Marilla Homes for Sale

Marilla Homes for Sale

Marilla: The Perfect Blend of Small-Town Charm and Natural Beauty

Nestled in Erie County, New York, Marilla is a quaint and picturesque town that offers a peaceful respite from the hustle and bustle of city life. With its beautiful landscapes, friendly community, and convenient location, Marilla is an ideal place to call home.

One of the highlights of living in Marilla is its close-knit community. Residents take pride in their town and actively participate in local events and initiatives. Whether it's the annual Marilla Winterfest or the Farmers Market, there's always something happening that brings the community together.

Nature enthusiasts will find plenty to explore in Marilla. The town is surrounded by lush greenery and offers numerous outdoor recreational opportunities. From hiking and biking trails to fishing and camping, there's something for everyone to enjoy. The nearby Sprague Brook Park is a popular destination for outdoor activities, with its scenic trails and picnic areas.

If you're in the market for a new home, Marilla has a range of options to suit different preferences and budgets. From charming cottages to spacious family homes, there's something for everyone. The real estate market in Marilla is thriving, with a variety of properties available for sale. Whether you're looking for a cozy retreat or a larger property with ample space, you're sure to find your dream home in Marilla.

In conclusion, Marilla offers the perfect blend of small-town charm and natural beauty. With its friendly community, abundant outdoor activities, and diverse real estate options, it's no wonder that Marilla is a sought-after location for those looking to settle down.

Newest Marilla Homes for Sale

1755 Eastwood Road, Marilla
$349,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1728145 MLS
Charming Cape Cod situated on 2.85 acres, offering a private and peaceful country setting with a picturesque pond spanning over an acre and featuring its own island! The home offers an open living space with two first-floor bedrooms and a full bathroom. The second floor features a third bedroom, an additional bonus room ideal for a home office, den, or playroom, and a second full bathroom. Additional living space can be found in the walkout basement, featuring a finished den/living room area. Step outside onto the spacious deck located just off the kitchen, creating a wonderful space to relax and enjoy the beautiful surroundings. The deck also provides direct access to the upstairs loft of the detached two-car barn, making this a unique and convenient setup for entertaining, gatherings, or creating your own special retreat. A long stone driveway extends to the back of the property, leading to a shed and a wonderful outdoor area perfect for a fire pit and outdoor entertaining. Additional features include a one-car attached garage and a horseshoe driveway. With 2.85 acres to enjoy, a beautiful pond, and plenty of room to play, entertain, and appreciate the privacy of the setting, this property offers the perfect opportunity to enjoy peaceful country living while remaining conveniently close to local amenities. Your own private oasis awaits! Tax records are incorrect for square footage, home was remeasured by Agent. An additional 383 ft.² of finished area in the walkout basement.

1755 Eastwood Road, Marilla

3400 Timothy Lane, Marilla
$399,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1727784 MLS
Welcome to 3400 Timothy Lane! Nestled on a beautiful 2-acre parcel in the Town of Marilla, within the Iroquois School District, this charming Cape Cod offers 2,200 square feet of living space, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, an attached 2-car garage & a beautiful detached barn! The expansive yard provides plenty of room to relax, entertain & enjoy the outdoors! Inside, you'll find a versatile floor plan featuring a welcoming living room & a convenient first-floor primary bedroom! The eat-in kitchen offers a comfortable dining area, perfect for everyday meals & gatherings! Just beyond, the spacious family room features large windows overlooking the backyard & a cozy wood-burning stove, creating a wonderful space to unwind! Upstairs, you'll find 2 additional generously sized bedrooms, a full bathroom & ample closet space! The partially finished basement provides additional flexible living space, including a room currently used as a bedroom with an egress window, perfect for guests, a home office or hobbies! Step outside to enjoy the spacious deck overlooking the beautiful backyard, complete with a hot tub & above-ground pool! Whether you're hosting summer gatherings, relaxing by the pool or enjoying peaceful evenings outdoors, this property offers endless opportunities to make lasting memories! A portion of the backyard is fully fenced, providing a wonderful space for pets to safely roam & play! The beautiful detached barn offers additional space for storage, hobbies or outdoor equipment! Additional highlights include a newer HWT & metal roof installed in 2023! Square Footage as per floor plans attached in the MLS! Enjoy the peaceful surroundings of country living while being less than 10 minutes from the Village of East Aurora & Route 400! With 2 acres of land, wonderful outdoor amenities & a desirable location, this inviting property has so much to offer. Make this home your own in 2027!! All offers due Tuesday, 11/17 at 10 AM.

