Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$359,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1648122 MLS
YOU'LL LOVE THE LOCATION of this NEARLY NEW, stunning, two-story, four-bedroom, two full bath, Village of Fredonia home. Extensively remodeled throughout. Custom kitchen with many quality cabinets, center island, fully equipped with stainless appliances. Dining area with large sliding door leading to a new deck. First floor bedrooms and new full bathroom. Two additional spacious bedrooms with large, walk-in closets on second floor. New large bathroom on second floor with walk-in, tiled shower. Second floor laundry room. New beautiful flooring throughout. Many new improvements including e-glass, argon thermo double-pane windows, hot water heating system, 200-amp electrical service, plumbing with 50-gallon hot water tank. Full poured concrete basement. Spacious, covered, front porch. New vinyl siding and architectural roof. New rear deck. Beautiful double lot. Conveniently located to the downtown Village area, restaurants, SUNY Fredonia Campus, playgrounds, schools, Lake Erie,...DON'T MISS OUT!

7 Hillcrest Drive, Pomfret
$394,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1647646 MLS
Attention outdoor lovers and investors! Nestled on 9.7 wooded acres filled with hard maple, cherry, and beech trees, this unique property offers the ultimate four-season getaway. Explore scenic trails right on your land or snowmobile directly across the street with access to over 2,000 acres of the Canadaway Creek Nature Conservancy. Enjoy nearby Earl Cardot Trails, and Cassadaga Lake- just minutes away. The updated 4-bedroom, 1.5 bath main home features an open floor plan with a cozy corner wood-burning stove, French doors leading to a 50x10 covered rear deck with bar, and an enclosed hot tub room—perfect for relaxing after a day outdoors. The kitchen offers a beautiful black walnut breakfast bar, and numerous updates make this home move-in ready. Beyond the main residence, this property is being operated as a Bed & Breakfast. This includes SEVEN rental cabins, a primitive and modern outhouse, new out door shower, offering a fantastic short-term rental or group retreat opportunity. A large gazebo, multiple fire pits, grill areas, and playsets create the perfect setting for gatherings and outdoor enjoyment. Located near snowmobile trails, public hunting and fishing lands, Lily Dale Assembly, Chautauqua County Wine Trail, the Amish Trail, Lake Erie, and SUNY Fredonia—less than 10 miles from NYS Thruway, with Buffalo, Erie, and Niagara Falls just over an hour away. Whether you’re looking for a recreational retreat, an income-producing property, or a place to live and play year-round, this one-of-a-kind property has it all!

2996 Bard Road, Arkwright
$39,900
R1646889 MLS
Discover the perfect setting for your dream home on this beautiful 2.5-acre parcel located on a quiet dead-end road in the Fredonia School District. With 546 feet of road frontage and a mix of wooded and open land, this property offers the ideal balance of privacy and natural beauty. The land is situated in the Agricultural District and zoned 311 Res VA Land, providing flexibility for a build-to-suit project. A meandering creek adds character and charm to the property, while the surrounding countryside provides peaceful views and a serene atmosphere. A survey has already been completed, and electric is available at the road, making your building plans even easier to bring to life. Whether you’re looking to construct your forever home or invest in a tranquil getaway, this parcel offers the space, scenery, and setting you’ve been searching for.

Stone Road W, Pomfret
$350,000
R1646155 MLS
Discover the perfect blend of natural beauty, privacy, and potential on this 101-acre property in Portland, NY. Mostly wooded and with some trails throughout, this land offers endless opportunities for recreation, hunting, hiking, or building your dream home or retreat. You can see Lake Erie through the trees, but with a bit of clearing the beautiful Lake Erie views would open up from within the property! A long rough driveway leads into the southern portion of the property. Electric service is already on site, and existing structures include a 16' x 56' carport and a shed, offering immediate utility and storage. Whether you envision a secluded getaway or simply a beautiful piece of land to explore and enjoy, this property captures the essence of country living with the bonus of lake views and modern convenience. The property is zoned CR: Conservation Residential. See Town of Portland Zoning Ordinance for permitted uses: townofportlandny.gov

