Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$239,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1680765 MLS
SI\NGLE FAMILY HOME CURRENTLY USED AS A COLLEGE HOUSING.... IT HAS 4 BEDROOMS AND WOULD WORK FOR A LARGE SINGLE DWELLING IT HAS BEEN FOAM INSULATE IN THE WALLS AND IS ADJACENT TO THE UNIVERSITY

140 Central Avenue, Pomfret
$179,900
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1680494 MLS
Investment property, 3 unit home with strong long term rental history. Off street parking, close to downtown, SUNY Fredonia and shopping.

60-62 Cleveland Avenue Unit 60, Pomfret
$115,000
R1680185 MLS
This 110-acre property is a great opportunity for anyone looking for hunting and recreational land. The property features a large wooded area that provides excellent wildlife habitat and makes it an ideal setting for deer, turkey, and other game. With a mix of open and wooded land, this property offers plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors and all that nature has to offer. Approximately 30 acres of the property are occupied by a solar farm under an existing long-term lease. The solar lease is not included in the sale; however, the buyer will own the entire 110-acre parcel, including the land beneath the solar farm, subject to the existing lease. If you have been looking for a large tract of land with excellent hunting potential, this property is well worth a look.

5208 W Main Road, Pomfret
$849,900
14 Beds ⋅ R1678532 MLS
Investor Opportunity – 14-Unit Apartment Complex in Fredonia Attention investors—this is a rare opportunity to acquire a well-maintained 14-unit apartment complex just inside the Village of Fredonia. With a strong rental history and gross annual income exceeding $140,000, this property offers immediate cash flow and long-term upside. The property features two buildings: a front house with four spacious units and a rear single-story building consisting of 10 more units. Combined there are seven studio apartments, three 2-bedroom apartments, and four 1 bedroom apartments. Several units have been thoughtfully renovated, enhancing both appeal and rental potential. Several major improvements have already been completed, including newer roofs, updated boilers, and hot water tanks, reflecting consistent ownership care and reduced future capital expenses. The front building offers separately metered gas and electric for each of the four units, reducing expenses while adding efficiency and ease of management. Ideally located within walking distance to downtown Fredonia’s shops, restaurants, and nightlife, and just minutes from SUNY Fredonia, this property benefits from a highly desirable rental location. Whether you’re expanding your portfolio or entering the multi-family market, this property is a solid investment with proven performance.

15 Chautauqua Street, Pomfret
$844,900
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1678335 MLS
Contemporary 6BR/4Bath home in the Village of Fredonia set on 1.6 acres! Custom built in 2010, this impressive property features an open-concept floor plan with a spacious great room, highlighted by a stunning cherry kitchen with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a premium Bertazzoni gas range. Expansive living and dining areas (dining set stays), a grand foyer, and a versatile front room ideal for a home office, plus, one bedroom and one full bath complete the main level. Enjoy 9-foot ceilings on the first, second, and lower levels. The home is equipped with a 9.1 surround sound system in the lower level and 5.1 on the upper level—perfect for entertaining or a home theater experience. Central vacuum services the first and second floors. The second floor offers a convenient laundry area (with potential for conversion to an additional bathroom) located off the bonus room/6th bedroom—ideal for a media or theater room. The massive primary suite features a large walk-in closet, tile shower, heated jetted tub, and steam shower. Radiant floor heating enhances comfort in the bathrooms. Additional amenities include dual heating and A/C systems, two water heaters, a 6-stage reverse osmosis water system with UV filtration, and a whole-house generator, radon mitigation system, and central vacuum system. The partially finished walkout basement includes a bar area, epoxy flooring, and is already plumbed for a future bathroom. Outdoor features are equally impressive with a composite deck, gazebo, charming bridge, and fire pit overlooking the pond—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The property also includes solar panels, a security system with cameras, and a Ring system for added peace of mind.

