Refine Search
Sort by
36 W Main Street, Pomfret
$259,900
R1628876 MLS
Own Your Business, Own Your Building! Opportunities like this don’t come around often! This beautifully preserved brick row building sits proudly in the heart of historic downtown Fredonia—where charm, foot traffic, and opportunity meet. The main level features a fully equipped, turn-key restaurant space that’s been thoughtfully renovated and is ready for your vision. Whether you’re an established restauranteur tired of renting or an entrepreneur ready to bring a new concept to life, this is your chance to own the walls that house your business and start building long-term equity instead of paying someone else’s mortgage. The restaurant includes everything you need to hit the ground running: a new Hood & ANSUL system, grease traps, gas lines, freezers, flat top, sinks, tables, and more—making this an easy transition for any operator. Current tenant is open to discussions about continuing their lease, offering built-in income while you plan your next move. Above the restaurant, the second and third floors host a spacious 3,200 sq ft loft-style apartment—a stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bath setup with soaring ceilings, a fireplace, built-in bar, and bonus room for an office or studio. It’s fully rented to college students through the 2025–2026 school year, providing steady, reliable income that helps cover expenses while you grow your business. With its prime location, strong rental history, and classic Main Street appeal, 36 W Main Street is more than just a property—it’s an opportunity to plant roots, grow your brand, and invest in your future.

36 W Main Street, Pomfret

133 Pulaski Street, Pomfret
$239,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1714331 MLS
There’s fully renovated, and then there’s this property. Completely gutted to the studs and meticulously rebuilt, this home is the result of an incredible amount of vision, craftsmanship and attention to detail. Not one thing was left untouched. Every system, finish and design element was thoughtfully selected with the goal of creating a home that is as beautiful as it is functional. The stunning interior showcases all-new electrical throughout with new panel, plumbing, insulation, tankless water heater, central A/C, gas & water meters and sump pump, complemented by beautiful finishes including quartz countertops, soft-close cabinetry, LVT & tile flooring, tray ceilings, recessed lighting with dimmers, ceiling fans, custom built-ins and an electric fireplace. The kitchen is truly a showpiece with all-new Black Stainless Frigidaire appliances, double oven, gas cooktop and a dedicated coffee bar. Beautiful French doors off the dining room open to the brand-new Trex back deck, creating a seamless connection to the outdoor living space. The fully finished basement adds 1,288 sq. ft. of additional living space with a second full bath featuring a walk-in shower, laundry room and spacious flex room perfect for a home gym, playroom, office or additional living space. Outside, the attention to detail continues with brand-new landscaping, a custom-built pergola over the front porch, new garage door and widened driveway to accommodate two cars. The fully insulated garage features epoxy flooring. All plumbing and sewer lines have been professionally jetted and cleaned by KRD Plumbing, and the new electrical system was inspected by Fox Electric and the Village of Fredonia. This is more than a renovation — it is a complete transformation. A home where every decision was intentional, every detail was considered, and every inch was given the attention it deserved. The result is truly something special. *OPEN HOUSE - SATURDAY (9/19) from 1-3PM*

133 Pulaski Street, Pomfret

19, 21 and 25 Lambert Avenue, Pomfret
$237,000
12 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ B1704060 MLS
Three apartments and a parking lot all in one unique parcel package! Totaling 12 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, this is a huge opportunity for any investor. A side by side duplex, where both units have upstairs and downstairs living space, coupled with a stand alone ranch house, all joined together by a parking lot big enough to fit at least 6 vehicles, and still there is yard space. Located in the Village of Fredonia right near SUNY Fredonia, just down the street from grocery and convenient stores, and close to downtown. In addition to the spacious structures and excellent location, unit 19 & 21 got a new roof in put on around 2019. The Ranch house is currently going through a complete renovations. Updated pictures will be available soon upon request. OPEN HOUSE Saturday August 8th from 11am-1pm. Owner is also selling 185 Temple St, Fredonia NY (B1704049) and 105 Water St, Fredonia NY (B1704008). Package deal available!

