Lancaster Homes under $400,000

Welcome to this spacious, one-owner, 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial situated on a beautiful, tree-lined street in the Village of Lancaster! This well-maintained home offers plenty of space, classic charm, and numerous updates throughout. The first floor features a brand-new kitchen in 2026, complete with a new cooktop and oven, laminate flooring, solid-surface countertops, and includes the refrigerator. The kitchen overlooks the large family room, featuring new carpeting in 2026. A formal dining room just off the kitchen provides the perfect setting for gatherings and entertaining, while the generously sized front living room offers additional space to relax. A convenient half bath and welcoming foyer complete the first floor. Upstairs, you'll find four bedrooms with hardwood floors, along with newly carpeted stairs and hallway, all updated in 2026. The primary bedroom features an en-suite full bath with a brand-new walk-in shower installed in 2026. The main full bath has also been updated with a brand-new tub and surround. Additional features include a full basement with washer and dryer, a new boiler and hot water tank in 2023, and a roof replaced in 2014. Enjoy the outdoors in the fully fenced backyard, complete with a covered patio, or relax on the charming covered front porch. Conveniently located just minutes from the heart of the Village of Lancaster, you'll enjoy easy access to local shops, restaurants, community events, and all the charm this wonderful village has to offer. With its spacious layout, numerous updates, and fantastic location, this Colonial is ready to welcome you home!

129 Albert Drive, Lancaster

$250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1724653 MLS

Charming All-Brick Cape Cod with Separate One-Bedroom Apartment! Don't miss this wonderful 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath all-brick Cape Cod offering charm, versatility, and income potential in the desirable Lancaster School District! The main home features a first-floor bedroom and bath, as well as a 2nd floor 1/2 bath, separate dining room, basement recreation room and a private, fully fenced backyard complete with a hot tub—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Numerous updates include a newer furnace (2022), vinyl replacement windows, glass block windows, updated flooring, a fully fenced yard, and gutter guards with a warranty. An attached storage shed at the rear of the garage provides additional space for all your storage needs. A standout feature is the legal one-bedroom apartment above the garage, complete with its own private entrance, separate utilities, and off-street parking. Currently vacant, the apartment offers an excellent opportunity for rental income. The sellers previously received $950 per month in rent! Refrigerators and stoves are included in both the main home and apartment. Conveniently located near the charming Village of Lancaster, with easy access to local shops, restaurants, schools, and amenities. A fantastic opportunity to enjoy the comforts of homeownership with the added benefit of rental income potential! Open House Sunday, October 25th, 1–3 PM. Also listed as a single family: B1724594.

128 Laverack Ave, Lancaster

$250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1724594 MLS

Charming All-Brick Cape Cod with Separate One-Bedroom Apartment! Don't miss this wonderful 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath all-brick Cape Cod offering charm, versatility, and income potential in the desirable Lancaster School District! The main home features a first-floor bedroom and bath, as well as a 2nd floor 1/2 bath, separate dining room, basement recreation room and a private, fully fenced backyard complete with a hot tub—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Numerous updates include a newer furnace (2022), vinyl replacement windows, glass block windows, updated flooring, a fully fenced yard, and gutter guards with a warranty. An attached storage shed at the rear of the garage provides additional space for all your storage needs. A standout feature is the legal one-bedroom apartment above the garage, complete with its own private entrance, separate utilities, and off-street parking. Currently vacant, the apartment offers an excellent opportunity for rental income. The sellers previously received $950 per month in rent! Refrigerators and stoves are included in both the main home and apartment. Conveniently located near the charming Village of Lancaster, with easy access to local shops, restaurants, schools, and amenities. A fantastic opportunity to enjoy the comforts of homeownership with the added benefit of rental income potential! Open House Sunday, October 25th, 1–3 PM. Also listed as a multi-family: B1724653.

128 Laverack Ave, Lancaster

$169,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1723955 MLS

Welcome to 178 Warsaw, Depew, NY 14043. A home you can sit and enjoy coffee on your adorable front porch or in your private backyard. Located in the desirable Depew-Lancaster area, this home offers 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, and a versatile layout featuring a living room, dining room, and family room and first floor laundry. The family room is highlighted by a vaulted ceiling, adding an open and spacious feel to the living area. With multiple gathering spaces and a convenient location, this property offers a wonderful opportunity to make it your own. Roof under 10 years old and New Windows throughout.