9 Ryan Place, Pomfret
$424,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1668967 MLS
Welcome to 41 Liberty Street—an impeccably maintained, nearly new (’21) RANCH style home offering elevated finishes, exceptional indoor living & an outdoor OASIS. Ideally located just moments from downtown Fredonia’s shops & dining, this residence blends modern comfort w/ refined design. Inside, a beautifully curated open-concept layout showcases vaulted tongue-and-groove ceilings, luxury vinyl plank flooring, & thoughtfully selected custom details throughout. The gourmet kitchen features quartz countertops, custom soft-close cabinetry, black stainless-steel appliances, & striking copper accents—seamlessly flowing into a bright, inviting living space designed for effortless entertaining. The spacious primary suite is a true retreat, complete w/ dual walk-in closets & a spa-inspired bath featuring a custom double vanity, heated floors, & a luxurious five-piece walk-in shower. Two additional generously sized bedrooms are positioned alongside a second full bath with custom cabinetry & heated tile floors. Additional highlights include first-floor laundry, a functional mudroom, multiple coat closets, crown molding accents, ceiling fans in every bedroom, & attached 2 car garage. The partially finished, fully insulated & waterproofed basement offers a third full bathroom w/ heated floors, dual electrical panels, a high-efficiency furnace with central AC, hot water tank, & sump pump (all just 5 years young)—providing excellent potential for additional living space or storage. Step outside into your private backyard retreat, accessible through two sliding glass doors leading to a stunning Trex deck(40x12). Enjoy a heated in-ground fiberglass pool (16x38) & unwind beneath a Kohler retractable awning(12x20), offering the perfect balance of sun & shade. The fully fenced white vinyl yard is truly a beautiful space offering both serenity & privacy, while the adjacent detached barn adds exceptional versatility—featuring a half bath, pool changing area, & ample space for storage, vehicles, or recreation! A RARE opportunity to own a thoughtfully designed NEWER home that perfectly balances quality craftsmanship, modern luxury, & resort-style amenities! Showings begin immediately!

41 Liberty Street, Pomfret
$129,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1673259 MLS
Opportunity awaits at 28 Cleveland Ave in Fredonia! This 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers timeless character with hardwood flooring and natural woodwork throughout select areas. The layout includes a formal dining room, inviting front porch, and functional living spaces. Exterior highlights include a detached garage and blacktop driveway. Ideal for first-time buyers or those looking to add personal touches, this home is full of potential! Fredonia Schools.

28 Cleveland Avenue, Pomfret
$375,000
R1672496 MLS
Currently operating as an automotive repair shop…the only spring/suspension shop in Chautauqua County; this property is offered at $375,000 for the building only. The building has two 14’ overhead doors and two 10’ overhead doors! The facility is equipped with three-phase electric and includes an additional rental space generating $600 per month in income. The business and building may be purchased together for $500,000, which includes inventory, tools, and equipment—such as two lifts, tire machine, spring machine, compressor, and more (estimated value of $150,000-$170,000)—along with an established customer base. The property is a registered repair shop and features a New York State inspection station. Purchaser will be required to obtain state approval to continue inspection operations.

80 Water Street, Pomfret
$299,900
7 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1671737 MLS
Bear Lake opportunity! Two cottages set on approximately 2.45 acres with over 500 feet of lake frontage and stunning water views. Plenty of space to add your own dock and fully enjoy lake life—kayaking, swimming, boating, and fishing. Bear Lake is known for its variety of fish, including largemouth bass, muskellunge, and walleye. The cottages offer charm and an excellent location, with great potential for updates and customization. Property is being sold cash only, “as is,” including well and septic. (Unsure of square footage of each cottage; square footage used is what was in tax records)

8131 Bear Lake Road S, Pomfret
$125,900
R1672298 MLS
Welcome to peace outside the busy village of Fredonia! This irregular plot of land, approximately 22 Acres, once used as a mobile park is cleared and ready for your vision to take it to the next level. Cleared land with a driveway in the front of the property have easy access and concrete borders for easy installation of new trailers or for new building. Used as a seasonal camp you have wooded acreage to explore with a small pond towards the back of the property. Electric meters set up have capacity of 5 with one still functional and running. Two septic systems in place with a leech field for easy connection and public water access. Close proximity to Lake Erie and State Park for more adventures. Plenty of land with tons of potential!