19, 21 and 25 Lambert Avenue, Pomfret

19 Lowell Place, Pomfret
$229,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1692268 MLS
Well-Cared-For Ranch in the Village of Fredonia Welcome home to this charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath ranch located in the heart of the Village of Fredonia on a double lot! This beautifully maintained home features a spacious living room, formal dining area, and a modern kitchen with all appliances included. Enjoy the inviting Florida room overlooking a deep, wooded backyard, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Additional highlights include an attached garage, storage room off back concrete patio, GENERAC GENERATOR, CULLIGAN WATER SYSTEM, DOYLE SECURITY SYSTEM and CENTRAL AIR CONDITIONING! Washer and dryer (included) are currently located in the heated garage but can easily be moved back to the basement if preferred or possibly put in main bathroom! Conveniently located near SUNY Fredonia, DFT Plaza, the NYS Thruway, and the Dunkirk Pier, this home combines comfort, convenience, and community charm — a must-see!

19 Lowell Place, Pomfret

18 Risley Street, Pomfret
$219,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1712736 MLS
Welcome to 18 Risley Street in Fredonia, NY! Situated on over half an acre, this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home offers a great combination of space, convenience, and location. Inside, the home features a comfortable floor plan with three bedrooms, a full bathroom, and an additional half bath. The basement provides convenient interior access and includes a bonus room offering flexible space for a home office, recreation room, hobby area, or additional storage. All appliances are included with the sale! A one-car garage is located underneath the home, while a second detached one-car garage provides even more space for vehicles, tools, lawn equipment, or a workshop. The spacious property offers over half an acre of land while still being conveniently located within walking distance of downtown Fredonia and SUNY Fredonia. Enjoy easy access to local shops, restaurants, parks, campus activities, and everything the Village of Fredonia has to offer. With its desirable location, generous lot, two garages, included appliances, and versatile interior space, 18 Risley Street is ready for its next owner.

18 Risley Street, Pomfret

2 Susann Court, Pomfret
$219,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1681666 MLS
Comfort and class, this move-in ready 2 bedroom Townhouse has an extensive list of renovations bringing a competitive standard of quality for it's somewhat smaller stature. Some notable updates include new multi-zone air conditioning, new appliances included, new exterior door, new sliding glass door to dining room, and entire first level flooring replaced with Bamboo to name a few. New LVP flooring in bathrooms and kitchen, new vanities and lighting in both bathrooms. All carpeting and interior doors have been replaced. Recently updated 3-season room includes new sliding glass doors x 3, insulation, LVP flooring and added electric. Private driveway plus 2 additional assigned parking spaces in shared front lot. In addition to the exterior features is a new vinyl privacy fence to the backyard, a new 21ft x 21ft concrete patio with underground drainage built in, recently repainted 12ft x 8ft shed, and stained exterior siding of home. A 20ft x 12ft attached garage, multiple closets throughout and a storage room opposite exterior entrance prove storage capacity is abundant. The vaulted ceiling brings space to the main living area, and the entry foyer brings a degree of separation coming in the main door. Schedule a showing at your earliest convenience. Currently under contract with an "escape clause", open to other offers.

2 Susann Court, Pomfret

23 Bradish Street, Pomfret
$219,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1686034 MLS
Fredonia 4 bedroom with nice comfortable layout! This home is located on a quiet side street that many do not know even exists! Tucked away yet walking distance to Village parks and restaurants! Let's tour this beauty! First floor features 2 bedrooms and a full bath with walk-in shower, along with a dining room, living room and a sundrenched bright and airy kitchen! Upstairs has another 2 bedrooms, another full bathroom and several closets for storage. Welcoming kitchen has Corian solid surface countertops, great prep space for cooking and great amount of cupboard and cabinet storage. Such a handy basement as well that has a laundry area plus mechanical area and workshop area which adds storage plus useful workspace. Vinyl windows and vinyl siding, and circuit breaker electrical service are upgrades we have here! Especially appealing is the expansive yard, over a quarter of an acre, plantings with landscape brick for yard beauty, blacktop driveway and the 2 car garage which is divided into car storage, mower storage and an additional bay used as a picnic room/sunroom. Decent taxes as well, a few thousand less than others in size and location comparison! Rare does a home come up for sale on this lovely little street in the heart of the Village. Great layout, great room count and great area! A great choice!!

