Allegany Real Estate

Allegany Real Estate

Allegany: A Charming Town in Cattaraugus County, NY

Nestled in the heart of Cattaraugus County, New York, lies the picturesque town of Allegany. Known for its small-town charm and natural beauty, Allegany offers a peaceful and welcoming community for residents and visitors alike.

One of the first things that will strike you about Allegany is its stunning surroundings. Surrounded by rolling hills and lush forests, this town is a nature lover's paradise. From hiking and biking trails to fishing and boating opportunities, outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty to explore in Allegany's scenic landscapes.

Allegany is also home to a vibrant community that takes pride in its rich history and cultural heritage. The town boasts a variety of historical landmarks, including the Allegany Area Historical Association Museum, where visitors can learn about the town's past and its significance in the region.

In terms of amenities, Allegany offers a range of local shops, restaurants, and services to meet residents' daily needs. The town also benefits from its close proximity to nearby cities, making it convenient for commuters or those looking for additional entertainment options.

For families, Allegany is served by the Allegany-Limestone Central School District, providing quality education for students of all ages. The town also hosts various community events throughout the year, fostering a strong sense of unity and camaraderie among its residents.

Whether you're seeking a peaceful place to call home or a charming destination to visit, Allegany has something for everyone. With its natural beauty, rich history, and welcoming community, Allegany is truly a hidden gem in Cattaraugus County, New York.

Newest Listings in Allegany

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1712718 MLS

Welcome to this spacious tri-level home situated on a desirable double lot in the Town of Allegany! The main level offers a comfortable and functional layout with a generous living room, formal dining room, and well-appointed kitchen. The kitchen provides plenty of cabinet and counter space, while the cozy living is perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The upper level is dedicated to the bedroom area, offering three spacious bedrooms with ample closet space and a full bath. The lower level provides even more living space with a large family room featuring an electric fireplace plus a convenient laundry area and second full bath. Need additional space? The partially finished basement offers a great area for a workout room, craft space, hobby area, or additional hangout space. Outside, you'll find a new shed with endless possibilities. With electric already connected to the home's main service, this space could easily become a home office, art or paint studio, playroom, or your own private retreat. Add a space heater in the winter and enjoy this versatile space year-round. A second shed provides convenient storage for lawn and garden equipment. Enjoy the outdoors from the back patio, complete with space for a hot tub, or relax under your own pergola with picnic table—an inviting spot for outdoor meals, morning coffee, or entertaining friends and family. A two-car garage provides additional convenience and storage. With its spacious rooms, multiple levels of living space, double lot, and flexible outdoor areas, this Allegany home offers plenty of room to live, work, relax, and enjoy!

3445 Celeste Drive, Allegany

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712521 MLS

Cozy 3 bedroom~2 bathroom single wide located in Colonial Village. This home offers a comfortable layout with plenty of storage throughout, making it easy to keep everything organized. This home features a separate laundry area, two full bathrooms, and a quaint living area with a fireplace (working condition is unknown). Right off the the driveway is a large enclosed shed that offers tons of potential and could be used as a workshop, hobby space, recreational space or additional storage. With plenty of room inside and out, this home offers a great combination of comfort, convenience and space.

3974 Route 417 Unit 138, Allegany

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712436 MLS

Move quickly on this one! Village of Allegany in wonderful neighborhood! Three bedrooms/2 baths with attached garage, great backyard, full basement. Tons of room with a great room, sunroom and living room to boot. Make this your forever home. Desirable dead end street so light traffic. Allegany schools!. All offers due Thursday at 1:00.

2 Upland, Allegany

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1710633 MLS

Welcome to your ultimate private sanctuary. Nestled on a spectacular 20-acre lot, this stunning 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and pristine beauty, complete with its own tranquil small pond and breathtaking panoramic views! 3 spacious bedrooms with ample natural light. Master features a private en-suite bathroom with jacuzzi tub and stand up shower. Attached two car garage, with an additional unattached garage and workshop area. Beautiful oak flooring and fully finished basement area for extra entertaining space. Deck area with pool, but the pool has not been used in several years. Escape the hustle and bustle without sacrificing convenience. This property offers the rare opportunity to live an off-grid lifestyle while staying a short distance away from local shopping, dining and schools. From breathtaking views to peaceful starry nights, this spectacular 20 acre estate is ready for your next chapter. t

