Sheldon Real Estate

Sheldon Real Estate

Sheldon: A Hidden Gem in Wyoming County, NY

Nestled in the heart of Wyoming County, New York, Sheldon is a charming town that offers a tranquil and picturesque setting for residents and visitors alike. With its rich history, natural beauty, and close-knit community, Sheldon is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered.

Situated in western New York, Sheldon enjoys the best of both worlds - the peace and tranquility of rural living, while still being within close proximity to major cities. The town is conveniently located just a short drive away from Buffalo, Rochester, and Niagara Falls, making it an ideal location for those seeking a balance between small-town charm and urban amenities.

Nature enthusiasts will find themselves in paradise in Sheldon. The town is surrounded by lush forests, rolling hills, and picturesque farmland, offering ample opportunities for outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, fishing, and birdwatching. Sheldon is also home to several parks and nature preserves, including the popular Letchworth State Park, renowned for its stunning waterfalls and scenic trails.

Sheldon's rich history is evident in its well-preserved architecture and historic landmarks. The town boasts a number of beautifully restored buildings, including the Sheldon Historical Society Museum, which showcases artifacts and exhibits that tell the story of Sheldon's past.

The close-knit community in Sheldon is known for its friendly residents and strong sense of camaraderie. The town hosts various community events throughout the year, including festivals, farmers markets, and parades, providing opportunities for residents to come together and celebrate.

In terms of real estate, Sheldon offers a range of housing options to suit different preferences and budgets. From charming historic homes to modern new constructions, there is something for everyone in this idyllic town.

Whether you're looking for a peaceful place to call home or a weekend getaway, Sheldon in Wyoming County, NY, is a hidden gem worth exploring. With its natural beauty, rich history, and strong sense of community, Sheldon offers a quality of life that is hard to find elsewhere.

Newest Listings in Sheldon

Escape to the beauty of Wyoming County with this exceptional buildable vacant lot nestled among the area's picturesque rolling hills. Located on a quiet dead-end road, this property offers the perfect balance of privacy, open space, and natural beauty. Several cleared areas provide an ideal setting for your dream home, cabin, or weekend retreat, while mature trees create a peaceful, wooded backdrop. Surrounded by abundant wildlife and scenic countryside, you'll enjoy the tranquility of nature with deer, wild turkey, and other native wildlife frequently visiting the property. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the convenient access to nearby snowmobile trails, making this an excellent year-round destination for recreation and adventure. Whether you're looking to build now or invest for the future, this property offers endless possibilities in a serene rural setting. If you've been searching for a place where privacy, natural beauty, outdoor recreation, and buildable potential come together, this Wyoming County property is ready to make your vision a reality. Buyer to accept current survey dated 3/24/2022, Surveyed by John F Gillen, with affidavit of no change. Seller reserves the right to set an offer deadline.

Thomas Road, Sheldon

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1699520 MLS

Don't miss this exceptional 2020-built hillside ranch situated on over 5 scenic acres, offering breathtaking views and the perfect blend of modern comfort and country living. Step inside and be welcomed by a bright, open-concept floor plan featuring a spacious living room, an inviting kitchen with a center island and dining area, all designed for entertaining and everyday living. Enjoy direct access to not one, but two decks where you can relax and take in the peaceful countryside. The first-floor primary suite is conveniently located next to the first-floor laundry, making one-floor living a breeze. Two additional bedrooms and a second full bath complete the main level. The finished walkout basement adds incredible living space with a large recreation room, two additional finished rooms that are perfect for guest accommodations, a home office, den, fitness room, or media space, plus a third full bath for added convenience. An attached 2.5-car garage provides even more storage. Outside, you'll love the beautiful grounds with room to garden, explore the wooded acreage, or simply enjoy the privacy and natural surroundings and walk through the beautiful maple trees. The impressive 40' x 30' outbuilding offers abundant space for vehicles, boats, ATVs, equipment, or a workshop. This is a rare opportunity to own a nearly new home with acreage, incredible views, outstanding storage, and the lifestyle you've been looking for.

2940 Dutch Hollow Road, Sheldon

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1698032 MLS

Welcome to this STUNNING farmhouse, lovingly cared for by the same family for decades & nestled in the picturesque Town of Sheldon! Set on approximately 30 acres (subject to subdivision), this incredible country property offers the perfect blend of charm, comfort & endless opportunity. Whether you've dreamed of hobby farming, raising horses or livestock, or simply enjoying wide-open space, this property delivers! Step inside & instantly feel at HOME! The heart of the house is the cozy eat-in kitchen, surrounded by a spacious mudroom, front entry way, convenient 1st-floor laundry, private office & an impressive walk-in pantry that neatly houses the refrigerator. The inviting living room is filled with natural light, featuring a gas fireplace & beautiful sight-lines from the front of the home all the way to the backyard. A rear door leads to the deck where you'll enjoy breathtaking rolling countryside views in every season. The flexible floor plan offers 5 bedrooms, including 1 on the 1st floor & 4 upstairs, all with closets. 2 full bathrooms provide convenience for family & guests, featuring a tub/shower on the 1st floor & a walk-in shower upstairs. Both bathrooms storage & fresh finishes too! Outside is where this property truly shines! Relax on the incredible patio while enjoying the swing set, or host summer cookouts on the side patio just off the back entrance. A storage shed provides additional space for tools & outdoor equipment. Across the road you'll find an impressive 4-car garage, multiple classic barns, expansive pastures & endless room to explore, making this an exceptional property for animals, equipment, hobbies or future possibilities. Properties like this are rarely offered! Enjoy peaceful country living with postcard-worthy views, timeless farmhouse character & approximately 30 acres to make your own—all within the Attica School District. 2,259 Square Feet is based on floor plans attached.This is more than a home...it's a lifestyle you'll treasure for generations. Around the corner from Byrncliff Golf Course too.

