a picnic amidst stunning natural surroundings.

For those seeking a small-town feel with easy access to urban amenities, Bethany is an ideal choice. The city is conveniently located near major highways, making it easy to commute to nearby cities such as Buffalo and Rochester. Residents can enjoy the tranquility of small-town living while still being within reach of shopping centers, restaurants, and cultural attractions.

Real estate in Bethany offers a diverse range of options to suit every buyer's needs. From cozy single-family homes to spacious ranch-style properties, there is something for everyone. The town's real estate market is known for its affordability, making it an attractive destination for first-time homebuyers and those looking to invest in a peaceful community.

In conclusion, Bethany is a hidden gem in Genesee County, New York. With its natural beauty, strong sense of community, and affordable real estate options, this city is a wonderful place to call home.

Newest Listings in Bethany

Bethany
$94,900
R1724397 MLS
RARE FIND. 12 acres awesome country location. corner lot partially wooded, cleared for building your dream home. enjoy scenic views. prime location. Do not walk property without permission. Now is the time to build your forever home. Alexander schools.

Bethany
5421 Ellicott Street Road, Bethany
$197,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723456 MLS
Country living perks located just outside of Batavia, in the Pavilion School District. This turn key, 3 bedroom, 1 bath home, with full basement on almost 2 acres, is just waiting for your dream paint colors and your "Welcome" porch sign. Large, well thought out kitchen overlooking your living/dining room combo. Newer metal roof and the public water line being run into the house means your setteling in Hakuna Matata style...it means "no worries..". Large driveway offers a convienent turn around. 2 Sheds convey with home as well. This is the perfect home for 1st timers, down sizers, landlords and everyone in between. Offers are being reviewed Monday, 10.26.26 @ 6:30 pm.

5421 Ellicott Street Road, Bethany
9463 Putnam Road, Bethany
$315,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1719976 MLS
Timeless character, generous living spaces, and thoughtful modern updates define this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in the Alexander School District. Set among mature trees and manicured grounds, the property offers a sense of privacy and tranquility while remaining conveniently close to shopping, dining, and everyday amenities. Inside, spacious bedrooms and baths, multiple inviting living areas, abundant natural light, and distinctive architectural details create a home that feels both refined and welcoming. Something so different than today’s cookie-cutter homes. Step inside to a bright, welcoming interior where hardwood flooring installed throughout in 2023 creates a warm and cohesive feel. The spacious kitchen was opened up with the removal of a wall in 2023 and features stainless steel appliances, recessed lighting, abundant storage, and beautifully restained cabinetry completed in 2026. Designed with both everyday living and entertaining in mind, the home offers multiple gathering spaces filled with natural light. Three fireplaces, including a striking stone fireplace, create inviting focal points, while the expansive window-lined sunroom overlooks the property and provides an incredible space to relax, entertain, or simply take in the peaceful surroundings. Recent improvements continue throughout the home with an updated laundry room with recessed lighting (2025), a new electrical breaker box, and new copper piping on the boiler (2025). The exterior received fresh paint and new shutters in 2025, followed by updated landscaping in 2026, adding to the home’s curb appeal. Outside, enjoy a spacious lawn, mature trees, beautiful views, and plenty of room to make the property your own. A two-car attached garage and metal roof add even more convenience and value. Full of personality and thoughtfully improved inside and out, this is a home that stands apart—offering the space, setting, and character that are increasingly hard to find. Seller reserves the right to set a deadline. Join us for an open house Saturday, October 10th from 11am to 1pm.

9463 Putnam Road, Bethany
5729 Ellicott Street Road, Bethany
$159,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1710915 MLS
Come see this cozy home with lots of space for entertaining! Home features natural woodwork, three bedrooms, 1.5 baths, formal dining room, first floor laundry and an enclosed porch. Just 4 miles from Genesee County Park and 6 miles South of Batavia.

5729 Ellicott Street Road, Bethany
9533 Bethany Center Road, Bethany
$49,900
B1709824 MLS
Build Your Country Dream! Newly surveyed 1.137-acre building lot located on a quiet country road. This lovely, scenic parcel offers a private, treed setting with plenty of country charm. The property was formerly the site of a home and currently has an existing well and septic system on site; seller makes no representations or warranties as to their condition or usability. Public water has recently been installed along the road and is expected to be available for future connection, should the new owner choose to hook up. A beautiful setting with existing infrastructure and future public water potential—bring your plans and make it yours!

9533 Bethany Center Road, Bethany
5875 Ellicott Street Road, Bethany
$225,000
B1612939 MLS
Exceptional Multi-Building Property – Church, Rectory & Event Barn/Gymnasium. A unique and well-cared-for property offering exceptional flexibility and potential! This multi-building complex includes a traditional church with attached rectory and a separate gymnasium/event barn—all situated on a well-maintained lot with updated systems and thoughtful improvements throughout. The church and rectory feature an upgraded HVAC system with central air added in the 2000s (no known heating or cooling issues), circuit breaker electrical, and solid roofing with shingles, gutters, and downspouts replaced in 2017. The rectory includes multiple rooms, ideal for living space, offices, or guest use, and although there is a small drywall repair needed above the stairwell, there are no active water or plumbing issues. A new well pump was installed in December 2024 for reliable water service. This is a rare chance to acquire a move-in-ready campus with historical charm and modern updates. Ideal for continued use as a place of worship, a community center, event venue, or visionary redevelopment. The event barn/gymnasium (EB Hall) has seen major improvements including a new septic system in 2018, drainage upgrades and waterproof exterior wall renovations in 2022, and an energy-efficient exterior door. The flat roof has been repaired and maintained consistently from 2010 through 2022, with no leaks reported. The interior is ideal for hosting events, sports, community functions, or repurposing for creative use.

5875 Ellicott Street Road, Bethany
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!