5281 Berry Road, Pomfret
$410,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1671317 MLS
Beautiful 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in excellent condition! This well-maintained property features a formal living room and dining room, plus a comfortable room off the modern kitchen with granite countertops and a sliding glass door leading to a 14' x 20' Trex deck. Enjoy outdoor living with a 16' x 32' in-ground pool with a new heater 2009, liner 2018, sand filter 2009, safety cover 2023, fenced-in backyard, and a peaceful wooded view. Recent improvements include NEWLY PURCHASED APPLIANCES, an 18 kW Generac generator in 2023, Heat & Glo gas fireplace insert in 2022, Lennox furnace and central A/C with Nest thermostat in 2021, and updated 200-amp electric service with breakers also in 2021. Additional upgrades include Pella windows throughout 2009, living room bay window 2013, updated primary bath 2015 with bubble tub and TV, hardwood floors on the first floor 2003 & 2018, second-floor laundry closet, epoxy garage floor 2019, waterproofed basement with glass block windows, and vinyl siding 2009. The property also offers an 8' x 14' storage shed matching the home 2016 and is ideally located on a cul-de-sac surrounded by lovely homes. This move-in-ready, low maintenance home combines thoughtful updates, comfortable living spaces, and a fantastic outdoor setting.

32 University Park, Pomfret
$429,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1668286 MLS
Let's check off all the boxes this amazing home has to offer!!! Located only about a mile outside the Village of Fredonia in a relaxed neighborhood of homes and farms, here we have a large home that has endless room inside! This raised ranch design features 6 rooms on upper level and 4 rooms on the lower level! 3 full bathrooms, 4 bedrooms with 2 more for an office, craft room, playroom or hobby room! A 2 story modern foyer with mudroom area lofts upwards and opens into the modern kitchen with complimentary colors and light fixtures with ample cupboard and counter space, appliances and life proof luxury plank flooring. On into the formal dining room featuring sliding doors to a covered deck overlooking the backyard! Moving onward to the formal living room with built-in bookshelves and a decorative electric fireplace with mantle. The primary bedroom has it's own full bath and a large closet with organizer! 2 more bedrooms with closets on this level as well as a 2nd and 3rd full bathroom! A 2nd vaulted 2 story foyer at the front door entryway takes you either up to the living room or down to the lower level featuring more bedrooms, each with a closet and a large recreation/gathering room ideal for games and play, watching TV, gaming or exercising! A basement exists also that houses all the mechanicals such as the 3-zone furnace new in 2024, Central A/C air conditioning new in 2021, sump pump new in 2020, and electric circuit breakers. Public water service and a septic system that was replaced in 2016. Your outdoor space features an upper covered deck, lower stamped concrete patio leading to a party pavilion with steel roof and canvas/vinyl removeable side walls, heating, a party bar and internet connection. The 28' above ground pool with deck is a saltwater pool that is heated and had a new liner in 2024. Shed was built in 2020. Extra features include 2 laundry rooms, one on each floor, high speed fiber internet, new entry doors, new living room viewing window, recessed dimmable ceiling lighting. And here's the best thing-FREE GAS! Heat your pool to bubbling and keep your home as warm as you like!! Country yet close!!!

4616 Berry Road, Pomfret
$52,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1666402 MLS
Charming small home on Rt. 60, just minutes from the Fredonia traffic circle and within easy reach of shops, restaurants and local entertainment. The layout includes one bedroom, a dine-in kitchen that opens to a bright bonus living area with vaulted ceilings and a sliding door to the backyard — perfect for indoor-outdoor living. First-floor laundry, a back mudroom and a generous walk-up attic provide practical storage and flexibility. This property would make a comfortable full-time residence, a weekend retreat, or a rewarding small renovation project.

9557 Route 60, Pomfret
$99,900
R1666135 MLS
Vacant land located on North Road with a small section extending to Route 20, ideally situated between the two neighboring parcels also being offered. This unique property includes an Iroquois Gas well, which is maintained by the company, and the future owner will receive royalty payments. The site also offers the option to build and have gas available directly on the property. With plenty of possibilities, this parcel would be perfect for building a home, starting a small farm, renting for agricultural use, or creating a seasonal camp.

North Rd E, Pomfret
$239,000
R1664400 MLS
Prominent brick office building in prime Fredonia business district ( Zoned B-2 business ). Situated on a hard to find lot providing private parking for approx. 10 cars. First floor is approx 1300 sq, ft. and consists of a front tiled foyer entrance, reception/office room, 2 private office rooms, a large copier/files/office room, a kitchen dining/snack room, and 1/2 bath. The second floor currently provides convenient income as a 3 bedroom apt with separate entrance but can easily be added to the first floor for increased office space if needed. Apartment is fully furnished. Building has a large full basement with 2 access stairs and provides plenty of storage. Some of the many improvements include all new wiring, windows, roof, furnace, brick work, and blacktop parking lot. Walking distance to the post office, banks, park, and restaurants. Seller is licensed real estate broker.

