Shelby Homes for Sale

Shelby Homes for Sale

Shelby, located in Orleans County, New York, is a charming town with a rich history and a close-knit community. For those looking to settle down in this picturesque area, there are plenty of homes for sale in Shelby. Whether you're searching for a cozy single-family home, a spacious farmhouse with acreage, or a modern townhouse, Shelby has a diverse range of real estate options to suit every taste and budget.

Homebuyers in Shelby can enjoy the tranquility of small-town living while still being within easy reach of amenities and attractions. With tree-lined streets, historic architecture, and a welcoming atmosphere, Shelby offers a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life. Residents can take advantage of local parks, shops, restaurants, and community events, making it a great place to call home.

If you're considering making a move to Shelby, now is a great time to explore the available homes for sale and find your perfect match in this idyllic town in upstate New York.

Newest Shelby Homes for Sale

362 South Avenue, Shelby
$136,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1722723 MLS
Looking for a home with convenience and a ton potential? This 3-bedroom home is located in the Village of Medina, close to local schools and village amenities. Features include convenient first-floor laundry, two bathrooms, a formal dining room that could easily be converted into a first-floor bedroom to suit your needs, and a shed for extra storage. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, looking for extra space, or searching for a home with flexible living options, this property offers plenty of possibilities. Open House Saturday October, 17th 1-3pm.

362 South Avenue, Shelby
706 West Avenue, Shelby
$179,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1691908 MLS
Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath two-story home nestled in Medina’s desirable West Village! Conveniently located within walking distance to downtown shops, restaurants, parks, and local schools, this home offers the perfect blend of character, space, and modern updates. Step onto the inviting covered front porch and into a spacious foyer featuring beautiful natural woodwork that continues throughout the home. The bright, updated kitchen offers abundant counter space and cabinetry, making it ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the large formal dining room and spacious living room, while a convenient first-floor half bath adds to the home’s functionality. Upstairs, you’ll find three generously sized bedrooms along with a full bath. The primary bedroom features a large walk-in closet. Continue to the finished third-floor attic, where approximately 700 square feet of additional living space provides endless possibilities for a fourth bedroom, home office, playroom or recreation area. Outside, enjoy the private, fully fenced backyard from the tiered back deck, perfect for relaxing, entertaining, or summer barbecues. Combining timeless charm, generous living space, and an unbeatable location, this West Village home is one you won’t want to miss! Delayed Showings & Negotiations until Saturday September 26th at 10AM.

706 West Avenue, Shelby
916 West Avenue, Shelby
$390,000
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1714478 MLS
Welcome to 916 West Avenue—a striking Italianate-style Victorian built in 1880 and offering 3,288 sq ft of character, space and flexibility on a deep .61-acre lot in the Village of Medina! From the distinctive rooftop cupola, open front porch and circular stone driveway to the abundance of natural woodwork inside, this home is filled with architectural personality. The main level features hardwood floors throughout many of the primary living spaces, including a massive formal dining room and spacious living room. A large family room showcases beautiful natural-wood pocket doors and could also serve as a first-floor bedroom. An additional 13x13 play/flex room, not included in the reported square footage, provides even more options. Two kitchens create excellent potential for multigenerational living—the first with hardwood floors, oak cabinetry, tile backsplash and stainless steel appliances, and the second with LVP flooring, island, dishwasher and gas range. A large first-floor laundry room with included washer/dryer plus a full bath with tile flooring and stand-up shower add everyday convenience. Upstairs are 4 additional bedrooms with newer LVP flooring, including an oversized primary suite with walk-in closet, mini-split and updated ensuite bath with tile flooring and tiled tub/shower surround. A second full bath completes the upper level. Outside, enjoy a private, fully fenced backyard with above-ground pool, deck with hot tub and shed. The impressive 832 sq ft barn/garage, built in 2018, offers space for up to 4 vehicles, a 12-ft door, separate 24x12 workshop and bonus room with its own mini-split and 100-amp subpanel. A walk-up attic adds useful storage, while the deep lot, mature setting and preserved architectural details reinforce the character and space rarely found in newer homes. Additional highlights include an 11-12-year-old tear-off roof, RHEEM high-efficiency furnace of similar age and a water heater approximately 5-6 years old. Conveniently located near historic Downtown Medina, the Erie Canal, shops, restaurants and local attractions—this is a rare property with exceptional flexibility and Victorian character throughout!

916 West Avenue, Shelby
1209 West Avenue, Shelby
$149,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1713482 MLS
Welcome to this precious 4 bedroom village Colonial is brimming with classic charm, beautiful original details, and a convenient location. Situated within walking distance of local schools and the business district, this home provides the perfect blend of character, comfort, and accessibly. Step inside through the welcoming foyer, where you'll appreciate the home's beautiful natural woodwork and stained-glass window, adding warmth and timeless elegance. The inviting interior also features a formal dining room, perfect for family gatherings and entertaining. Enjoy the changing seasons from the enclosed porch, while the enclosed back porch offers additional space for relaxing hobbies, or everyday living. Outside, the extra-large lot provides plenty of room for gardening, recreation, or simply enjoying your own outdoor space. A 2-car garage adds convenient parking and storage. This is a wonderful opportunity to own a spacious village Colonial filled with classic character, original details, generous space, and a location close to schools, shopping, and local businesses. Delayed showings until Friday, September 18 at 11 am.

1209 West Avenue, Shelby
429 E Oak Orchard Street, Shelby
$115,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712248 MLS
Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 1½-bath home in the Village of Medina, situated on a spacious half-acre lot! The first floor features a nice size living room with new flooring, a kitchen with ample cabinet space, and convenient first-floor laundry. The stove and refrigerator are included and convey in as-is condition. A room off the half bath is currently being used as a pantry; the seller will be removing the freestanding shelving. Upstairs, you'll find two bedrooms, including one with a walk-in closet, plus a versatile bonus area that could be used as a playroom, home office, or hobby space. While tax records reflect three bedrooms, the additional upstairs area is not enclosed and has never been finished as a bedroom. With the addition of a wall, it may offer potential for a third bedroom, subject to buyer verification and applicable requirements. A walk-up attic provides even more potential for future finished living space. Recent updates include a roof (2016), vinyl replacement windows (2017), furnace (2020), electrical panel, and an updated full bathroom with Bath Fitter. The home needs some TLC and is ready for your personal touches. Enjoy the generous half-acre lot, flexible living spaces, and the opportunity to make this Village of Medina home your own!

429 E Oak Orchard Street, Shelby
580 East Avenue, Shelby
$148,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1701934 MLS
Opportunity awaits in this spacious Village Colonial situated on a generously sized lot. Offering 4 bedrooms with the potential for up to 6, this home provides flexible living space to accommodate a growing family, home office, guest rooms, or hobby areas. The main level features the two bonus rooms that can easily be adapted to fit your needs—whether as additional bedrooms, a home office, playroom, or den. The large yard offers plenty of space for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or future improvements. Bring your vision and unlock the potential this classic Colonial has to offer!

580 East Avenue, Shelby
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!