23 Bradish Street, Pomfret

38-40 Lambert Avenue, Pomfret
$209,900
8 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ B1698996 MLS
Exceptional turnkey investment opportunity in the heart of Fredonia! Perfectly positioned at 38 Lambert Ave, this fully furnished three-unit property is located less than a five-minute drive from SUNY Fredonia, making it an ideal addition to any investor's portfolio. With strong rental demand driven by the nearby university, this property offers outstanding income potential from day one. The building features a spacious mix of units, including a 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath, 3-bedroom, 1-bath, and 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment, providing flexibility to attract a variety of tenants. The 3-bedroom unit is already generating $2,000 per month in rental income, while the remaining units offer excellent opportunity for additional cash flow. The 4 bedroom unit currently has 3 bedrooms rented out, and the 4th will be rented soon. Each apartment is separately metered for gas and electric, allowing tenants to pay their own utilities and helping reduce owner expenses. Best of all, this is a truly turnkey investment-all furniture, furnishings, and contents are included in the sale, allowing the next owner to step in and begin operating immediately. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio, capitalize on the consistent student rental market, or own a low-maintenance income-producing property in a prime location, 38 Lambert Ave checks all the boxes. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a fully equipped multi-family property just minutes from campus, downtown Fredonia, restaurants, shopping, and local amenities. $5K+ IN POTENTIAL GROSS RENTAL INCOME!! Showings begin immediately, offers will be reviewed as they are received.

38-40 Lambert Avenue, Pomfret

199 E Main Street, Pomfret
$200,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1717731 MLS
Completely remodeled in approximately 2020, this bright and cheerful home beautifully blends charm, character, and comfortable living. Offering four bedrooms and one-and-a-half baths, this inviting property welcomes you with gorgeous hardwood floors, a charming fireplace, and a spacious living room that flows seamlessly into the dining room, where two windows fill the space with natural light. The kitchen opens to the dining room and features abundant counter space, ample cabinetry for storage, and a raised countertop ideal for casual dining and entertaining. A versatile rear entrance/mudroom provides additional space that could serve as a home office, sitting area, or everyday drop zone. A convenient half bath completes the first floor, along with a first-floor bedroom featuring hardwood flooring. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms and a full bath conveniently located at the top of the stairs, with laundry hookups for added convenience. Step outside and enjoy your morning coffee or unwind at the end of the day on the spacious, charming front porch. A newer garage/shed at the rear of the lot provides additional storage.

199 E Main Street, Pomfret

8150 Cummings Road, Pomfret
$199,999
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1718981 MLS
Country charm, room to roam, and a place to unwind! Situated on 3 acres in Stockton, this 4-bedroom, 1-bath ranch offers an inviting setting for everyday country living or a weekend getaway. Beautiful woodwork throughout adds warmth and character, giving the home a welcoming feel that complements its country setting. Outside, a beautiful custom pergola creates a standout space for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying the surroundings. An automatic backup generator adds peace of mind, while a newer hot water tank and a water softener system offer everyday convenience. A 1-car garage and an additional storage shed provide space for parking, tools, and outdoor equipment. The acreage leaves room to enjoy the outdoors, explore gardening ideas, or simply relax under the open sky. Whether you envision quiet mornings with coffee or weekends away from the bustle, 8150 Cummings Road offers space to settle in and make it your own. Come experience the charm and possibilities of this country property! Sale includes tax map id # 065889-181-000-0001-053-000 & 065889-181-000-0001-055-000.

8150 Cummings Road, Pomfret

66 Eagle Street, Pomfret
$198,900
7 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1716987 MLS
DON'T MISS YOUR OPPORTUNITY to own this EXCELLENT INVESTMENT PROPERTY! Spacious, two-family home offering four bedrooms and 2 full baths on the first level. Featuring a large, eat-in kitchen with many oak cabinets, living & dining areas. Enclosed, back porch. Ideal for owner occupancy with additional income from upper 3-bedroom apartment. Recently remodeled and updated interior with new flooring throughout. Freshly painted. Separate utilities. Currently utilized as a successful Airbnb. Previously occupied as a student rental. Potential unlimited. Vinyl sided accented with stone front exterior and vinyl windows. New roof (September 2026). Well maintained. Double driveways. Large rear parking space. Close to downtown, SUNY Fredonia, restaurants, and Village conveniences. Near recreational activities; Lake Erie, beaches, Harbor front, near wine trail, and many more opportunities for entertainment. Don't wait on this one!