1381 Two Mile Road, Allegany

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1707860 MLS

These BRAND NEW Homes are in the only 55+ Community in our area, and are designed around comfort, convenience & community with carefree & independent living. They offer a peaceful, country-like feel while remaining close to city conveniences. Situated along a quiet circular neighborhood road, each home offers 1,540 sq.ft. of step-free living! They Feature 2 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, an Attached, Oversized 2-Car Garage. They have radiant floor heat, Central Air, Gas Fireplace, Brand New Dishwasher & Microwave, Abundant Storage, as well as a Sun Room, Covered Front Porch & Rear Patio with seasonal awning that provide inviting outdoor space without the burden of exterior upkeep! Each Residence is a Town House, separated by a substantial 10" concrete studded wall designed for sound & fire separation for added privacy. For greater affordability, you own your home while leasing the land beneath it, with full use of the amenities. The current $371 monthly land rental/maintenance fee includes: weekly garbage collection, lawn mowing, snow shoveling, weeding, trimming, plus installation, removal & storage of the rear awning. Taxes are approximately $5,000 annually & eligible homeowners may qualify for NY's STAR property-tax relief program. Buyers should verify individual taxes and STAR eligibility. Best of all, this is **Independent Living On YOUR Terms.** Should you ever want housekeeping services they may be arranged according to your individual needs. As part of the Field of Dreams Senior Living campus, residents can enjoy the campus grounds & amenities, including Modern Clubhouse for gatherings and private events, Walking Trails, Golf-Cart Path, a Dog Park, Ponds & Year-Round Activities. An on-site maintenance team is also available 24/7, offering reasonably priced services exclusively to the community when extra help is needed. Enjoy the Lifestyle that you've worked so hard for! Start the next Chapter at this Brand New Welcoming Neighborhood Community!

11 Louis Drive, Allegany

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1708259 MLS

Side-by-side single-story duplexes don't come along often. Only a few stairs to enter, no shared floors, no neighbors overhead — just two private units, each with its own entrance and its own driveway. That layout is exactly what tenants stay put for, and it's why this property has held long-term renters year after year. At 2,048 square feet, there's real living space here, not the cramped footprint you find in most small multifamily. Both units are single-story, making them appealing to a wide tenant pool. The investor angle: one unit will be delivered vacant at closing, giving you the chance to reset that rent at market from day one. The remaining tenant is long-term, currently at $550 plus utilities, and open to negotiating a new lease. Tenants pay their own utilities, keeping your operating costs predictable. Recent capital already in place: a portion of the roof was replaced within the last 2–3 years, with the balance approximately 12 years old — meaningful deferred maintenance already handled. Yes, it needs some TLC. That's the opportunity. Cosmetic updates here translate directly into higher rents in a village where quality rentals are genuinely hard to find. Whether you're adding to a portfolio or house-hacking your first property — live in one side, let the other side pay the mortgage — this is the kind of property that rewards a little sweat equity. Sought-after Village of Allegany location. Properties like this rarely hit the open market. Schedule your showing today.

37 N 3rd Street, Allegany

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1708140 MLS

2 unit apartment building located in the town of Alllegany NY. Off street parking. The upper and lower units are identical. They are both 552 sf with One bedroom and One bathroom each. The upper is currently occupied at $1,000 per month. The lower is vacant and is in the process of some updates. This is a very efficient apartment and is always rented. The location cannot be beat. Located beteween Olean and The village of Allegany with many retails stores within walking distance or a short drive. This apartment building is located directly behind the Plaza that houses UR medicine and Grand Slam. If this plaza expands they will need this property. In the meantime it is an easy money maker

1827 Willard Street, Allegany

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1706895 MLS

Historic Charm, Modern Updates & Income Potential in the Heart of Allegany! Welcome to this beautifully updated Victorian-style home offering 5 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, timeless character, and exceptional versatility, all within walking distance to St. Bonaventure University. From the inviting front porch and classic gabled rooflines to the upper-level rooftop patio, this home is full of unique architectural details and charm. Inside, you'll find spacious living areas enhanced by fresh paint throughout, updated flooring, new windows, a new furnace, and a newer roof, providing peace of mind while preserving the home's historic appeal. Truly move-in ready, all that's left to do is unpack and enjoy. The home features generous living and entertaining spaces, including a formal dining room highlighted by built-in shelving and cabinetry, adding warmth, character, and functionality. A bright greenhouse/sunroom provides the perfect space for plants, morning coffee, reading, or relaxing year-round. The primary bedroom includes its own convenient half bath, while the five-bedroom layout offers flexibility for family, guests, home offices, or hobby spaces. An outstanding bonus is the detached garage apartment, currently generating $950 per month in rental income, creating an excellent opportunity to offset expenses, accommodate guests, or add investment value. Located in the heart of charming Allegany, you'll enjoy a walkable lifestyle with easy access to St. Bonaventure University, local shops, restaurants, parks, and village amenities. Homes offering this combination of historic character, modern updates, outdoor living spaces, and income potential are rare. Move right in and enjoy all this exceptional property has to offer!

75 E Main Street, Allegany

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1703233 MLS

Discover the comfort and convenience of this well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath double-wide home featuring a unique floor plan designed for both functionality and flexibility. Thoughtfully designed with handicap accessibility in mind, this home offers spacious living areas and an easy-flow layout that accommodates a variety of lifestyles. Enjoy the versatility of two separate living rooms, providing plenty of space for entertaining, relaxing, or creating a home office or hobby area. The generously sized kitchen offers ample cabinetry and counter space, making meal preparation and gatherings a breeze. The primary suite features a private full bath, while two additional bedrooms and another full bath provide comfortable accommodations for family or guests. A convenient half bath adds extra functionality for everyday living and can easily be converted back into a closet if desired. Step outside and enjoy the home's three decks, offering multiple spaces for outdoor entertaining or peaceful relaxation. One deck features a handicap-accessible ramp, providing easy access to the home. With abundant natural light, comfortable single-level living, and a layout that offers both accessibility and flexibility, this property is ready to welcome its next owner. Schedule your private showing today and discover all this unique home has to offer! Must be approved into the park. Sellers need time to find suitable housing.

