Pomfret Homes under $200,000

Pomfret Homes under $200,000

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Pomfret and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Newest Pomfret Homes under $200,000

8150 Cummings Road, Pomfret
$199,999
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1718981 MLS
Country charm, room to roam, and a place to unwind! Situated on 3 acres in Stockton, this 4-bedroom, 1-bath ranch offers an inviting setting for everyday country living or a weekend getaway. Beautiful woodwork throughout adds warmth and character, giving the home a welcoming feel that complements its country setting. Outside, a beautiful custom pergola creates a standout space for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying the surroundings. An automatic backup generator adds peace of mind, while a newer hot water tank and a water softener system offer everyday convenience. A 1-car garage and an additional storage shed provide space for parking, tools, and outdoor equipment. The acreage leaves room to enjoy the outdoors, explore gardening ideas, or simply relax under the open sky. Whether you envision quiet mornings with coffee or weekends away from the bustle, 8150 Cummings Road offers space to settle in and make it your own. Come experience the charm and possibilities of this country property! Sale includes tax map id # 065889-181-000-0001-053-000 & 065889-181-000-0001-055-000.

8150 Cummings Road, Pomfret
118 Prospect Street, Pomfret
$149,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1718677 MLS
Charming 3BR home in the Village of Fredonia! Welcoming foyer leads to a spacious living room and formal dining room. Bright, modern kitchen and a large, updated bathroom provide comfortable, functional living space. Enjoy the enclosed front porch, plus a back concrete patio—perfect for relaxing or entertaining! The property also features a large barn with a new metal roof installed in 2022, offering excellent storage and workspace potential. House roof new in 2023! A wonderful opportunity to own a well-maintained home with character and plenty of space in a convenient Village location.

118 Prospect Street, Pomfret
66 Eagle Street, Pomfret
$198,900
7 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1716987 MLS
DON'T MISS YOUR OPPORTUNITY to own this EXCELLENT INVESTMENT PROPERTY! Spacious, two-family home offering four bedrooms and 2 full baths on the first level. Featuring a large, eat-in kitchen with many oak cabinets, living & dining areas. Enclosed, back porch. Ideal for owner occupancy with additional income from upper 3-bedroom apartment. Recently remodeled and updated interior with new flooring throughout. Freshly painted. Separate utilities. Currently utilized as a successful Airbnb. Previously occupied as a student rental. Potential unlimited. Vinyl sided accented with stone front exterior and vinyl windows. New roof (September 2026). Well maintained. Double driveways. Large rear parking space. Close to downtown, SUNY Fredonia, restaurants, and Village conveniences. Near recreational activities; Lake Erie, beaches, Harbor front, near wine trail, and many more opportunities for entertainment. Don't wait on this one!

66 Eagle Street, Pomfret
134 Newton Street, Pomfret
$99,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1715663 MLS
Discover the potential in this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home, ideally situated on a generous ½-acre lot! Several key updates have already been completed, including renovations to the main living space, kitchen, and bathroom in 2021, plus a metal roof installed in 2021. With some additional finishing touches, there is plenty of opportunity to personalize the home and create a space that fits your vision. The spacious lot offers room to enjoy the outdoors, garden, entertain, or simply spread out. Conveniently located near SUNY Fredonia, local shopping, restaurants, and everyday amenities, this property offers a great combination of location, space, and potential. Being sold as-is. Whether you’re looking for a home you can make your own or an investment opportunity with potential to renovate and build equity, this property is worth a look!

134 Newton Street, Pomfret
148 Prospect Street, Pomfret
$195,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1714862 MLS
148 Prospect St Fredonia NY 14063. This 4 Bedroom 1.5 Bath Home has been completely updated. Full exterior paint job in 2026. Full tear-off roof completed in 2026. Back sunroom rebuilt boasting new framing, electrical, insulated and conditioned, can be used year-round! Open Concept first floor, totally updated kitchen, Butcher Block Island, Granite Counter Tops, New Cabinets and solid Oak Hardwood Floors. First floor also has a Half Bathroom, Bedroom, coat closet and an enclosed front entrance. Second floor has three great sized Bedrooms, a Full Bathroom & Laundry Hook-ups! All four Bedrooms have ceiling fans. Full basement for plenty of storage, side yard concrete patio and a big backyard. All mechanical items have been updated, truly move-in ready.