8170 Campbell Road, Portland
$80,000
R1645913 MLS
10 Acres Bordering Moonbrook Country Club A beautiful and private 10-acre property located along a secluded lane in the Town of Ellicott, bordering the prestigious Moonbrook Country Club. This peaceful setting offers a rare chance to own land surrounded by natural beauty and quiet luxury—perfect for anyone dreaming of a custom home, family compound, or private retreat. The property features multiple surveyed lots that can be purchased together (approximately 10 acres total) or individually, allowing buyers the flexibility to choose the ideal size and layout for their needs. A private, tree-lined road leads into the property, offering a sense of exclusivity and calm while still being just minutes from Jamestown, Chautauqua Lake, and I-86. Underground utilities—gas, electric, cable, and high-speed internet—are already available, making the lots ready for construction. Enjoy scenic surroundings with gently rolling terrain, views of the neighboring golf course. Located within the Bemus Point School District, the area is known for its strong community and high quality of life.

Oak Hill Road, Ellicott
$99,999
B1642515 MLS

604 Route 5 & 20, Hanover
$52,900
R1645619 MLS
Endless possibilities await with this two-story, two car garage. Great for a car enthusiast, a workshop, or just added storage, this spacious garage would make a great investment. The second floor was originally intended to be an apartment, so all utilities have been ran to the garage, making in an easier transition. The space is currently open allowing a blank state for your vision!

161 Baker Street, Jamestown
$49,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1643874 MLS
Three-bedroom house in the city! Located on a side street, this home is still in close proximity to the best shopping and dining Jamestown has to offer. The main floor has a living room, a spacious kitchen with laundry hook-ups, and a first-floor bedroom. There are two more sizable bedrooms and a bathroom upstairs. All three of the bedrooms have closet space. The house is fully electric, with baseboard heat, so you can skip the shocking winter gas bills. There is a shed in the yard to store your lawn care items. The house is in need of some upgrades, but for the right buyer, the price can't be beat!

307 Summit Avenue, Jamestown
$549,900
3 Beds ⋅ R1644272 MLS
Investment opportunity! Own a piece of Fredonia’s vibrant business district with this unique mixed-use property at 38, 40, & 42 W Main Street. Comprising three centrally located commercial/residential buildings, this investment opportunity offers both stability and growth potential in a high-traffic location. Property Highlights: 4 Commercial Spaces: Three leased to reliable, long-term tenants, ensuring steady income. One vacant space, ready for a new tenant or your business vision. 3 Residential Units: Includes two spacious 2-bedroom apartments and one generous 3-bedroom apartment, all with separate utilities for hassle-free management. Prime Location: Situated in the heart of Fredonia’s bustling village business area, benefiting from high visibility and foot traffic. Parking Convenience: Ample street and municipal parking available for tenants and customers. This property is a rare find, blending consistent rental income with the flexibility to grow. Perfect for investors or owner-occupiers looking to capitalize on Fredonia’s downtiwn commercial scene. Don’t miss out—schedule a viewing today!

38-42 W Main Street, Pomfret
$74,900
R1643360 MLS
Are you looking for boat or other storage?? This is ideal for that! Beautiful setting toward the back of property to build a house or other and storage building near the front of property. Building has electric! Owner is a NYS Licensed Real Estate Agent.

5460 Weaver Road, Ellery
$259,000
15 Beds ⋅ R1639943 MLS
Excellent investment opportunity with this well-maintained five-unit rental property! Each unit features separate utilities, offering ease of management and strong income potential. Tenants enjoy the convenience of dedicated parking spots and their own private garage—a rare and highly desirable feature. The property has seen numerous updates throughout, including updated kitchens in each unit. Every unit also offers private laundry located in the basement, adding comfort and long-term tenant appeal. With solid functionality, thoughtful upgrades, and strong amenities, this property is ideal for investors seeking a turnkey multi-family with lasting value.

