Randolph Real Estate

Randolph Real Estate

Randolph: A Charming Town in Cattaraugus County, New York

Nestled in the heart of Cattaraugus County, New York, lies the picturesque town of Randolph. With its small-town charm and close-knit community, Randolph offers a peaceful and welcoming atmosphere for residents and visitors alike.

Located in the southwestern part of the state, Randolph boasts stunning natural beauty, with rolling hills, lush forests, and scenic landscapes. Outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty of opportunities for recreational activities, such as hiking, biking, fishing, and camping, thanks to the town's proximity to Allegany State Park and the Allegheny National Forest.

Randolph is known for its rich history and preservation of its heritage. The town's Main Street is lined with historic buildings, showcasing the architectural beauty of yesteryears. The Randolph Historical Society actively works to preserve and promote the town's history through exhibits, events, and educational programs.

In addition to its natural beauty and historical significance, Randolph offers a range of amenities and services to its residents. The town has a vibrant downtown area with local shops, restaurants, and cafes, providing a charming and convenient place to meet friends or grab a bite to eat.

For families, Randolph offers excellent schools, making it an ideal place to raise children. The town also hosts various community events throughout the year, fostering a strong sense of community and creating opportunities for residents to come together and celebrate.

Whether you're looking to settle down in a peaceful and friendly community or planning a visit to explore the natural wonders of Cattaraugus County, Randolph is a destination worth considering. Its small-town charm, rich history, and stunning surroundings make it a hidden gem in the heart of New York.

Newest Listings in Randolph

144 Main Street, Randolph
$75,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1723864 MLS
Historic character and renovation potential meet at 144 Main Street in Randolph, NY. Known as the Sheldon Residence. Thaddeus Spencer Sheldon (1818–1868) arrived in Randolph in 1836 and operated a store that served as an exchange for goods produced by area farmers. This circa-1850, one-and-a-half-story, three-bay Gothic Revival home showcases wood-frame construction, board-and-batten siding, and a cross-gabled roof with ornate wood vergeboard at the eaves. There are new wood details in the garage ready to be installed. Tall windows with decorative wood head trim and wood shutters add to its distinctive architectural charm. A new metal roof is already in place, setting the stage for bringing this historic property back to life. Offering over 3,000 square feet, the spacious interior was last used as a flower and gift shop. Some hardwood floors remain in very good condition, while portions of the upstairs have been gutted following water damage. No utilities are currently on or functioning within the home. Renovation is needed, providing an opportunity to restore its character and explore future uses, subject to applicable approvals. Situated on a nice corner lot along the Amish Trail in Cattaraugus County, the property includes a driveway, attached garage, and access to on-street parking. Its Main Street location offers convenient access to Interstate 86, routes toward Ellicottville, and nearby Allegany State Park. Bring your vision to this distinctive piece of Randolph history. Whether you’re drawn to a home with historic character to restore and make your own or envision a distinctive setting for your business, the Sheldon Residence offers possibilities worth exploring. Could this piece of Randolph history be the right opportunity for you? Buyers are encouraged to independently investigate potential historic preservation grants and rehabilitation tax credits. Eligibility and funding availability are subject to applicable program requirements and approvals and are not guaranteed.

144 Main Street, Randolph
85 Main Street, Randolph
$249,900
B1723209 MLS
Charming, Beautifully Renovated Commercial Space with Drive-Thru Potential in the Heart of Randolph! Dreaming of opening your own coffee shop, wine bar, boutique, or specialty retail business? This beautifully transformed commercial property at 85 Main Street in the charming village of Randolph might be just what you’ve been waiting for! Thoughtfully renovated from top to bottom, this inviting space offers the perfect blend of modern updates, warmth, and character. Inside, you'll discover gorgeous new luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, a cozy electric fireplace with a beautiful mantel, a brand-new bathroom, and a convenient kitchenette. Additional improvements include updated plumbing and electrical, along with a mini-split system providing efficient heating and air conditioning. One of the property’s most exciting features is the drive-thru window with an exterior drive-thru path, offering a unique opportunity for a coffee shop, café, or grab-and-go business! The welcoming atmosphere makes it easy to envision customers gathering over their morning coffee, enjoying an evening glass of wine, or browsing a charming boutique. With so many major improvements already completed, this property offers a wonderful head start for your next business venture. Whether you’re an aspiring entrepreneur, an established business owner looking for a new location, or an investor searching for a distinctive commercial property, the possibilities here are exciting! Beautifully updated, full of charm, and ready for your vision—85 Main Street is an opportunity you won’t want to miss!