3400 Timothy Lane, Marilla

12286 Williston Road, Marilla
$774,900
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ B1723954 MLS
WELCOME TO YOUR OWN COUNTRYSIDE RETREAT IN MARILLA, SITUATED ON 4.79 BEAUTIFUL ACRES IN THE IROQUOIS SCHOOL DISTRICT! This impressive farmhouse offers over 4,500 square feet of versatile living space, featuring 6 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, a complete in-law setup, a rustic barn & breathtaking countryside views in every direction! A welcoming entryway leads into the foyer with a staircase to the main living quarters, featuring 4 bedrms & 2.5 bathrms. The expansive living room showcases soaring vaulted ceilings & a cozy fireplace, while the formal DR offers beautiful views of the surrounding property. The stunning, fully remodeled kitchen features quartz countertops, abundant cabinetry, a center island, included appliances & direct access to a balcony overlooking the picturesque grounds! The primary suite offers a private ensuite bath, walk-in closet & plenty of room for a king-size bed, while the 3 additional beds provide generous closet space. A home office, convenient laundry area & mechanical/storage space add to the home's functionality. The attached 2-car garage features a separate staircase leading to an expansive upper storage area! The 1st floor in-law quarters offer exceptional flexibility, with 2 generously sized bedrooms, a full bath, kitchen, LR with FP, one-step entry, private exterior access & ample parking! Ideal for multi-generational living, extended guests or potential rental opportunities! NEW ROOF(2025) & NEW PATIO(2026)! Outside, the charming barn is currently equipped with multiple animal stalls & pastures, creating an incredible opportunity for equestrian enthusiasts, hobby farmers or anyone seeking a peaceful country lifestyle! Imagine enjoying your morning coffee while watching your horses graze in your own backyard! Horses, chickens & goats are permitted, with plenty of open green space to enjoy. Horse boarding or rental income add even more versatility to this remarkable property! THE SALE INCLUDES 2 SEPARATE PARCELS WITH POTENTIAL TO BUILD ON THE ADJOINING LOT. Enjoy the scenic views, peaceful surroundings & endless possibilities this one-of-a-kind property has to offer! Sq footage as per plans. SHOWINGS BEGIN FRI 10/23 AT 10 AM!

12286 Williston Road, Marilla

11995 Clinton Street, Marilla
$524,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1723098 MLS
Your own private retreat awaits! Nestled on 1.1 beautifully landscaped acres with the perfect blend of sunshine and shade, this spacious Colonial offers the ideal combination of comfort, charm and outdoor enjoyment. Imagine summer afternoons relaxing by your sparkling inground saltwater pool, evenings entertaining on the patio and peaceful mornings enjoying the views from your inviting full front porch! Built in 2003 (using 2”x 6” construction), this beautifully maintained home features an inviting floor plan with hardwood flooring throughout the living room and kitchen. The formal dining room and versatile bonus room, currently used as a den, provide additional space for everyday living and entertaining. The updated kitchen features granite countertops and a comfortable eating area. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms and a total of 2.5 baths throughout the home. The attached two-car heated garage offers the added convenience of hot and cold water service, while a secondary electrical panel is wired to accommodate a future generator. The home is serviced by public water. Step outside to your backyard oasis, featuring beautiful landscaping, a concrete patio and an inviting inground fiberglass saltwater pool that has been professionally opened and closed annually. The back deck features a fabric awning that has been professionally installed and removed seasonally. Additional outdoor amenities include a storage shed and pet-friendly invisible fencing. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate nearby snowmobile trails for winter recreation. Thoughtful improvements include a new roof (2019), central air conditioning (2020), hot water tank (2025) and professionally sealed blacktop driveway (2026). A sump pump with water backup provides additional peace of mind. With its generous living spaces, beautifully maintained grounds and exceptional outdoor amenities, this property offers the perfect balance of everyday comfort and year-round enjoyment!

