Amherst Homes under $400,000

Amherst Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Amherst, New York—a charming and vibrant community nestled in Erie County, just a stone’s throw away from the bustling city of Buffalo. Known for its exceptional quality of life, Amherst boasts a top-rated school district that is a cornerstone of the community. The Amherst Central School District is committed to fostering a nurturing and engaging learning environment for students of all ages. With a strong emphasis on academic excellence, innovative programs, and extracurricular activities, parents can feel confident that their children are receiving a well-rounded education.

One of the many appeals of Amherst is the availability of homes under $400,000, making it an attractive option for families, first-time homebuyers, and those looking to downsize. You’ll find a diverse range of properties, from charming single-family homes with spacious yards to modern townhouses that cater to a more low-maintenance lifestyle. The real estate market here is vibrant, offering something for everyone, whether you’re seeking a cozy abode or a contemporary dwelling.

Living in Amherst means enjoying access to beautiful parks, shopping centers, and a plethora of dining options, all while being surrounded by the natural beauty of Western New York. With its friendly atmosphere and community-oriented events, this town truly feels like home. If you’re looking for a place where education, community, and affordability intersect, Amherst is the perfect destination for you and your family. Come explore the possibilities that await in this delightful corner of New York!

Newest Amherst Homes under $400,000

190 Ivyhurst Road, Amherst
$324,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1729482 MLS
Meticulously maintained Snyder home with abundant updates since 2015. Looking for a massive backyard? This one has both recreational space (extra deep fully fenced lot) and entertaining space on its gorgeous paver patio (installed in 2021). The exterior was freshly painted with new roof and gutters in 2019. The driveway, front steps and railing were replaced in 2023. Windows were all replaced between 2015-2018 including the glass block windows in the basement. If the landscaped gardens and curb appeal isn't enough, enter the home into a cozy foyer and get wowed by the newly refinished hardwood floors (2026) and abundant light that fills the living room. The dining room connects the living rm, family rm and kitchen. Kitchen was opened up and completely redone in 2015. It has all the extras like garbage disposal, under cabinet lighting, recessed lighting, solid surface counter tops, tile backsplash, and comes with all appliances. The family room is newly carpeted (2026) and offers a gas fireplace, built in bookshelves, an updated half bathroom huge walk-in storage closet, and access to the back patio. All new doors throughout this home in 2017 (except the charismatic front door). There are 3 bedrooms upstairs with hardwood floors and ample closet space. The full bathroom was redone in 2015. Much of this home was freshly painted recently and let's not forget to mention the dry basement with updated hot water tank & bubbler to street updated in 2018, laundry tub and hose bibs updated in 2021 and electrical panel replaced in 2014. The homeowners are offering a complimentary one year home warranty to top it off! Let's make it happen and welcome you home to 190 Ivyhurst Rd.

190 Ivyhurst Road, Amherst

209 Thistle Lea, Amherst
$350,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1726788 MLS
Pride of ownership shows in this Amherst split-level, ready for its next owner to move in and enjoy! Recent updates include all-new siding and insulation (January '26), a rebuilt chimney (March '26), a new electrical panel with whole-home surge protection (July '26) and a new boiler (‘21). Step inside to bright natural light and hardwood floors that flow from the living room into the dining area, creating an open space for everyday living and entertaining. Built-in dining room cabinetry adds character and storage. The freshly painted kitchen features a tile backsplash, with all appliances included. Just a few steps down, the flex space offers room to relax, work or play, along with a convenient half bath featuring a new toilet. Upstairs, hardwood floors continue through the hallway and all three bedrooms. The primary bedroom has its own freshly painted full bath with a glass-enclosed walk-in shower. A second full bath features a tub with a tiled surround, a new light fixture and fan. The basement provides additional finished space, a laundry room and storage. Enjoy time outdoors on the concrete patio overlooking the backyard with plenty of green space and a storage shed. The attached one-car garage has room for a workbench, giving you extra storage and project space. All of this is in the Amherst Central School District, close to parks, shopping and restaurants. Showings begin Thursday, 11/12, at 10 a.m. Open house Saturday, 11/14, from 11 a.m.–1 p.m.

209 Thistle Lea, Amherst

339 Smallwood Drive, Amherst
$349,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1725990 MLS
Charming 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch overlooking the park and Smallwood Elementary with beautiful sunset views and access to tennis and pickleball courts right across the street. Set a nearly a quarter acre lot, this well- maintained home offers classic character, versatile living space, and thoughtful improvements throughout. Open the beautiful front door to a foyer w/ a closet for guests. The spacious living room features hardwood flooring, a fireplace framed by built-in bookcases, and opens to a separate formal dining room. The eat-in kitchen has bamboo flooring and includes stainless appliances and a newer induction range (2025) with double oven configuration. The beautiful first floor bath has been fully tiled w/ a rain shower fixture, ceramic flooring & nice cabinet w/hard surface counter. The large LR has a fireplace flanked by bookcases and is open to the separate formal DR . A finished basement provides an additional 350 square feet of well-lit, flexible space, complete with vinyl flooring and nearby second full bathroom for your convenience. The deep, nearly fully fenced backyard offers outdoor opportunities with a pergola-covered deck, generous lawn space, and a storage shed. Notable improvements include perimeter drain tile, updated 150 amp electrical service, and a line for a generator connection. Smart lighting, smart locks, and a Ring doorbell add modern conveniences and security. Enjoy easy accessibility to nearby recreation, a wonderful neighborhood and the character of a home with room to make it your own.

339 Smallwood Drive, Amherst

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!