66 Eagle Street, Pomfret

21 Woodward Drive, Pomfret
$197,600
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1725466 MLS
Ranch-style single-family residence offering approximately 1,780 square feet of above-grade living space with 4 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom and 1 half bathroom. Situated on an approximately 12,000-square-foot lot, the single-level design provides a functional floor plan together with a full basement for additional storage and utility space. Property features include a 1-car attached garage, fireplace, gas forced-air heating, public water and public sewer service. The residence is being offered in its current condition, providing an opportunity for updates and customization. Located in the Fredonia/Pomfret area of Chautauqua County, the property is in a suburban residential setting. The historical MLS provides local access directions through Route 20 and identifies the subject within the Pomfret/Fredonia market area.

21 Woodward Drive, Pomfret

148 Prospect Street, Pomfret
$195,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1714862 MLS
148 Prospect St Fredonia NY 14063. This 4 Bedroom 1.5 Bath Home has been completely updated. Full exterior paint job in 2026. Full tear-off roof completed in 2026. Back sunroom rebuilt boasting new framing, electrical, insulated and conditioned, can be used year-round! Open Concept first floor, totally updated kitchen, Butcher Block Island, Granite Counter Tops, New Cabinets and solid Oak Hardwood Floors. First floor also has a Half Bathroom, Bedroom, coat closet and an enclosed front entrance. Second floor has three great sized Bedrooms, a Full Bathroom & Laundry Hook-ups! All four Bedrooms have ceiling fans. Full basement for plenty of storage, side yard concrete patio and a big backyard. All mechanical items have been updated, truly move-in ready.

148 Prospect Street, Pomfret

5 Pleasant Avenue, Pomfret
$189,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1640683 MLS
Why has this not sold ?!? # 1 - It DID sell recently and was off the market for months but buyer had to cancel right at closing due to health reasons. # 2 - Taxes are too high! The property is assessed reflecting a market value of $265,636 which is clearly too high. Taxes can be grieved by new buyer in the spring which should lower taxes substantially. Convenient and easy to maintain one floor living, this 2 bedroom 1 1/2 bath townhouse features a large open floor plan with vaulted ceilings and skylights. Kitchen has all appliances and a breakfast bar open to a more formal dining area and spacious living area. Ample size main bedroom w/double closet, 1st. floor laundry, and bath with separate shower and tub. Central air, full poured basement with add'l. 1/2 bath and finished office room. Rear deck, easy to care for yard, and attached garage.

5 Pleasant Avenue, Pomfret

105 Water Street, Pomfret
$184,000
10 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1704008 MLS
Welcome to 105 Water Street, Fredonia! This fully occupied 3-unit property, when fully occupied, brings in over $3k per month in rent. Featuring a total of 10 bedrooms across three spacious apartments (3-bed, 3-bed, and 4-bed layouts). Each unit has separate gas and electric meters, making utility management simple. The property offers ample off-street parking and includes garage spaces. All units come equipped with stoves, refrigerators, washers, dryers, and keyless entry systems for added convenience. Recent upgrades include a durable new metal roof. An ideal opportunity for investors seeking strong rental income in a desirable location near SUNY Fredonia. OPEN HOUSE Saturday August August 8th from 1-3pm. No private showings available until after the open house. Offers due Saturday August 8th at 1pm. Owner is also selling 185 Temple St, Fredonia NY (B1704049) and 19, 21 and 25 Lambert Ave, Fredonia NY (B1704060). Package deal available!