11995 Clinton Street, Marilla

2035 Eastwood Road, Marilla
$474,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1722285 MLS
16.26 BEAUTIFUL ACRES IN THE IROQUOIS SCHOOL DISTRICT! Nestled in a peaceful country setting in Marilla, this spacious ranch offers the privacy, tranquility & outdoor lifestyle you've been searching for! Enjoy a picturesque backyard overlooking your own pond, while the wooded acreage beyond is ideal for hunting, hiking, ATV trails & exploring nature right outside your door. Inside, you'll find a home filled with character, charm & incredible potential! The impressive 25' x 22' family room is truly the showpiece, featuring a massive floor-to-ceiling fireplace with a beautiful mantel & walls of windows showcasing the scenic surroundings. The inviting living room features exposed beams, brick flooring & a second fireplace, creating a cozy gathering space with a large sliding door leading outdoors. The eat-in kitchen offers abundant cabinet storage, a peninsula, dinette space, an office nook & all appliances included! The convenient ranch layout features 3 generously sized bedrooms with closets, a spacious full bathroom with dual vanities & plenty of natural light throughout. A drive-under attached garage leads to the full basement, offering exceptional storage, mechanical space & room for a workshop. Outside, enjoy the large patio, mature landscaping, storage shed, rustic two-story barn, wraparound balcony & expansive yard! Whether you dream of fishing, gardening, outdoor recreation or simply escaping the hustle of everyday life, this property offers a lifestyle that's becoming increasingly difficult to find! Lovingly owned by the same family for generations, this cherished estate is ready for its next chapter. Offered as-is, this home presents a wonderful opportunity to update & personalize to your taste! CONTINGENT BUYERS WELCOME! Bring your vision & make this one-of-a-kind property your own!

2035 Eastwood Road, Marilla

11411 Stolle Road, Marilla
$1,645,000
5 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ B1709730 MLS
Welcome to 11411 Stolle Road, an exceptional 10-acre private estate offering space, privacy, efficiency and resort-style amenities just outside East Aurora. Built in 2003, this distinctive 5-bedroom, 6-bath home offers 5,434 sq. ft. and was operated by a previous owner as a B&B for more than 20 years. At the heart of the home is a chef's dream kitchen with a large walk-in pantry. Generous living spaces include a gas fireplace and second-floor family/common area. An additional room above the attached garage has a full bath, while a third-floor walk-in attic provides abundant storage. Energy-efficient features include geothermal heating/cooling with touchscreen thermostat and zone control, solar panels and whole-home battery backup. A 25kW generator can recharge the batteries during an outage. It can operate on propane or natural gas, currently runs on propane, and the propane tank is owned. Other improvements include a new utility transformer, 16 Pella replacement windows, LeafFilter and a new radon mitigation system. Enjoy large covered front and rear porches, a heated inground pool with LED pool lighting, and a fenced garden area with established apple trees. Parking and workshop space includes an attached 3-car garage and 24' x 36' detached pole barn/2.5-car garage with lift. The basement is accessible from both the home and attached garage. A Grasshopper zero-turn mower and fuel-storage tank are included. Additional improvements include a redone driveway from the road to the circular drive, and replacement of the south side of the roof and pool house roof in 2017. Offering 10 private acres, over 5,400 sq. ft., extensive garage/workshop space, heated pool, covered porches and impressive energy and backup-power systems, this distinctive property offers an exceptional Western New York estate lifestyle. distinctive Western New York estate.

11411 Stolle Road, Marilla

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!