57 Temple Street, Pomfret
$150,000
B1662228 MLS
* OUTSTANDING * PERFECT LOCATION * Professional Building For Sale! Currently Operating As A Thrift-Plant Store / Welcoming Covered Wood Front Porch W Trex Stairs / Front Entrance W Foyer / Spacious Front Room / Half Bath On 1st Floor / Updated Vinyl Flooring Throughout 1st Floor / Kitchen-Breakroom-Employee Lounge / Security Office W Shower / Rear Entrance W Handicap Accessible Elevator / 2nd Floor W WTW Carpet / Flex Room W Closet / Half Bath On Second Floor / Office-Bedroom On Second Floor / Full Basement W Bilco Door, Copper plumbing, Updated PVC Plumbing, Updated 200 AMP Service, HE Furnace W Central AC, Updated Electric HWT, Sump Pump / Black Top Driveway W 4-5 Parking Spaces / Architectural Shingle Roof & Vinyl Siding / Perfect For Retail, Lawyer, Tattoo, Massage Therapy, Barber-Salon..etc / Possible Conversion To Residential W Village Approval

34 White Street, Pomfret
$359,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1648122 MLS
YOU'LL LOVE THE LOCATION of this NEARLY NEW, stunning, two-story, four-bedroom, two full bath, Village of Fredonia home. Extensively remodeled throughout. Custom kitchen with many quality cabinets, center island, fully equipped with stainless appliances. Dining area with large sliding door leading to a new deck. First floor bedrooms and new full bathroom. Two additional spacious bedrooms with large, walk-in closets on second floor. New large bathroom on second floor with walk-in, tiled shower. Second floor laundry room. New beautiful flooring throughout. Many new improvements including e-glass, argon thermo double-pane windows, hot water heating system, 200-amp electrical service, plumbing with 50-gallon hot water tank. Full poured concrete basement. Spacious, covered, front porch. New vinyl siding and architectural roof. New rear deck. Beautiful double lot. Conveniently located to the downtown Village area, restaurants, SUNY Fredonia Campus, playgrounds, schools, Lake Erie,...DON'T MISS OUT!

7 Hillcrest Drive, Pomfret
$39,900
R1646889 MLS
Discover the perfect setting for your dream home on this beautiful 2.5-acre parcel located on a quiet dead-end road in the Fredonia School District. With 546 feet of road frontage and a mix of wooded and open land, this property offers the ideal balance of privacy and natural beauty. The land is situated in the Agricultural District and zoned 311 Res VA Land, providing flexibility for a build-to-suit project. A meandering creek adds character and charm to the property, while the surrounding countryside provides peaceful views and a serene atmosphere. A survey has already been completed, and electric is available at the road, making your building plans even easier to bring to life. Whether you’re looking to construct your forever home or invest in a tranquil getaway, this parcel offers the space, scenery, and setting you’ve been searching for.

Stone Road W, Pomfret
$549,900
3 Beds ⋅ R1644272 MLS
Investment opportunity! Own a piece of Fredonia’s vibrant business district with this unique mixed-use property at 38, 40, & 42 W Main Street. Comprising three centrally located commercial/residential buildings, this investment opportunity offers both stability and growth potential in a high-traffic location. Property Highlights: 4 Commercial Spaces: Three leased to reliable, long-term tenants, ensuring steady income. One vacant space, ready for a new tenant or your business vision. 3 Residential Units: Includes two spacious 2-bedroom apartments and one generous 3-bedroom apartment, all with separate utilities for hassle-free management. Prime Location: Situated in the heart of Fredonia’s bustling village business area, benefiting from high visibility and foot traffic. Parking Convenience: Ample street and municipal parking available for tenants and customers. This property is a rare find, blending consistent rental income with the flexibility to grow. Perfect for investors or owner-occupiers looking to capitalize on Fredonia’s downtiwn commercial scene. Don’t miss out—schedule a viewing today!

38-42 W Main Street, Pomfret
$189,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1640683 MLS
Convenient one floor living, this 2 bedroom 1 1/2 bath townhouse features a large open floor plan with vaulted ceilings and skylights. Kitchen has all appliances and a breakfast bar open to a more formal dining area and spacious living area. Ample size main bedroom w/double closet, 1st. floor laundry, and bath with separate shower and tub. Central air, full poured basement with add'l. 1/2 bath and finished office room. Rear deck overlooks a wooded area and attached garage.