1957 Schwab Road, Sheldon

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1697274 MLS

Escape to nature in this charming 2 bedroom cabin nestled in the sought-after Popular Point community off Centerline Road. Situated on a spacious corner lot overlooking a peaceful fishing pond, this cozy retreat is the perfect place to relax and unwind. Start your mornings on the deck with a cup of coffee while taking in the tranquil views and sounds of nature. Inside, you'll find a warm and inviting living room featuring cathedral ceilings and skylights that fill the space with natural light. Updated kitchen and bathroom, roof (approx. 10 years old), HWT & heater (approx. 8 years old) and all furniture is included, making this a truly turnkey getaway. Enjoy everything Popular Point has to offer, including fishing, swimming ponds, and the beauty of the outdoors, all while being just minutes from Byrncliff Golf Resort. Whether you're looking for a weekend escape, seasonal retreat, or peaceful place to recharge, this cabin is ready to welcome you home.

69 Foxtrail, Sheldon

Rare Commercial Enetrprise Space with tremendous Opportunity and Expansion Potential! MAXIMIZE YOUR INVESTMENT! This versatile commercial property in Varysburg offers the perfect blend of immediate utility and future growth. Featuring a well-maintained building with an adaptable floor plan, this site is ideal for storage, retail, office space, or a service-based business looking for high visibility and easy access. THE X-FACTOR: This sale includes an additional vacant lot, providing a rare opportunity in this market as expanded parking, outdoor storage, or build to suit your growing needs. Whether you are an owner-occupant looking to plant roots or an investor seeking a multi-faceted asset, this "package deal" is a standout. DON'T MISS OUT: * Delayed Showings: Start Tuesday, 4/21/26 at 12:00 PM. Delayed Negotiations: All offers are due by Thursday, 4/30/26 at 12:00 PM. Secure your spot in Varysburg’s commercial landscape today!

2477 & 2479 Route 20a, Sheldon

Welcome to The Route 78 Pub & Residence — a landmark property in the heart of Strykersville offering a rare chance to live, work, and invest under one roof. Now priced at $550,000, this turn-key restaurant and four-bedroom apartment combine small-town character, proven business opportunity, and financial flexibility in one exceptional package. Downstairs, the well-known Route 78 Pub has long been a community favorite — recognized for its welcoming atmosphere, quality food, and local following. The space is fully equipped and ready for new ownership, featuring seating for 100+ guests, an outdoor patio, and a beautifully crafted bar with hardwood floors and timeless charm. The commercial kitchen is built for performance, complete with a full cook line, walk-in cooler and freezer, prep and pizza stations, and a separate overflow kitchen. A walk-up ice cream service window provides an additional seasonal income stream and draws extra traffic in the warmer months. Upstairs, a spacious, updated four-bedroom apartment adds valuable income potential or the ideal setup for an owner-operator. The apartment features open-concept living, modern finishes, a third-floor bonus area, and a private primary suite with deck and walk-in cedar closet. Recent updates include newer furnaces and central A/C (within 4 years) and a full roof replacement (approx. 12 years ago). From an income-and-expense standpoint, the ability to live on-site while operating the business creates a significant advantage and keeps overhead low. The Route 78 Pub & Residence is fully outfitted and poised for success — waiting for someone to bring their vision, energy, and ideas to the next chapter of this established local favorite. Also listed as commercial under MLS B1648800. Square footage is based on updated measurements at the time of listing

3974 Route 78, Sheldon

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1648800 MLS

Welcome to The Route 78 Pub & Residence — a landmark property in the heart of Strykersville offering a rare chance to live, work, and invest under one roof. Now priced at $550,000, this turn-key restaurant and four-bedroom apartment combine small-town character, proven business opportunity, and financial flexibility in one exceptional package. Downstairs, the well-known Route 78 Pub has long been a community favorite — recognized for its welcoming atmosphere, quality food, and local following. The space is fully equipped and ready for new ownership, featuring seating for 100+ guests, an outdoor patio, and a beautifully crafted bar with hardwood floors and timeless charm. The commercial kitchen is built for performance, complete with a full cook line, walk-in cooler and freezer, prep and pizza stations, and a separate overflow kitchen. A walk-up ice cream service window provides an additional seasonal income stream and draws extra traffic in the warmer months. Upstairs, a spacious, updated four-bedroom apartment adds valuable income potential or the ideal setup for an owner-operator. The apartment features open-concept living, modern finishes, a third-floor bonus area, and a private primary suite with deck and walk-in cedar closet. Recent updates include newer furnaces and central A/C (within 4 years) and a full roof replacement (approx. 12 years ago). From an income-and-expense standpoint, the ability to live on-site while operating the business creates a significant advantage and keeps overhead low. The Route 78 Pub & Residence is fully outfitted and poised for success — waiting for someone to bring their vision, energy, and ideas to the next chapter of this established local favorite. Also listed as commercial under MLS B1648806. Square footage is based on updated measurements at the time of listing.

3974 Route 78, Sheldon

Start Your Search