Allegany Real Estate

Allegany Real Estate

Allegany: A Charming Town in Cattaraugus County, NY

Nestled in the heart of Cattaraugus County, New York, lies the picturesque town of Allegany. Known for its small-town charm and natural beauty, Allegany offers a peaceful and welcoming community for residents and visitors alike.

One of the first things that will strike you about Allegany is its stunning surroundings. Surrounded by rolling hills and lush forests, this town is a nature lover's paradise. From hiking and biking trails to fishing and boating opportunities, outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty to explore in Allegany's scenic landscapes.

Allegany is also home to a vibrant community that takes pride in its rich history and cultural heritage. The town boasts a variety of historical landmarks, including the Allegany Area Historical Association Museum, where visitors can learn about the town's past and its significance in the region.

In terms of amenities, Allegany offers a range of local shops, restaurants, and services to meet residents' daily needs. The town also benefits from its close proximity to nearby cities, making it convenient for commuters or those looking for additional entertainment options.

For families, Allegany is served by the Allegany-Limestone Central School District, providing quality education for students of all ages. The town also hosts various community events throughout the year, fostering a strong sense of unity and camaraderie among its residents.

Whether you're seeking a peaceful place to call home or a charming destination to visit, Allegany has something for everyone. With its natural beauty, rich history, and welcoming community, Allegany is truly a hidden gem in Cattaraugus County, New York.

Newest Listings in Allegany

3869 South Nine Mile, Allegany
$215,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723713 MLS
Welcome to 3869 South Nine Mile Road! This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom ranch combines comfortable one-floor living, extensive recent updates, and a fantastic Allegany location. Situated on a spacious 0.62-acre lot in the Allegany-Limestone School District, this move-in-ready home offers an attached garage, a generous yard, and an extra parcel across the road bordering the Allegany River! Step inside to discover freshly painted walls and ceilings in every room, beautiful hardwood floors, and abundant natural light from vinyl replacement windows. Recent improvements include an updated bathroom, new hot water tank, new oven and range hood fan, new entryway flooring, and new window shades, with bedroom shades planned for installation. The welcoming floor plan features three bedrooms, a spacious living room, an eat-in kitchen, and convenient first-floor laundry. Additional highlights include 200-amp electrical service updated in 2024 and an updated water softener. Outside, low-maintenance vinyl siding, gutter guards, a concrete driveway, and an attached garage make everyday upkeep easier. Enjoy the open yard or head across the road to the additional riverfront parcel, an appealing spot for fishing, kayaking, or simply taking in the scenery. The location puts you approximately 3 miles from St. Bonaventure University, 12 miles from Allegany State Park, and 19 miles from Ellicottville, with convenient access to shopping, dining, outdoor recreation, and year-round activities. Whether you’re looking for your first home, downsizing, or seeking a Western New York getaway, this thoughtfully refreshed ranch is ready to welcome you home!

3869 South Nine Mile, Allegany
3033 W State Street, Allegany
$225,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1723543 MLS
This property is located within a block of major commercial properties that include Walmart, Home Depot, BJ's Wholesale Club, Tim Horton's, Starbuck's, Applebees, Aspen Dental and several other national chains including new national chains currently under construction. This a great investment with the possibility of acquiring the three neighboring properties totaling approximately 1.60 acres one of them being a corner lot.