178 Warsaw Street, Lancaster

$229,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723113 MLS

Charming Updated 1887 Home in Depew, NY! Step into the charm of yesteryear with this beautifully updated 1887 home in Depew, NY! Blending timeless character with modern updates, this home offers a unique opportunity to enjoy historic charm with everyday convenience. Located just minutes from the Village of Lancaster’s Main Street, you’ll love the easy access to local shops, restaurants, and community amenities. Outside, enjoy a fully fenced yard with plenty of potential for entertaining, relaxing, gardening, or letting your four-legged friends roam. The garage features both heat and electricity, making it a versatile space for hobbies, projects, storage, or year-round use. Notable updates to this home include Sump Pump 2021, Windows & Sliding Doors 2022, Furnace & AC 2023 & Vinyl Fence 2023, flooring in bedrooms 2026. If you’re looking for a home with history, character, and a convenient location, this charming property is ready to capture your heart! Showings Delayed until the open house on Saturday October 24th at 12PM

190 Warsaw Street, Lancaster

$319,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1724241 MLS

Welcome to this tastefully and beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home in a desirable location! Featuring a great layout and updates throughout, this home truly is move-in ready. The interior boasts a completely renovated kitchen with new appliances, fresh paint, updated flooring throughout, and modern fixtures. Exterior improvements include fresh paint, landscaping, a new extended wide driveway and a fully fenced yard featuring a huge patio and fire pit—perfect for outdoor entertaining and relaxation. Additional highlights include: updated windows, mostly newer mechanicals, a partially finished basement, and a generously sized lot. Meticulously maintained and thoughtfully updated, this home is ready for its next owner to move right in and enjoy all it has to offer! **Showings begin Thursday, 10/22 at 3:00 PM. Offers due Thursday, 10/29 at 3:00 PM.** **OPEN HOUSE: Sunday, 10/25 from 11:00 AM–1:00 PM.**

22 Petersbrook Circle, Lancaster

$274,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723332 MLS

Welcome to 17 Bellwood Lane in Depew within the Lancaster School District. This 1,266 square foot 3 bedroom, 1 bath Ranch is in excellent condition. Spacious living room has large picture window. The eat-in kitchen was remodeled in 2019 featuring white, bright cabnets & attractive countertops. Luxury vinyl floors were installed in the family room and kitchen. Fantastic family room with sliding glass door leading to a wonderful 15x14 covered patio. Fully fenced rear yard also has a 8x8 shed and backs up to Warner Estates Park/Playground. Convenient location. A great home!! Seller reserves the right to set offer deadline date.

17 Bellwood Lane, Lancaster

$385,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1723442 MLS

Welcome to 5160 William Street in Lancaster, NY! Situated on a deep, private 1-acre lot, this inviting home offers over 2,000 sq. ft. of living space with 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, and a wonderful combination of comfort, character, and functionality. Step inside to a spacious, light-filled living room that flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, perfect for entertaining and everyday gatherings. The fully equipped kitchen features ample cabinetry, counter space, and a casual dining area. Just off the kitchen, the warm and inviting family room is sure to become a favorite gathering spot, showcasing a fireplace, vaulted ceiling, and charming spiral staircase leading to a versatile loft space. A convenient first-floor laundry room and half bathroom complete the main level. Upstairs, retreat to the generously sized primary bedroom featuring double closets, a cozy sitting area, and direct access to the full bathroom. Two additional spacious bedrooms complete the second floor. The full basement offers abundant storage and endless possibilities for additional finished living space. Outside, enjoy the privacy and tranquility of the expansive backyard with plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, recreation, or simply relaxing. Additional highlights include a 2.5-car attached garage, newer roof (2018), and updated electrical (2024). Located in the desirable Lancaster school district. Showings begin Friday, October 23rd, or visit the open house Saturday, October 24th, from 1–3 PM. Offers due Thursday, October 29th, at 12 PM.