255-261 Buffalo Street, Jamestown
$370,000
R1640899 MLS
Prime downtown opportunity with nearly 8,000 square feet of commercial space on West 3rd Street in the heart of Jamestown. This single-story building offers excellent frontage and visibility, making it ideal for retail, office, or mixed-use redevelopment. Situated on a 0.18-acre lot with approximately 120 feet of street frontage, the property benefits from strong pedestrian and vehicle traffic. Recent improvements include new roof on most of the building in 2025 and new HVAC in 2024.Public water and sewer are connected, and the flat-roof structure provides a clean slate for renovation or modernization. With its location in Jamestown’s core business district and flexible zoning, 304-310 W 3rd Street presents strong potential for an owner-occupant or investor seeking value-add opportunities.

304 - 310 W 3rd Street, Jamestown
$189,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1640683 MLS
Convenient one floor living, this 2 bedroom 1 1/2 bath townhouse features a large open floor plan with vaulted ceilings and skylights. Kitchen has all appliances and a breakfast bar open to a more formal dining area and spacious living area. Ample size main bedroom w/double closet, 1st. floor laundry, and bath with separate shower and tub. Central air, full poured basement with add'l. 1/2 bath and finished office room. Rear deck overlooks a wooded area and attached garage.

5 Pleasant Avenue, Pomfret
$17,000
R1639483 MLS
Unique Opportunity Near Bergman Park! Discover this one-of-a-kind parcel perfectly situated close to schools, shopping, and everyday conveniences—yet tucked away with a serene, natural backdrop. Backing directly to Bergman Park, this location offers privacy, greenspace, and the peaceful sound of a stream running along the wooded edge. An ideal setting for your dream single-family home overlooking nature, or explore the potential for a pole barn (subject to zoning approval). Located within the desirable Southwestern School District, this lot offers both lifestyle and value. Parcels like this rarely become available—don’t miss your chance to build in a prime spot that combines convenience with tranquility. Property will require septic if built on for residential use.

Orr Street, Busti
$339,900
R1639256 MLS
Investment Opportunity in Downtown Fredonia! Two commercial office buildings offered together, zoned for business use! #33 is currently leased to a long-term tenant, while #35 is occupied by the sellers, who are open to a lease-back arrangement. Both buildings feature spacious first-floor offices and additional second-floor space. The upper level offers potential to create an additional apartment alongside the existing 3-bedroom unit—an excellent value-add opportunity! Recent updates include a new rubber roof (2024), 7-year-old boiler, and two central A/C units that have been consistently maintained. Convenient parking with municipal lots just around the corner, plus on-street parking along the front and side.

33-35 E Main Street, Pomfret
$69,900
R1638576 MLS
Discover a rare opportunity to own a well-known landmark in the heart of Falconer, New York. Situated on a prominent corner lot, this all-brick, mixed-use building offers both commercial and residential income potential. The main level previously housed the beloved Hultman’s Four Coins Restaurant & Lounge, a long-standing local favorite, and is ready for its next chapter. Property Features:     •    Main Floor – Commercial Space:     •    Approximately 1470 square feet of open-concept space     •    Full bar and kitchen infrastructure in place (equipment negotiable)     •    Classic brick exterior with large street-facing windows     •    Separate entrances for restaurant and apartments     •    Ideal for a bar, café, retail shop, or a fresh new concept     •    Upper Floor – Residential Units:     •    Two spacious apartments with private access     •    Perfect for owner-occupancy or rental income     •    Updated mechanicals and utilities separated     •    Lot & Location:     •    Corner lot with excellent visibility and foot traffic     •    Off-street parking and nearby municipal lots     •    Centrally located in Falconer with easy access to surrounding communities Whether you’re an investor looking to expand your portfolio, an entrepreneur ready to launch a new business, or someone dreaming of living upstairs while operating a business below — this is the opportunity you’ve been waiting for.