3033 W State Street, Allegany
3027 Nys Route 417, Allegany
$195,000
R1723940 MLS
Great location for your business. This building with over 4,000 square feet is located near a large shopping center and is situated on a corner lot. There is a small office area and plenty warehouse storage. The building has two 8' overhead doors for easy access. There is plenty of room for vehicle storage fro approximately 20 cars. The building has a three phase electric wiring service if you need the extra power. This property is located within a block of major commercial properties that include Walmart, Home Depot, BJ's Wholesale Club, Tim Horton's, Applebees, Starbuck's, Aspen Dental and several other national chains including new national chains currently under construction. This a great investment with the three neighboring properties totaling approximately 1.60 acres one of them being a corner lot. Directions: On the corner of Route 417 & Allegany Street

3027 Nys Route 417, Allegany
179 N 2nd Street, Allegany
$179,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1722865 MLS
Welcome to 179 N 2nd Street, a solid 1963 ranch on a quiet neighborhood cul-de-sac in the Village of Allegany. Offering 1,674 sq ft of true one-level living, this 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath home sits on a 0.28-acre rectangular lot (75 x 160) and is ready for its next chapter. The heart of the home is the eat-in kitchen, featuring an island with a built-in electric cooktop, a breakfast bar, a built-in wall oven, and plenty of cabinet space. It opens to a warm, knotty pine family room with exposed beams, a wood-burning brick fireplace with mantel, built-in cabinetry, and a large bay window overlooking the yard. Three first-floor bedrooms with ceiling fans, two full baths, and a convenient first-floor laundry room make everyday living easy. Outside, enjoy a covered porch, deck, and patio, plus an attached 1-car garage with an opener and a blacktop driveway. The full poured basement offers excellent storage or room to expand. Public water and sewer, gas forced-air heat, a gas water heater, and high-speed internet. Located in the Allegany-Limestone School District, just minutes from Route 417, St. Bonaventure, and everything Olean has to offer. With great bones and a fantastic location, this home is a wonderful opportunity to add your personal touches and build equity. Schedule your showing today!

179 N 2nd Street, Allegany
3212 Buffalo Road, Allegany
$450,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1722104 MLS
Unique Stone Home with Character, Space & Endless Entertaining Possibilities! Step into a home where timeless charm meets room to spread out and enjoy! This distinctive 5-bedroom, 2-full-bath stone home offers character, warmth, and an abundance of space both inside and out. The remodeled kitchen provides a fresh, inviting feel, with a full bath conveniently located just off the kitchen. A formal dining room, office, living room, and charming parlor offer plenty of options for everyday living, entertaining, or working from home. A wonderful family room addition takes entertaining to the next level, featuring a gas fireplace, bar, and plenty of room for a pool table and large or small gatherings . Upstairs, you'll find spacious bedrooms and a full bath featuring a classic clawfoot tub with shower. Double staircases add to the home's unique character and appeal. Enjoy your morning coffee or unwind in the evening on the inviting covered front porch, or head to the back deck overlooking the beautiful, park-like yard. The outdoor amenities offer something for everyone, including an above-ground pool, a pavilion perfect for covered picnics and gatherings, and an outbuilding with a greenhouse for gardening enthusiasts. The detached garage offers ample space for two vehicles or a fifth-wheel camper. An additional one-car garage sits alongside a metal building with attic storage and space suitable for chickens or other small animals, making this property an appealing option for those dreaming of a homestead lifestyle. If you're looking for a home with distinctive character, generous living space, and room to entertain, garden, and enjoy the outdoors, this one-of-a-kind property is ready to capture your imagination!

3212 Buffalo Road, Allegany
111 W Main Street, Allegany
$139,000
7 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1714952 MLS
Excellent investment opportunity in the heart of Allegany, NY, just minutes from St. Bonaventure University! This well-located 4-unit property offers strong rental potential, ideal for student housing or long-term tenants. Each unit provides functional living space with separate entrances, making it attractive for a variety of rental strategies. Situated in a high-demand rental area, this property benefits from consistent occupancy driven by proximity to the university, local amenities, and downtown Allegany. Whether you're looking to expand your portfolio or start investing, this property offers great income potential with upside through improved rents or updates. Don’t miss your chance to own a multi-unit in a prime location!