5 Pleasant Avenue, Pomfret
$339,900
R1639256 MLS
Investment Opportunity in Downtown Fredonia! Two commercial office buildings offered together, zoned for business use! #33 is currently leased to a long-term tenant, while #35 is occupied by the sellers, who are open to a lease-back arrangement. Both buildings feature spacious first-floor offices and additional second-floor space. The upper level offers potential to create an additional apartment alongside the existing 3-bedroom unit—an excellent value-add opportunity! Recent updates include a new rubber roof (2024), 7-year-old boiler, and two central A/C units that have been consistently maintained. Convenient parking with municipal lots just around the corner, plus on-street parking along the front and side.

33-35 E Main Street, Pomfret
$259,900
R1628876 MLS
Own Your Business, Own Your Building! Opportunities like this don’t come around often! This beautifully preserved brick row building sits proudly in the heart of historic downtown Fredonia—where charm, foot traffic, and opportunity meet. The main level features a fully equipped, turn-key restaurant space that’s been thoughtfully renovated and is ready for your vision. Whether you’re an established restauranteur tired of renting or an entrepreneur ready to bring a new concept to life, this is your chance to own the walls that house your business and start building long-term equity instead of paying someone else’s mortgage. The restaurant includes everything you need to hit the ground running: a new Hood & ANSUL system, grease traps, gas lines, freezers, flat top, sinks, tables, and more—making this an easy transition for any operator. Current tenant is open to discussions about continuing their lease, offering built-in income while you plan your next move. Above the restaurant, the second and third floors host a spacious 3,200 sq ft loft-style apartment—a stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bath setup with soaring ceilings, a fireplace, built-in bar, and bonus room for an office or studio. It’s fully rented to college students through the 2025–2026 school year, providing steady, reliable income that helps cover expenses while you grow your business. With its prime location, strong rental history, and classic Main Street appeal, 36 W Main Street is more than just a property—it’s an opportunity to plant roots, grow your brand, and invest in your future.

36 W Main Street, Pomfret
$12,900
R1627412 MLS
Village of Fredonia treed building lot tucked in on a dead-end street!

00 Middlesex Drive, Pomfret
$279,900
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1616655 MLS
This charming early 1900s Italianate-style home is nestled in the heart of the historic Village of Fredonia—close to the village center and SUNY Fredonia! Rich in character, it features original hardwood floors, built-in cabinetry, and a unique “pull-out” desk in the dining room. The spacious living room offers a woodburning fireplace with a gas option, and a cozy den sits just off the dining area. The modern kitchen blends seamlessly with the home’s vintage charm. Upstairs you’ll find two bedrooms, a full bath, and a versatile three-room suite—perfect for guests, office, or hobby space. Enjoy the outdoors on the large deck overlooking the deep backyard. Notable updates include: furnace (2023), central A/C (2024), roof (2019), and electric CB panel (2022).

15 Leverett Street, Pomfret
$349,000
R1611139 MLS
Step into a rare opportunity to own a cornerstone of Fredonia’s vibrant nightlife scene. Valentine’s Place, located at 12-14 Water Street, is a turnkey bar and nightclub boasting a rich history and a loyal patronage. Features include state-of-the-art sound and lighting systems, an updated bar, renovated restrooms, new tile flooring, and upgraded electrical and refrigeration systems. More recent structural updates include a newer roof ensuring longevity and reduced maintenance costs. Valentine’s Place is renowned for its lively atmosphere, live music, and diverse drink offerings, including a great beer selection and cocktails like their famous "Vegas Bomb" drink. It is centrally located close to SUNY Fredonia and adjacent to plenty of public parking. The sale includes the land, building, and business, allowing for a seamless transition. Don't miss this chance to own a piece of Fredonia's nightlife history and continue the legacy of Valentine’s Place.

12-14 Water Street, Pomfret
$39,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1597263 MLS
This home is an investment or starter home opportunity. Located in the heart of the village of Fredonia this 3 bedroom/1 bathroom home offers plenty of potential. Vinyl siding, vinyl windows, new floring throughout. New hot water tank installed in 2021 and a gas forced air furnace in good working condition. This home appears as though it is attached to the neighboring home, it is not. There is separation between the two homes and each home sits on its own parcel. Within walking distance to downtown Fredonia restaurants, bars, shops, and businesses. Cash Only sale

77 Eagle Street, Pomfret