148 Prospect Street, Pomfret
11 Buffalo Street Unit S, Pomfret
$55,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1707392 MLS
Welcome to 11 Buffalo Street, a charming year-round home located in the unique and historic community of Lily Dale, New York. The first floor offers a comfortable and functional layout featuring one bedroom and a half bath, along with a large eat-in kitchen, dining area, and inviting living room. Enjoy quiet mornings or relaxing evenings on the welcoming front porch, while the private back patio provides another wonderful outdoor space for entertaining, reading, or simply unwinding. Upstairs, you'll find two generously sized bedrooms and a full bath, providing plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office. Unlike many seasonal cottages, this home is equipped for year-round living with hot-water baseboard heat. A metal roof and vinyl siding add durability and help make exterior maintenance easier. Located within Lily Dale, a historic and close-knit community along the Cassadaga Lakes, this home provides the opportunity to enjoy the peaceful surroundings and distinctive character that have made Lily Dale a special destination for generations. Lily Dale is a unique, gated community with strict rules. You must be a member in good standing of the Spiritualist religion, and property is handled through leaseholds rather than traditional land ownership. Housing and Rules: No Land Ownership: You cannot actually buy and own the land under a home. Instead, you buy a leasehold that gives you the right to live on the property for a set number of years. Cash Only: Mortgages are not allowed inside the community, meaning you must buy your home outright with cash. Even without land ownership, you still have to pay property taxes. Religious Requirement: You must be a member in "good standing" of a recognized Spiritualist church and go through an application process with the Lily Dale Assembly board of directors. Community Life: Small Population: Only around 250 to 275 people live there year-round, though thousands of visitors arrive during the summer program season. Land lease is currently $1143/year

11 Buffalo Street Unit S, Pomfret
9185 Chautauqua Road, Pomfret
$179,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1710333 MLS
Home: Approximately 1,704 Square Feet of Living Space 1st Floor: 852 +/- Square Feet Entry Way – Laundry Hook-ups, Glo-warm Mounted Heater Kitchen – Laminate Flooring, Wood Cabinets, Electic Stover Hook-Ups, NO APPLIANCES ARE INCLUDED Dining Room – Laminate Flooring, Ceiling Fan/Light, Stove Platform and Connection for Pellet Stove (no stove) Full Bathroom – Located off the Dining Room, Shower/Tub Combo, Tile Flooring Mudroom - Tile Flooring Living Room – Laminate Flooring, 2 Ceiling Fan/Lights, Harman Pellet Stove, Storage Closet Under Stairs, 2nd Floor: 852 +/- Square Feet Landing Area – Storage Closet, Ceiling Fan/Light Bedroom #1 – Laminate Flooring, Ceiling Fan/Light Bedroom #2 – Laminate Flooring, Ceiling Fan/Light, Closet Bedroom #3 – Laminate Flooring, Ceiling Fan/Light, Closet Rheem 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater Circuit Breakers – 200 Amp Fiber Cement Siding Stone Foundation Shingle Roof Stone/Gravel Driveway Partial Basement w/ Dirt Floor Private Septic Private Well Detached Garage - Metal Roof There is a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment upstairs of the garage. However, it is in rough shape. Metal Storage Shed

9185 Chautauqua Road, Pomfret
57 Maple Avenue, Pomfret
$170,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1710291 MLS
VILLAGE CHARMER. You'll love the character and charm of this two-bedroom, one bath ranch style home featuring beautiful, natural woodwork throughout. Two car detached garage. Plenty of storage space and outdoor space. Quaint home with plenty of window light and a cozy wood burning fireplace. A cute place to call home. Nice sized yard and patio to enjoy the outdoors. Conveniently located in the Village of Fredonia, near SUNY Fredonia and close to shopping and Lake Erie. DON'T WAIT on this one!