5160 William Street, Lancaster

$244,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723737 MLS

Welcome to this inviting 1,400+ sq. ft. home nestled in the desirable Village of Lancaster! Offering easy single level living, this home features three generously sized bedrooms, an updated four-piece bathroom, and an open-concept layout with LVP flooring throughout. Freshly painted rooms provide a bright, refreshed feel, while the sunny kitchen offers ample storage, brand-new countertops, a beautiful accent wall, and all appliances included! Enjoy peace of mind with sound mechanicals, vinyl windows, and central air conditioning. Outside, you’ll find a fully fenced, level backyard complete with a nice patio area and lighting, creating the perfect setting for relaxing or entertaining friends and family into the evening. A spacious one-car garage adds convenience and extra storage. Ideally located just down the road from supermarkets, gas stations, shopping, and everyday conveniences, this home combines comfort, functionality, and location. Situated within the Lancaster School District, this is a wonderful opportunity for anyone looking for a well-maintained home with convenient single-level living in a sought-after community. Don’t miss your chance to make this house your home!

278 Aurora Street, Lancaster

$250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1723378 MLS

Value Range Pricing- Owner will consider offers between $250,000- $300,000 or higher on this charming Two-Family Home in the Heart of Lancaster Village! Discover a fantastic investment opportunity in this well-maintained two-family home, ideally situated near vibrant bars, restaurants, and shopping. Each rental unit features two spacious bedrooms, gleaming hardwood floors, and replacement windows, ensuring comfort and efficiency. Both units come equipped with appliances, making them move-in ready for tenants or family. This owner-occupied property has been meticulously cared for and shows beautifully, reflecting pride of ownership. Enjoy the convenience of off-street parking with a two-car garage, providing ample space for vehicles and storage. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer looking to offset your mortgage with rental income or an investor seeking a solid addition to your portfolio, this property is a must-see. Don’t miss out on this incredible opportunity to own a piece of Lancaster Village living! Offers will be reviewed on 10/26/26 at 10 am.

16 Brandel Avenue, Lancaster

$249,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1722822 MLS

Welcome to this charming ranch-style home in the Village of Lancaster and Lancaster Central School District. Offering plenty of potential, this home is ready for your personal touches and cosmetic updates to truly make it your own. A partially finished basement features a versatile bonus room with full bath and closet space for whatever may suite your needs best. Whether its a guest retreat, home office, recreation area or a potential rental opportunity, subject to municipal approvals of course, there are plenty of possibilities. The pull down stairs to the attic will provide plenty of storage space, and a brand new electrical panel was just installed. Outside, you'll find a welcoming front porch, a one-car garage, and two additional parking spaces in the front of the property. A short distance to Keysa Park, featuring swimming pools, a playground, basketball courts, skate park, and green space for outdoor enjoyment. You're also conveniently located near the Village of Lancaster's shops, restaurants, and community attractions. Listing agent is related to the sellers.

69 Banner Avenue, Lancaster

$270,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1722633 MLS

Welcome to this inviting 3-bedroom ranch, nestled on a quiet dead-end street. Offering comfortable one-floor living and a full dry basement, it has plenty of possibilities. This home is a wonderful opportunity for those looking to make a home their own. The Well-Appointed Kitchen and Bright Dining Area add to the charm. It is conveniently located for commuting, shopping and entertainment. Mechanical updates include Furnace and AC installed in 2021, Extensive Plumbing Improvements with Transferable Warranty from Mr. Plumber recently completed including installation of a Sump Pump with Battery Back-Up. The yard is partially fenced and the Open Porch on the front is a great place for your morning coffee or evening relaxation. The Enclosed Sunroom makes the outside available, even when Mother Nature doesn't cooperate. The 2025 Stove and Dishwasher are included as is the 2026 Microwave and the Refrigerator. Even the Washer and Dryer are included for added convenience. This freshly painted home is Move-In Ready and just waiting for its next chapter! Showings start immediately - Offer review will begin on 10/25 at 6PM.

50 5th Avenue, Lancaster

Lancaster Homes under $400,000

Newest Lancaster Homes under $400,000

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?