232 W Main Street, Ellicott
$450,000
5 Beds ⋅ R1636581 MLS
Commercial & Residential Investment Package – Hamlet of Busti Unlock the potential of this rare 4+ acre property in the heart of Busti, offering a mix of commercial and residential opportunities all in one package. With 8 buildings and room for up to 16 rental units, this property is ready to generate income from multiple streams. Country Store – perfect for a local retail hub or community gathering spot-Currently rented Beauty Salon – currently rented Garages/Workshops – great for storage, service, or small business use 2 Single-Family Homes – live on site or rent out for steady income-both rented 3 Apartment Units – immediate rental revenue with expansion options Whether you’re an investor looking for a diversified income property, a developer with vision for growth, or an entrepreneur wanting to live and work on-site, this property delivers flexibility and opportunity. Nestled in the Hamlet of Busti, this location blends small-town charm with everyday convenience. Rarely does a mixed-use property with this kind of scale, versatility, and upside potential come to market. Schedule your showing today and explore the possibilities.

878 - 884 - 888 - 890 Busti Sugar Grove Road, Busti
$399,500
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1636765 MLS
Welcome to 5480 Scandia Drive! This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home is located in a wooded private setting in the lakeside community of Sunset Bay off of Route 430. The home comes with deeded lake access and boat slip. Upon approaching the front door, you will notice a large covered wrap around front porch perfect for early morning coffee or evening reading. Entering through the front door is a welcoming front foyer with closet with 2 large bedrooms with large closets and a full bath with a skylight to the right. To the left is a large open living room area with a vaulted ceiling, large ceiling fan and a gas fireplace to warm those cosy winter nights. A large open kitchen with a large island, a well lit pantry and skylight provides a wonderful space for entertaining and gathering. To the left of the kitchen is a large formal dining room with large windows. There is a laundry area with a half bath that leads to a large attached 2 car garage with ample storage, electrical panel and HVAC closet. To the left rear of the home is a breakfast room or sitting area and a large primary bedroom with a walk in closet and a large full bath with 2 sinks. Both rooms lead to a private side rear deck perfect for evening meals and relaxing. Home has new hardwood flooring and carpeting. Property also has an adjacent lot for other projects and possibilities. Listing agent is a member of the seller LLC.

5480 Scandia Drive, Ellery
$54,900
R1636418 MLS
The property is completely wooded with a nice mix of hard maple, soft maple, black cherry, red oak, hickory, tulip poplar, beech and more. There was a recent timber harvest here and there is still nice timber remaining, including lots of big red oak to help provide feed for deer and turkey! The logging trails created have all been bulldozed into shape making it ideal for hunting, hiking and ATV use. The deer are already using the trails, evidenced by their prints in the trail system. The log landing area can make a good area for building a camp or pulling in a camper. With a little more clearing you can make a really nice setting above the road with view if you cut some additional trees. Directly across the road is County owned (public) land with a lean-to by Cassadaga Creek. Cassadaga Creek is an excellent fishing stream and is part of the Cassadaga-Conewango Canoe Trip Trail. This is a nice stream to canoe or kayak on, sometimes with some extra portaging necessary. With County land across the road you will not have anyone building across from you here! All oil, gas, mineral and timber rights transfer.

Route 380, Ellicott
$169,900
R1635693 MLS

100 E 5th Street, Jamestown
$79,900
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1631438 MLS
Spacious five bedroom, two bath home with incredible potential! This solid property sits on a large lot and features an oversized two-car garage, already set up for a car shop—perfect for hobbyists or those needing extra workspace. Inside, you’ll find beautiful natural woodwork throughout, a cozy wood-burning fireplace, and plenty of room to make this house your own. Metal roof and many newer windows. While it could use some TLC, the strong bones and character provide a great opportunity to create your dream home. Don’t miss the chance to add your personal touch and unlock the full potential of this property!

1146 Cassadaga Road, Villenova
$29,500
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1624873 MLS
Rehab house in Ashville, Panama School district. House sits on a 1.19 acre lot. All in as is condition. No utilities on, bring flashlight.