111 W Main Street, Allegany
114 N 3rd Street, Allegany
$189,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1714540 MLS
Welcome to this spacious 4-bedroom, 3-full-bath home located in the highly desirable Village of Allegany! Offering a versatile layout with plenty of room for family and guests, this home combines comfort, convenience, and functionality. The first floor features a bright eat-in kitchen with direct access to the covered patio, perfect for morning coffee, outdoor dining, or entertaining. Just off the kitchen is a welcoming living room offering plenty of space to relax and gather. The first-floor primary suite provides added privacy and convenience with an en suite bathroom featuring a Jacuzzi tub, dual 5-foot walk-in shower, and double vanity. With a second primary suite located upstairs, the first-floor suite also offers great flexibility and could easily be converted into additional living space, a family room, home office, or whatever best suits your needs. First-floor laundry and an attached 2-car garage add even more everyday convenience. Upstairs you'll find three generously sized bedrooms, including the second primary suite with its own private full bathroom—an excellent setup for guests, extended family, or multi-generational living. An additional full bathroom serves the remaining bedrooms. Other highlights include a 3-zone hot water boiler system for customizable heating, durable vinyl siding, and a low-maintenance metal roof. Conveniently located near schools, parks, shopping, and everything the Village of Allegany has to offer, this home provides an impressive amount of space, flexibility, and functionality in a great location.

114 N 3rd Street, Allegany
2615 N Nine Mile, Allegany
$50,000
R1700800 MLS
Land Only. Great hunting, secluded, excellent entry road. See highlighted area on map attached. But a survey has been ordered to outline exactly what part of the parcel is for sale. 16.6 acres of land has not been assessed without the homestead. Timber rights included. Oil and gas rights negotiable.

2615 N Nine Mile, Allegany
2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany
$1,500,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1697031 MLS
Exceptional opportunities await with this truly one-of-a-kind multi-use estate situated on approximately 6 picturesque acres. At the heart of the property is a stunning, completely updated 4,020-square-foot luxury residence where timeless natural woodwork meets sophisticated modern design. Meticulously maintained and beautifully decorated throughout, this remarkable home offers an impressive blend of warmth, elegance, and functionality. The heart of the home is an extraordinary 1,000+ square-foot open-concept living area that seamlessly combines the kitchen, Dining  room, 2  living rooms, each with their own  cozy fireplace.   Anchored by a 3rd fireplace, the sunroom invites you to enjoy every season in comfort while overlooking the peaceful surroundings. Just outside, a welcoming covered porch provides the perfect setting to unwind after a long day, grill with friends, or simply relax and enjoy the country atmosphere. The second floor offers four exceptionally spacious bedrooms, each thoughtfully designed with generous 4' x 6' closets. The luxurious primary suite is truly a retreat of its own, spanning approximately 550 square feet and featuring soaring 12-foot cathedral ceilings, a breathtaking two-person walk-in stone shower, and an extraordinary walk-in closet complete with its own dressing room and built-in bureau. For added convenience, the laundry room is also located on the second floor. Continue to the third floor where a charming loft provides flexible space for a private office, creative studio, media room, or  playroom. The full basement, complete with radiant heated floors and partially finished living space, offers endless possibilities for recreation, fitness, hobbies, or additional entertaining. Every detail of this exceptional home reflects quality craftsmanship, thoughtful updates, and pride of ownership. Whether you're searching for a luxurious private residence, a family compound, or the centerpiece of a larger business or investment opportunity, this extraordinary property delivers an unmatched combination of comfort, elegance, and versatility. MLS #R1697048 and R1697184 for more details on the other buildings and land.