85 Main Street, Randolph
3536 Watts Road, Randolph
$99,999
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1722446 MLS
Explore the possibilities at 0 Watts Road in the Town of Randolph! Located off West Main Street in Cattaraugus County, this approximately 2.082-acre parcel is being subdivided from a larger lot, with approximately 200 feet of road frontage and a depth of 481 feet. Bring your plans for a new home, or envision a seasonal RV retreat for snowbirds returning to enjoy Western New York’s beautiful summers, subject to applicable approvals. A stone/gravel dirt driveway leads to an approximately 32-by-50-foot, one-and-a-half-story garage/shop with a metal roof, metal exterior, and solid concrete floor. The barn features a large front deck, a smaller rear deck, and new man doors on the upper level. The barn previously had electric service, and interior wiring remains; a new meter and service box would be needed to restore service. There is no water or septic serving the barn. Taxes will be determined following subdivision. Please review the listing photos and supplemental tentative parcel/survey information for the proposed boundaries and layout. Enjoy easy access to Interstate 86 along the Southern Tier of Western New York. A nature lover’s wonderland, the surrounding area offers a snowmobile trail close by, equestrian trails, and opportunities for boating, hiking, fishing, and skiing. Create your own home base for enjoying the beauty and recreation of every season!

3536 Watts Road, Randolph
361 Main Street, Randolph
$259,999
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1722219 MLS
Completely renovated from top to bottom with additional square footage added, this four-bedroom, two-bath home at 361 Main Street in Randolph blends fresh updates with warm, inviting finishes. The living room features a vaulted ceiling and electric fireplace, while the new kitchen offers hickory cabinets, granite countertops, and sliding glass doors opening to a deck that spans the back of the house. A formal dining room provides space for everyday meals and special gatherings, and the spacious entry offers flexibility for an office area if needed. Three bedrooms that have vaulted ceilings with carpet and ceiling fans complement an oversized primary bedroom LVP flooring & 2 ceiling fans has its own sliding glass doors to the back deck that spans 55' with a center octagon seating area. One full bathroom includes a tub, while the second bathroom features a convenient corner shower and laundry area. Updates include a metal roof, vinyl siding, a new 200-amp electrical panel, all new windowns, plumbing, electric baseboards, fixtures, lighting, flooring, drywall and new perimeter drain tile. The attached 24X15 one-car garage with a 10x10' door insulated features LED lighting and floor drain and an additional side parking pad. New water main from the road. Located in the heart of Amish country in Cattaraugus County, this home offers convenient access to Interstate 86 for travel to Olean, Jamestown, and the county seat of Little Valley. Enjoy four-season recreation within a short drive, including Holiday Valley and Onoville Marina, along with snowmobile trails, equestrian trails, hiking, skiing, fishing, and boating. Updated living and outdoor adventure come together in this thoughtfully renovated Randolph home.

361 Main Street, Randolph
12523 Torrence Road, Randolph
$159,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1721145 MLS
Enjoy the possibilities this country property has to offer! Situated on approximately 4.75 acres with beautiful mountain views, this two-story home features 3 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, an eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar, and convenient first-floor laundry. Additional features include a full unfinished basement, metal roof, aluminum siding, propane forced-air heating, and a pellet stove. A detached two-car garage provides additional parking and storage. The property is serviced by a private well and septic system, and gas rights are included, subject to verification of applicable terms and documentation. While the home would benefit from some updating and personal touches, it offers an opportunity to make it your own and enjoy the space and setting that acreage provides. Explore the potential of this property and schedule your showing today!

12523 Torrence Road, Randolph
2418 Little Bone Run Road, Randolph
$199,999
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1720677 MLS
It's all about the VIEWS! Welcome to 2418 Little Bone Run Road, where breathtaking countryside views take center stage! Situated on 3.9 acres in Kennedy, NY, this charming 3 bedroom, 1 bath home offers a picturesque setting with sweeping views of the surrounding rolling hills and countryside. The sellers have thoughtfully removed numerous trees to open up the landscape and showcase the stunning scenery. Whether you're enjoying your morning coffee or unwinding at sunset, the views are truly something special! Two covered porches provide wonderful spaces to relax, entertain, and take in the peaceful surroundings. The property also features a small pond, a 2-car garage, a spacious garden shed, and plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. Inside, you'll find a home filled with updates! Improvements include a new furnace (2022), updated kitchen flooring, appliances and fixtures, a completely remodeled bathroom, new bedroom carpeting, fresh paint, select replacement windows, a new hot water tank, sidewalk, and soffits. Additional features include central air conditioning, a blacktop driveway, generator panel connection, and a partially finished walkout basement offering flexible additional living space. Located in Cattaraugus County within the Randolph Central School District and just minutes from Chautauqua County, this property combines beautiful scenery, acreage, and modern updates in one inviting package.

2418 Little Bone Run Road, Randolph
1 New Street, Randolph
$79,999
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1707216 MLS
Welcome to 1 New Street in Randolph, NY—a home with plenty of space, great potential, and an opportunity to make it your own! Featuring 5 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, this property offers room to grow and is ready for someone willing to bring a little vision and sweat equity. One of the bathrooms has been updated, while recent improvements include a new gas forced-air furnace and a roof approximately four years old. Additional heating options include several gas wall units and a wood stove, giving you plenty of choices during Western New York winters. Situated on a corner lot, the property offers outdoor space with room for a future garage. The home does need TLC and updating, but its size, location, and recent mechanical improvements provide a solid starting point for renovation. Conveniently located near Interstate 86, you'll enjoy easy access throughout the Southern Tier while still being close to the conveniences and small-town charm of Randolph. If you've been looking for a property where you can build equity, add your own style, and unlock its potential, 1 New Street may be the opportunity you've been waiting for!

