Carroll Homes for Sale

Carroll Homes for Sale

Carroll: A Quaint Town in Chautauqua County, NY

Nestled in the scenic county of Chautauqua, New York, lies the charming town of Carroll. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Carroll offers a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life. With a variety of homes for sale, this idyllic town presents a great opportunity for those seeking a tranquil place to call home.

Carroll boasts a rich history, evident in its well-preserved architecture and historic landmarks. The town's close-knit community takes pride in its heritage, organizing local events and festivals that showcase the area's unique culture. From exploring the Carroll Historical Society Museum to strolling through the charming downtown area, there's always something to discover in this quaint town.

For nature enthusiasts, Carroll offers an abundance of outdoor activities. The town is surrounded by beautiful parks, hiking trails, and lakes, providing endless opportunities for recreation and relaxation. Whether you enjoy fishing, boating, or simply taking in the breathtaking views, Carroll's natural beauty will captivate you.

As for the real estate market, Carroll has a range of homes for sale to suit various needs and preferences. From cozy cottages to spacious family homes, there's something for everyone. The town's real estate market is known for its affordability and value, making it an attractive option for first-time buyers and those looking to invest in a peaceful community.

In conclusion, Carroll, located in Chautauqua County, NY, offers a unique blend of small-town charm and natural beauty. With its rich history, friendly community, and diverse real estate options, Carroll presents an ideal opportunity for those seeking a peaceful and picturesque place to call home.

Newest Carroll Homes for Sale

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1713200 MLS

Welcome to 267 Bragg Road! This beautiful country home has only had one owner and is looking for the next buyer to call it home! With 1.7 acres of land, it sits cozily on the hillside, showcasing the beautiful views of Chautauqua County. The main level has an inviting feel, with an open concept between the living room and kitchen. The granite counter tops, stainless steel appliances and electric fireplace, makes this space perfect for everyday living and entertaining guests. The 2023 home also features large windows that showcase the natural light and the best views of the surrounding landscape. Continuing to the back of the home, you can find the primary bedroom with an on-suite full bathroom,walk-in shower and large walk-in closet. Stay warm in the colder months with the pellet stove and multiple smart wall heaters that are already affixed to the walls in the bathrooms, primary bedroom and the lower living area. The lower level features a wet bar, complete with a sink, cabinets and a fridge. A full bathroom with laundry hookups and a utility closet, and a finished area that is currently being utilized as a den/office completes the basement. Walking out the front door, you'll find the inviting covered concrete patio, which is great for relaxing and entertaining. This home has appropriate egress for this to be a full primary bedroom, in-law suite, or a possible investment property, with minimal work needed to separate the two levels. An 8X10 storage shed comes with the property for extra outdoor storage space. Located in the Frewsburg School District, it is in between the Kinzua Resevoir and Chautauqua Lake, minutes from game lands, and less than an hour from Holiday Valley Ski Resort! 267 Bragg Road is waiting for you to make it your next place to call home, vacation home, hunting camp or investment property! **Delayed Showings & Negotiations until Saturday, September 12, 2026 at 11 AM.**

267 Bragg Road, Carroll

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1711593 MLS

Here’s your chance to own a unique property with acreage in Frewsburg. Set on over 8 acres in the country, this home is only a short drive from town. The home may have a small footprint, but inside, it is packed with features. The main living space has a kitchen and a living room, allowing for seamless entertaining. The kitchen has an island that provides extra workspace and doubles as a dining table. The bedroom and full bathroom are on opposite sides of the hallway, offering privacy. The bathroom has a whirlpool tub and an NSF-certified composting (burning) toilet. Outside, a barn and 8 acres of land offer room to explore. This unique property could be used for year-round living or as a weekend retreat. The current owner uses this as an Airbnb.

628 Warren Road, Carroll

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1711602 MLS

If you’re dreaming of starting over in the countryside, this might be the home for you! Set on approximately 28 acres in Frewsburg, this four-bedroom home offers the peace and tranquility of country living. Inside, the home has a thoughtfully laid out kitchen with solid surface countertops and a bonus breakfast bar. There is a formal dining room with views into the yard, and a cozy living room with a ceiling fan to help circulate the country air. There is a bedroom on the main floor, and a full bath. Upstairs, there are three more bedrooms. Outside, there is a covered front porch for enjoying quiet conversation with guests, and an abundance of space to add a fire pit or other seating areas if you so desire. There are approximately 28 acres of property to explore; there is a pond, plenty of areas to make ATV or walking trails, and endless space to garden.

757 Page Road, Carroll

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1712533 MLS

Welcome to this Spacious Cap Cod home attached garage nestled on 1.8 acres of very well maintained and landscaped lot in Frewsburg. Offering 3 Bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, approximately 2650 sq. ft. of living space, plus a 1,000 sq. ft. finished basement, this home has room for everyone. inside you'll find an updated kitchen, and baths, beautiful hardwood floors throughout most of the first floor. Charming woodwork trim through out, along with tongue n groove ceilings in the upstairs quarters. Head down stairs to the finished basement that offers additional living space with two stair access points, including one directly from the attached garage, Enjoy relaxing or entertaining outdoors from the covered patio and deck, with easy access from the foyer. The 26 x 24 Detached garage with additional second-floor storage is perfect for vehicles, hobbies, a workshop, or all your storage needs. A truly versatile property that combines space , comfort, and functionality in a great Frewsburg location.