2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany
2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany
$1,500,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1697184 MLS
Rarely does a property of this caliber become available! Situated on approximately 6 picturesque acres, this extraordinary multi-use estate offers the perfect combination of luxury living, business opportunities, and income potential. Whether you're an entrepreneur, investor, or looking for a private family compound, the possibilities are endless. The centerpiece is a stunning, completely updated 4,020 sq. ft. home showcasing beautiful natural woodwork and modern finishes throughout. The heart of the home features an incredible 1,000+ sq. ft. open-concept kitchen, formal dining area, two living rooms, and a four-season sunroom, all warmed by three cozy fireplaces. Step outside to a welcoming covered porch, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Upstairs you'll find four spacious bedrooms, each with generous 4' x 6' closets. The spectacular 550 sq. ft. primary suite boasts 12' cathedral ceilings, a luxurious two-person 4' x 8' walk-in shower, an oversized walk-in closet complete with its own dressing room and built-in bureau, plus the convenience of a second-floor laundry room. A third-floor loft makes an ideal office, studio, or playroom, while the full basement with radiant heated floors and partially finished space offers endless possibilities. Beyond the home, this remarkable estate includes a separate five-station beauty salon, two detached income-producing rental buildings, a large five-bay automotive repair shop, a magnificent two-story timber-frame barn with exceptional craftsmanship, and an additional storage barn. Whether you choose to operate your own businesses, generate multiple rental incomes, expand your investment portfolio, or simply enjoy the privacy and versatility of this incredible property, opportunities like this are exceptionally rare. Luxury, craftsmanship, income potential, and endless possibilities—all in one unforgettable property. For more info and pictures for the entire property, see Mls #R1697031, #R1697048, R1697184

2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany
2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany
$1,500,000
R1697048 MLS
Rarely does a property with this level of versatility become available! Situated on approximately 6 picturesque acres, this extraordinary multi-use estate offers an exceptional combination of luxury living, established business space, rental income potential, and room for future vision. Ideal for an entrepreneur, investor, live/work buyer, or someone seeking multiple income streams, this property brings residential, commercial, and investment opportunities together in one impressive setting. Beyond the residence, the property includes a separate five-station beauty salon, two detached income-producing rental buildings, a large five-bay automotive repair shop, a magnificent two-story timber-frame barn with exceptional craftsmanship, and an additional storage barn. Whether continuing the current uses, operating your own businesses, expanding an investment portfolio, or exploring future concepts such as event, hospitality, retreat, agritourism, or other business uses, the possibilities are extensive. The centerpiece is a stunning 4,020 sq. ft. home showcasing beautiful natural woodwork and modern finishes throughout. The heart of the home features an incredible 1,000+ sq. ft. open-concept kitchen, formal dining area, two living rooms, and a four-season sunroom, all warmed by three cozy fireplaces. Step outside to a welcoming covered porch, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Upstairs you’ll find four spacious bedrooms, each with generous 4' x 6' closets. The spectacular 550 sq. ft. primary suite boasts 12' cathedral ceilings, a luxurious two-person 4' x 8' walk-in shower, an oversized walk-in closet with dressing room and built-in bureau, plus the convenience of second-floor laundry. A third-floor loft makes an ideal office, studio, or flex space, while the full basement with radiant heated floors and partially finished space offers even more opportunity. Luxury, craftsmanship, business potential, income opportunity, and endless possibilities—all in one unforgettable property. Buyer to verify zoning, permitted uses, occupancy, and intended use. See also MLS #R1697031, #R1697048, #R1697184.

2715 Five Mile Road, Allegany
122 E Union Street, Allegany
$159,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1692130 MLS
This Move-In ready 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath two-story home located in the Village of Allegany! Conveniently situated within walking distance of St. Bonaventure University, scenic walking trails, and downtown amenities, this home with updates and newer kitchen appliances offers character and endless potential. Inside, you'll find beautiful original woodwork and hardwood floors that showcase the home's timeless appeal. The cozy interior provides an excellent opportunity to update and customize to fit your personal style while preserving its classic charm. Outside, enjoy a generous lawn and backyard—perfect for family gatherings, outdoor entertaining, or simply relaxing. Well maintained and full of possibilities, this home is ready for its next owner to make it their own. Don't miss this opportunity to own this home in a desirable location!

122 E Union Street, Allegany
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!