57 Maple Avenue, Pomfret
82 Eagle Street, Pomfret
$170,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1709462 MLS
Welcome to 82 Eagle Street, a well-maintained multi-unit property conveniently located within walking distance of Downtown Fredonia and just minutes from SUNY Fredonia! Both units are currently occupied and generating $1,200 per month each, providing a total of $2,400 in monthly rental income. The property has seen numerous updates, including new vinyl siding on portions of the front and side, two new hot water heaters, new rear steps/porch, and substantial improvements to both front porches. The lower porch features new roof railings and stairs, while the upper front porch has completely new decking, railings, and stairs. The lower unit offers newer flooring in the kitchen and living room, new trim throughout most rooms, new carpet in the office, along with a new refrigerator, washer, and dryer. The upper unit has also received fresh paint. Each unit has its own driveway, providing convenient off-street parking. With established rental income, continued improvements, and a desirable location close to Downtown Fredonia and SUNY Fredonia, this property offers a great investment opportunity and owner occupancy!

82 Eagle Street, Pomfret
7 Union Street, Pomfret
$139,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1708463 MLS

7 Union Street, Pomfret
5332 Van Buren Bay Court, Pomfret
$158,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1707510 MLS
Opportunity awaits in the sought-after Van Buren Bay lake community! This charming year-round fully furnished, 2-bedroom, 1-bath ranch is situated on a double lot and features a spacious yard, detached garage, and a lovely rear deck—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Enjoy the peaceful atmosphere of this quiet community, with a park and a short walk to the shores of beautiful Lake Erie. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence, weekend getaway, or vacation home, this property offers an excellent opportunity to enjoy all that Van Buren Bay has to offer!

5332 Van Buren Bay Court, Pomfret
8 Marion Street Unit LD N, Pomfret
$168,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1701295 MLS
Lily Dale is a unique, gated community with strict rules. You must be a member in good standing of the Spiritualist religion, and property is handled through leaseholds rather than traditional land ownership. Housing and Rules: No Land Ownership: You cannot actually buy and own the land under a home. Instead, you buy a leasehold that gives you the right to live on the property for a set number of years. Cash Only: Mortgages are not allowed inside the community, meaning you must buy your home outright with cash. Even without land ownership, you still have to pay property taxes. Religious Requirement: You must be a member in "good standing" of a recognized Spiritualist church and go through an application process with the Lily Dale Assembly board of directors. Community Life: Small Population: Only around 250 to 275 people live there year-round, though thousands of visitors arrive during the summer program season. Lily Dale is considered to be the 'Psychic Capital Of The World'. The lease fee to the 'Lily Dale Assembly' is currently $1143/year. This 4 bedroom home has a fantastic layout and is ever so welcoming!! 2 bedrooms and a full bath on first floor, 2 more bedrooms and a full bath on 2nd floor as well. Huge walk-in closets are amazingly everywhere. The large living room has a wood burning fireplace and A/C. There is a Mitsubishi mini-split A/C on the 2nd floor to cool the bedrooms upstairs as well! Living in Lily Dale gives you the ability to use the beach and stroll the lovely waterfront, which you can see from the balcony of the upper back bedroom in this home! The basement is partially finished with recreation room that has tiled floor, another 1/2 bath, brick fireplace, mini kitchen, laundry and utility/workshop room and glass block windows. Attached garage with overhead door opener, blacktop driveway. This unique Lily Dale home that is teeming with character and warmth can be lived in for summer use during the Lily Dale Program Event season or year round as it is heated with a Lennox Elite Series forced air furnace. Steel roof, blown-in insulation, high speed internet available. your journey awaits!

8 Marion Street Unit LD N, Pomfret
Start Your Search