545 Warren Road, Carroll

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ R1711342 MLS

Stunning home on 14± acres with a pond, 4,192± sq ft of living space, and a full barn/workshop perfect for equipment, hobbies, or business use. Inside you’ll find a high-end kitchen, multiple living areas, 5 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, a 3-seasons room, and a partially finished basement with rec room and bonus spaces. The primary suite features a walk-in closet, clawfoot tub, and walk-in shower. Modern mechanicals throughout: Viessmann boiler, Generac 17kW generator, Powerworx energy system, security + sprinklers, 200-amp service, poured foundation, vinyl siding, blacktop drive, and paver patio. The barn offers concrete floors, 100-amp service, water, and multiple overhead doors — plus upper-level storage with ground-level access. A rare combination of land, space, and infrastructure in Frewsburg. Selling in an online auction on petersonauction.com. The complete Terms & Conditions of the auction are available on our website and the bidding platform. Bidding is open 9/21/2026 - 9/24/2026. There is a public open house on Tuesday, September 15th 9AM-12PM and Friday, September 18th 4PM-6PM.

100 Tiffany Lane, Carroll

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1698786 MLS

Cute and cozy three-bedroom ranch home in the ‘burg. This home is tucked away on a side street and is within walking distance of both schools and dining options. Inside, practicality and comfort abound with single-level living. The main entry point is through the front door and into the living room, which features a bay window that looks out into the front yard. Just off the living room is the formal dining room with sliding glass doors into the three-seasons room. The three-seasons room looks out over the back yard, the exposed beams give the room an expansive and grand feel, this room will be your favorite place to watch the seasons change. The eat-in kitchen has plenty of storage space, including a clever built-in bread box and a pantry cupboard. The room is spacious enough to add in a small dining table or a breakfast nook. The home has a total of three bedrooms, all offering closet space. The full basement is partially finished, with a bar room to expand your options for hosting. The basement also has a workshop space with multiple surfaces to support a project of nearly any scale. The home has an attached one-car garage, and there is also a shed in the backyard to store your lawn care equipment. The back yard is currently lush with summer greenery, and there is an almost-hidden pergola just behind the house, imagine adding a seating area here, it would be your favorite place to relax after a long day.

4 E Meadow Lane, Carroll

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1697624 MLS

Exquisite contemporary ranch home in Frewsburg. Inside, the home features single-level living with a total of four bedrooms and two full baths on the primary floor. The galley-style kitchen is thoughtfully laid out with bright natural light from the skylight. The living room has a fireplace with stone masonry and a tastefully vibrant, but relaxing color palette. The formal dining room is located between the kitchen and the living room, providing a natural flow for entertaining. The primary bedroom has an ensuite bath and a generous closet. The basement is partially finished and does have an egress door. The finished part of the basement serves as a recreation space, but would also work as a home gym or a game room, perfect for entertaining. There is a bonus storage room in the basement. Outside, the home has a two-car carport, and the backyard has a patio for enjoying the temperate weather. There is a shed to store lawn care equipment, and there are planters for the aspiring gardener. This unique home has many upgrades, including central A/C, a radon mitigation system, and a water softener, adding value and comfort to an already attractive property.

16 Mattison Street, Carroll

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1697610 MLS

Spacious home on a generous 3/4-acre lot in the heart of Frewsburg. Set on a gorgeous tree-lined lot, this home captures the feeling of country living right in the cozy suburbs. On the back of the house is an oversized family room that would be great for entertaining. Inside, the main floor features a formal dining room and a roomy eat-in, country kitchen offering clever hidden storage drawers in the baseboards and a fireplace. The living room also has a fireplace, built-in storage, and recessed lighting. The family room features another fireplace and baseboard heat, but also banks of windows that look out over the backyard, bringing in natural light and a touch of the outdoors. There is a first-floor bedroom that could also serve as an office or hobby space. The main floor offers a full bath and a convenient laundry room. Upstairs, there is another full bath and two more bedrooms. The primary bedroom has two large walk-in closets. One of the closets shares a wall with the other bedroom, and that wall could potentially be removed to split the other bedroom into two. The home is equipped with central A/C and forced air heat for year-round comfort. Outside, the detached garage has three work bays and workshop space available. PLEASE LOOK AT THE ADDITIONAL SELLER INFO SHEET for updates to the property.

62 Ivory Street, Carroll

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1691398 MLS

Move-in ready three-bedroom ranch in the ‘burg! Set on a side street off Ivory, this home is in the heart of Frewsburg. The schools are within walking distance, along with the public library and various dining options. The home is heated with hot-water baseboard heat and also has a separate forced-air Central A/C system. Inside, the home has a spacious living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a built-in curio cabinet, and a large picture window bringing in warm, natural light. The eat-in kitchen has a breakfast bar and a pantry, with space to add a small dining table or a breakfast nook. The formal dining room features French doors onto the patio for seamless entertaining. The primary bedroom is large, with two closets and an en-suite bath. The full basement is partially finished, there is a spacious recreation room with a bar and a second wood-burning fireplace, such a great space for entertaining guests! The unfinished part of the basement offers more storage space and workshop space. Outside, the home has an attached two-car garage with water service. The home is set on a double lot, giving you plenty of space to plant a garden or host summertime barbecues. The current owner has just put on a new roof, and a brand-new septic system will be installed prior to closing. List agent is related to seller.

10 Durand Street, Carroll

Start Your Search