1 New Street, Randolph
37 N Washington Street, Randolph
$179,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1693224 MLS
Impeccable three-bedroom home in Randolph. Located on a neighborhood street, this home will satisfy your desire for small-town life, while still being a short drive from I-86, putting city amenities in easy reach. Inside, the cool color palette and spacious rooms give the interior an airy and open feel. The main floor has a primary bedroom with an en-suite bath. The country kitchen has a breakfast bar and solid-surface counters, and is spacious enough to include a dining nook. The formal dining room has built-ins to display your china. The living room features a gas fireplace and a wall of built-in storage, the perfect place for your movies or books. The main floor also has a media room that could be an office, a laundry room, and a storage room. Upstairs there are two more spacious bedrooms and a second full bath. Outside, there is a covered porch and a deck overlooking the backyard. This property also features an extra-large, two-car garage with electrical service and heat. The garage also has workshop space and storage, with an open second floor.

37 N Washington Street, Randolph
232 Main Street, Randolph
$45,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1692463 MLS
Opportunity awaits at 232 Main Street, East Randolph, NY! This 1,470-square-foot Cape Cod-style home sits on a manageable 58' x 95' lot and offers a blank canvas for your vision. The home has been completely gutted, providing the perfect opportunity to design and finish the interior to suit your personal style, needs, or investment goals. Enjoy the convenience of village living with public water, sewer, natural gas, and electric already connected to the property. The classic Cape Cod design offers the potential for additional living space on the second floor, creating flexibility for extra bedrooms, a home office, or recreational space. Located just minutes from Randolph Central School, local shopping, restaurants, and everyday conveniences, this property combines small-town charm with accessibility. Easy access to Interstate 86 makes commuting simple while providing convenient travel to nearby destinations including Jamestown, Salamanca, Ellicottville, Allegany State Park, Seneca Allegany Resort & Casino, and the recreational opportunities of Chautauqua County and the Enchanted Mountains region. Whether you're looking to create your dream home, a rental property, or a renovation project, this property offers endless possibilities. Conveniently located in "East" Randolph, you'll appreciate the accessibility to local amenities while enjoying the charm of a small-town community. Bring your imagination and turn this property into something special! No children at showings as there are missing floor boards and no handrailing.

232 Main Street, Randolph
10 Jamestown Street, Randolph
$125,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1691160 MLS
Excellent investment opportunity in the heart of Randolph, NY! This well-maintained brick duplex offers two income-producing units and is conveniently located close to schools, shopping, restaurants, and all village amenities. The upper apartment features 3 bedrooms (1 currently used as laundry room) and 1 full bath, open kitchen and living room with plenty of storage. The lower unit offers 1 bedroom, large, walk-in closet, living room, and kitchen, and 3/4 bath. The property has been thoughtfully maintained, including professionally repointed brickwork and two newer furnaces, 1 newer hot water tank. Tenants pay their own gas and electric, with separate gas and electric meters for each apartment. Public water and sewer are currently paid by the seller. Both units include a stove and refrigerator owned by the seller. Any washers and dryers located on-site belong to the tenants and are not included in the sale. Additional features include a full basement, ample off-street parking, and an extra lot that provides additional space and flexibility. Situated along a high-visibility, heavily traveled corridor, the property offers excellent exposure and potential for future development opportunities. The additional lot may provide possibilities for expanded use, additional parking, or other ventures, subject to municipal approvals and zoning requirements. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio or explore mixed-use possibilities, this property offers outstanding potential in a desirable village location. Don't miss this opportunity to own a solid brick multi-family property with strong rental appeal and future possibilities in Randolph, New York!

10 Jamestown Street, Randolph
41 Main Street, Randolph
$599,000
R1660140 MLS
Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a well-established turnkey automotive dealership in the heart of the Enchanted Mountains! Located just minutes off of I-86 which serves as a strategic hub for customers across Cattaraugus and Chautauqua Counties. This property boasts significant road frontage along with a large, paved display area. Walk into a bright inviting showroom that includes multiple private sales offices along with a cozy waiting room. The State-of-the-art service center has multiple bays equipped with high clearance overhead doors and commercial grade lifts. There is a parts department for keeping inventory secure and organized. The back building has been used for a drive in detail bay perfect for prepping multiple vehicles at the same time. The sale includes the transfer of a New York State Motor vehicle inspector certification, GM Specialty tools, front end alignment machine, inspection machine, battery tester, wheel balancing machines, tire machines and more. Metal roof was installed in 2010 and a new boiler system in 2024!

41 Main Street, Randolph
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!