Eagle Homes for Sale

Eagle Homes for Sale

Welcome to Eagle, a charming city nestled in Wyoming County, New York. Known for its scenic beauty and friendly community, Eagle offers a tranquil and idyllic setting for those seeking a peaceful place to call home.

With a variety of homes for sale, Eagle caters to diverse preferences and budgets. Whether you're looking for a cozy cottage, a spacious family home, or a luxurious estate, you're sure to find the perfect property to suit your needs.

Eagle's real estate market boasts a range of options, from historic properties with character and charm to modern, newly constructed homes with all the latest amenities. Many homes in Eagle also feature large yards, perfect for outdoor activities and enjoying the picturesque surroundings.

Living in Eagle means having access to a wide array of recreational opportunities. Nature lovers will appreciate the nearby state parks and hiking trails, offering breathtaking views of the surrounding countryside. The area is also home to several lakes, providing opportunities for boating, fishing, and other water activities.

Eagle's convenient location allows residents to enjoy a peaceful rural lifestyle while still being within easy reach of urban amenities. The city is just a short drive away from larger towns and cities, offering shopping, dining, and entertainment options.

If you're searching for a place that combines natural beauty, a close-knit community, and a range of housing options, look no further than Eagle, NY. Discover the homes for sale in this charming city and start your journey to finding your dream home today.

Newest Eagle Homes for Sale

3428 Garry Road, Eagle
$109,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1722977 MLS
*Your Own Country Retreat with a Private Pond and Over an Acre of Land!* Looking for peaceful country living, a weekend getaway, or a place to make your own? This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home at 3428 Garry Road offers a beautiful natural setting, a picturesque pond, and plenty of room to relax and enjoy the outdoors. Situated on approximately *1.15 acres across two parcels*, the property features a spacious wraparound covered porch overlooking the grounds—perfect for morning coffee, summer evenings, or simply taking in the scenery. The expansive yard, mature trees, and detached two-car garage provide plenty of space for outdoor activities, hobbies, storage, and entertaining. Inside, you'll find a comfortable living room, eat-in kitchen, two main-level bedrooms, and convenient laundry facilities. The home is livable and offers an opportunity to make cosmetic improvements and personalize the space over time. Recent improvements include a *metal roof installed approximately two years ago*, well servicing in 2023, and a water filtration system. A natural gas-powered backup generator provides additional peace of mind, while the walkout lower level offers useful storage and utility space. Whether you're looking for an affordable primary residence, a peaceful weekend escape, or a country property with room for your own ideas, this home offers an appealing combination of natural beauty, practical features, and potential. *Offered at $109,900. Come see the views, explore the grounds, and experience this unique setting for yourself!*

3428 Garry Road, Eagle
3919 Wing Street, Eagle
$675,000
6 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1722438 MLS
If you’ve been looking for space, privacy, and a simpler way of life, without sacrificing comfort, this 50.58-acre property delivers. The 3,324 sq. ft. custom-built home offers 6 generously sized bedrooms and 2 full baths, with large, open living areas designed for everyday life and meaningful gatherings. The spacious kitchen flows naturally into the dining area and living room, creating a warm central hub of the home. Downstairs, a substantial basement provides abundant storage. Step outside and the property truly opens up. Wide fields, wooded areas, and a newly dug pond with shed create a setting that feels private, usable, and deeply connected to the land. Whether it’s gardening, outdoor recreation, animals, or simply enjoying the quiet, there’s room here to live at your own pace. The outbuildings add incredible versatility: Barn 1: 2,176 SF (32’ x 68’) - Ideal for equipment, animals, storage, or workshop use. Barn 2: 5,000 SF (50’ x 100’) plus 300 SF addition - High ceilings, concrete floors, overhead doors, and a ~14’ x 80’ one-bedroom, one-bath apartment. Over 6,400 SF of greenhouse space, operational and ready for continued use, hobby growing, or homestead expansion. Unlike many rural properties, this one offers both scale and functionality, ample living space, substantial barns and shop areas, and acreage that supports a truly self-sufficient lifestyle. Whether you envision gardening year-round, working on projects in a true shop space, raising animals, or simply enjoying wide-open skies and quiet evenings, this property offers the space and infrastructure to make it happen. Note: The actual square footage differs from public record. The source of the actual square footage is from the building plans.