4115 S Nine Mile Rd Lot 187, Allegany

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1699420 MLS

Nestled on 2.57 acres just outside the Village of Allegany, this well-built ranch home offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and breathtaking country views. Set in a peaceful setting surrounded by rolling hills and mountains, you'll enjoy stunning scenery from both the spacious living room and dining area through the home's numerous windows that fill the space with natural light and invite in the refreshing country breeze. The thoughtfully designed floor plan features three bedrooms and two full baths, along with convenient first-floor laundry and a dedicated office space ideal for working from home or managing daily tasks. The spacious kitchen is a standout with an abundance of cabinetry and generous counter space, making meal preparation and entertaining a breeze. All bedrooms offer spacious closets for ample storage, while the primary suite boasts a large walk-in closet with room for everything you need. A full basement provides endless possibilities for additional living space, recreation, a workshop, or storage. If you're looking for quality construction, beautiful views, and a private country setting just minutes from village amenities, this property is one you won't want to miss.

2456 Keim Hollow Road, Allegany

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1697031 MLS

Exceptional opportunities await with this truly one-of-a-kind multi-use estate situated on approximately 6 picturesque acres. At the heart of the property is a stunning, completely updated 4,020-square-foot luxury residence where timeless natural woodwork meets sophisticated modern design. Meticulously maintained and beautifully decorated throughout, this remarkable home offers an impressive blend of warmth, elegance, and functionality. The heart of the home is an extraordinary 1,000+ square-foot open-concept living area that seamlessly combines the kitchen, Dining room, 2 living rooms, each with their own cozy fireplace. Anchored by a 3rd fireplace, the sunroom invites you to enjoy every season in comfort while overlooking the peaceful surroundings. Just outside, a welcoming covered porch provides the perfect setting to unwind after a long day, grill with friends, or simply relax and enjoy the country atmosphere. The second floor offers four exceptionally spacious bedrooms, each thoughtfully designed with generous 4' x 6' closets. The luxurious primary suite is truly a retreat of its own, spanning approximately 550 square feet and featuring soaring 12-foot cathedral ceilings, a breathtaking two-person walk-in stone shower, and an extraordinary walk-in closet complete with its own dressing room and built-in bureau. For added convenience, the laundry room is also located on the second floor. Continue to the third floor where a charming loft provides flexible space for a private office, creative studio, media room, or playroom. The full basement, complete with radiant heated floors and partially finished living space, offers endless possibilities for recreation, fitness, hobbies, or additional entertaining. Every detail of this exceptional home reflects quality craftsmanship, thoughtful updates, and pride of ownership. Whether you're searching for a luxurious private residence, a family compound, or the centerpiece of a larger business or investment opportunity, this extraordinary property delivers an unmatched combination of comfort, elegance, and versatility. MLS #R1697048 and R1697184 for more details on the other buildings and land.

2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1697184 MLS

Rarely does a property of this caliber become available! Situated on approximately 6 picturesque acres, this extraordinary multi-use estate offers the perfect combination of luxury living, business opportunities, and income potential. Whether you're an entrepreneur, investor, or looking for a private family compound, the possibilities are endless. The centerpiece is a stunning, completely updated 4,020 sq. ft. home showcasing beautiful natural woodwork and modern finishes throughout. The heart of the home features an incredible 1,000+ sq. ft. open-concept kitchen, formal dining area, two living rooms, and a four-season sunroom, all warmed by three cozy fireplaces. Step outside to a welcoming covered porch, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Upstairs you'll find four spacious bedrooms, each with generous 4' x 6' closets. The spectacular 550 sq. ft. primary suite boasts 12' cathedral ceilings, a luxurious two-person 4' x 8' walk-in shower, an oversized walk-in closet complete with its own dressing room and built-in bureau, plus the convenience of a second-floor laundry room. A third-floor loft makes an ideal office, studio, or playroom, while the full basement with radiant heated floors and partially finished space offers endless possibilities. Beyond the home, this remarkable estate includes a separate five-station beauty salon, two detached income-producing rental buildings, a large five-bay automotive repair shop, a magnificent two-story timber-frame barn with exceptional craftsmanship, and an additional storage barn. Whether you choose to operate your own businesses, generate multiple rental incomes, expand your investment portfolio, or simply enjoy the privacy and versatility of this incredible property, opportunities like this are exceptionally rare. Luxury, craftsmanship, income potential, and endless possibilities—all in one unforgettable property. For more info and pictures for the entire property, see Mls #R1697031, #R1697048, R1697184

2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany

Start Your Search