105 Water Street, Pomfret

8 Marion Street Unit LD N, Pomfret
$168,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1701295 MLS
Lily Dale is a unique, gated community with strict rules. You must be a member in good standing of the Spiritualist religion, and property is handled through leaseholds rather than traditional land ownership. Housing and Rules: No Land Ownership: You cannot actually buy and own the land under a home. Instead, you buy a leasehold that gives you the right to live on the property for a set number of years. Cash Only: Mortgages are not allowed inside the community, meaning you must buy your home outright with cash. Even without land ownership, you still have to pay property taxes. Religious Requirement: You must be a member in "good standing" of a recognized Spiritualist church and go through an application process with the Lily Dale Assembly board of directors. Community Life: Small Population: Only around 250 to 275 people live there year-round, though thousands of visitors arrive during the summer program season. Lily Dale is considered to be the 'Psychic Capital Of The World'. The lease fee to the 'Lily Dale Assembly' is currently $1143/year. This 4 bedroom home has a fantastic layout and is ever so welcoming!! 2 bedrooms and a full bath on first floor, 2 more bedrooms and a full bath on 2nd floor as well. Huge walk-in closets are amazingly everywhere. The large living room has a wood burning fireplace and A/C. There is a Mitsubishi mini-split A/C on the 2nd floor to cool the bedrooms upstairs as well! Living in Lily Dale gives you the ability to use the beach and stroll the lovely waterfront, which you can see from the balcony of the upper back bedroom in this home! The basement is partially finished with recreation room that has tiled floor, another 1/2 bath, brick fireplace, mini kitchen, laundry and utility/workshop room and glass block windows. Attached garage with overhead door opener, blacktop driveway. This unique Lily Dale home that is teeming with character and warmth can be lived in for summer use during the Lily Dale Program Event season or year round as it is heated with a Lennox Elite Series forced air furnace. Steel roof, blown-in insulation, high speed internet available. your journey awaits!

8 Marion Street Unit LD N, Pomfret

82 Eagle Street, Pomfret
$165,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1709462 MLS
Welcome to 82 Eagle Street, a well-maintained multi-unit property conveniently located within walking distance of Downtown Fredonia and just minutes from SUNY Fredonia! Both units are currently occupied and generating $1,200 per month each, providing a total of $2,400 in monthly rental income. The property has seen numerous updates, including new vinyl siding on portions of the front and side, two new hot water heaters, new rear steps/porch, and substantial improvements to both front porches. The lower porch features new roof railings and stairs, while the upper front porch has completely new decking, railings, and stairs. The lower unit offers newer flooring in the kitchen and living room, new trim throughout most rooms, new carpet in the office, along with a new refrigerator, washer, and dryer. The upper unit has also received fresh paint. Each unit has its own driveway, providing convenient off-street parking. With established rental income, continued improvements, and a desirable location close to Downtown Fredonia and SUNY Fredonia, this property offers a great investment opportunity and owner occupancy!

82 Eagle Street, Pomfret

34 White Street, Pomfret
$150,000
B1662228 MLS
* OUTSTANDING * PERFECT LOCATION * Professional Building For Sale! Currently Operating As A Thrift-Plant Store / Welcoming Covered Wood Front Porch W Trex Stairs / Front Entrance W Foyer / Spacious Front Room / Half Bath On 1st Floor / Updated Vinyl Flooring Throughout 1st Floor / Kitchen-Breakroom-Employee Lounge / Security Office W Shower / Rear Entrance W Handicap Accessible Elevator / 2nd Floor W WTW Carpet / Flex Room W Closet / Half Bath On Second Floor / Office-Bedroom On Second Floor / Full Basement W Bilco Door, Copper plumbing, Updated PVC Plumbing, Updated 200 AMP Service, HE Furnace W Central AC, Updated Electric HWT, Sump Pump / Black Top Driveway W 4-5 Parking Spaces / Architectural Shingle Roof & Vinyl Siding / Perfect For Retail, Lawyer, Tattoo, Massage Therapy, Barber-Salon..etc / Possible Conversion To Residential W Village Approval

34 White Street, Pomfret

Straight Road, Pomfret
$149,999
R1701055 MLS
Build your custom estate on this 3.3-acre Fredonia, NY lot, offering the ideal balance of quiet village living and direct access to metropolitan amenities. Zoned A-R, this property allows for horses, hobby farming, & barndominiums. Ready to start projects on day one? The acreage includes a pristine, structurally sound 32 x 60, (2 - 12 foot doors & 16 foot ceilings) pole barn, ideal for equipment & storage. Located minutes from local conveniences and major travel routes (I-90 and Route 20), you can enjoy rural peace while remaining within an hour's drive of major jobs, entertainment, and airports in Buffalo NY & Erie PA. Village of Fredonia has approved and planned for city water and city sewer to run up Straight Rd to Christy Rd in early 2027

Straight Road, Pomfret

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!