3919 Wing Street, Eagle
6865 Centerville Rd, Eagle
$575,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1720440 MLS
So much to say about this gorgeous property! 8 acres of pristine property, meticulously maintained, offering the seclusion you are searching for! Enjoy the over 2 acre stocked pond with dock, relax on the multiple decks with the pond view. Have horses, want horses? Two story barn with 6 horse stalls leading to the pasture area. Shed for even more storage. Enter into the bright windowed mudroom and then into the plentiful cherry cabinet kitchen with large breakfast bar open to a dining/living area which leads to one of the many decks. Formal living room also and extra large primary suite with doors to your private hot tub deck! Walk out finished basement in this hillside home with generous family room area leading to another outdoor living space. 3 full baths in this home! Stay cozy warm with two pellet stoves and one wood burning stove. Multi zoned Hot water baseboard propane heat as well. The location offers views and privacy! A must see!

6865 Centerville Rd, Eagle
3051 Wing Street, Eagle
$440,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1713788 MLS
Stunning Cedar A-Frame retreat on just under 10 acres is waiting for you to call it home! Discover the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort in this meticulously maintained 2208 sq ft A-frame home. Thie property offers a rare opportunity for a peaceful living environment with a versatile space for guests or hobbies. The homes core is crafted from premium Western Red Cedar imported from Canada providing a timeless, warm aesthetic. The property was thoughtfully expanded in 2016 with high-quality White Cedar additions adding a formal dining room and 3 bedrooms. This home offers 3 generous bedrooms including a convenient main level bedroom, a primary bedroom with a full bath and a second full bath on the first floor. The newly updated kitchen is open to the main living area providing the perfect space for togetherness! The outbuilding/garage offers a converted cottage unique to this property. Fully insulated with its own electric service providing a perfect spot for guests, an in-law apartment or hobby area. There are two small ponds on the property that do need a bit of attention, but beautiful nonetheless! This property is a must see of those seeking privacy, character and move in ready convenience!

3051 Wing Street, Eagle
2979 Wing Street Unit B, Eagle
$249,900
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1706691 MLS
Combining modern comfort, peaceful surroundings, and plenty of space to enjoy every season, this beautifully remodeled home sits on 2 acres in Bliss NY, Wyoming County, and features a pond and detached garage. This A-frame home has been completely remodeled and is located on a peaceful, private lot, making it an ideal full-time residence or seasonal getaway. The home has new electric wiring, new plumbing, a new roof, a fresh interior, and fresh paint on a lot of the decking. The property is located several hundred feet off the road and is accessed by a deeded driveway. As you enter the property, there is a pond with a new dock and fountain. The front porch overlooks the pond, while the back deck overlooks the fireplace and large lawn. There is also an enclosed netting area on the deck that could be used for eating outside or just enjoying the property. Inside, the entire house has been remodeled with a new kitchen, appliances, bathroom, and living room. The full bathroom is downstairs, while the bedroom and half bathroom are upstairs. There is also a walkout deck off the upstairs bedroom that gives you a nice view of the property and a peaceful place to enjoy the morning. A new split heater has also recently been installed. There is a detached 2-car garage for parking and storage. An ATV side-by-side, tractor, riding lawnmower, and two snowmobiles are also negotiable with the property. The storage container on the property stays. The landowner also receives an annual payment of approximately $2,500 due to the property’s proximity to the windmills. Overall, this is a unique home that has been completely remodeled and offers a private setting with a pond, garage, large lawn, and plenty of outdoor space. It would make a great place to live year-round or use as a seasonal getaway. This property is located 10 minutes from Arcade NY, 27 minutes from Warsaw NY, 20 minutes from Rushford Lake and Java Lake, and 1 Hour from Buffalo NY.

2979 Wing Street Unit B, Eagle
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!