1849 S Maple Avenue, Busti
$2,550,000
33 Beds ⋅ R1632258 MLS
Presenting a well-maintained 33-unit multifamily community that combines strong curb appeal, excellent tenant amenities, and consistently above-average occupancy. This property represents a rare opportunity to acquire a stabilized asset with both proven cash flow and continued upside through modernized unit renovations. Property Highlights • Unit Mix: 23 spacious two-bedroom apartments and 10 one-bedroom apartments, catering to a broad range of tenant demographics. • Upgrades: Many units have been completely remodeled, offering modern finishes that attract quality tenants and command premium rents. • Building Quality: Secure, well-kept building with on-site storage and garage parking available for select units—an attractive amenity that differentiates the property in the marketplace. • Outdoor Features: Residents enjoy green space and a gazebo area, creating a sense of community and enhancing tenant retention. • Management: Professional, attentive management has maintained occupancy levels consistently above market averages, ensuring reliable income and reduced turnover risk. Investment Appeal This 33-unit property offers investors the rare combination of stability and value-add potential. With a strong history of occupancy, upgraded units, and attractive amenities, the building generates steady cash flow while still leaving room to capture further upside through the continuation of interior renovations and potential operational efficiencies. Ideal for both private investors and institutional buyers, this is a turnkey multifamily acquisition in a demand-driven rental market.

317 Fairmount Avenue, Jamestown
$37,500
R1631836 MLS
Are you interested in building a new home in a nice Dunkirk location? Look no more! This prime almost 2 acre city spot has all of the utility connections you need right at the road. Located on a low traveled street almost at the end of the city limits. Picture your single floor ranch home being built here or modern 2-story or how about a 'Tiny-House' to live in during our beautiful summer months while spending the cold weather months elsewhere!! Cleared and ready for your new home, this large large parcel consists of 3 lots all connecting. Very desirable and all ready for your imagination, the spot is ready for your new home design to be built!!! Not ready to build yet but want to acquire a parcel for a future build? This land parcel welcomes you to plant gardens, flowers, fruits and vegetables for an oasis in the city and a spot to wind down, garden, plant and when the time comes to build, it's yours!!!

W Benton & Ruggles Street, Dunkirk
$549,900
21 Beds ⋅ R1598521 MLS
BACK ON MARKET; BUYER FINANCING FAILED! Occupancy is the highest it’s been in years, and the current owner has completed numerous updates—making this 21-unit property a standout opportunity. This is an excellent investment for a savvy buyer seeking scale with the convenience of one centralized location. The property is operating smoothly with many improvements already completed. Current rent roll exceeds $13,000/month and continues to grow, offering immediate income with upside potential. There’s still room to increase value—implement strategic improvements to drive rents higher over time. The potential here is significant. Established property management has a strong relationship with tenants and is willing to remain in place, providing a seamless transition for the next owner.

218 E 2nd Street Unit 212-218, Jamestown
$499,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1629990 MLS
Be the first to live in this must see, breathtaking brand new single family residence in the Town of Chautauqua across from Chautauqua Lake and just a couple miles from Chautauqua Institution. The 3100 plus square foot home has an amazing great room with vaulted ceilings, a beautiful stone fireplace with a gas insert and stunning wood cabinets in the kitchen with live edge granite tops and stainless appliances. There are three large bedrooms and also three full baths in this multi level floor plan. The owner thought of everything with a direct gas line to the grill on the covered back porch, a spacious laundry with lots of cabinets and counter space, radiant heat in the floors on the main level, hot water baseboard heat on the second level and central air throughout. The most amazing 2000 square foot garage is the last stop on the tour with an oversized garage door and two addition overhead garage doors. The stone front adds to the beauty of the garage, that also has radiant heat in the floors, a tankless combo boiler, a half bath and a utility sink. Additionally stairs drop down to enter the second floor space. The garage is finished with metal on the inside and vinyl/stone exterior. Make your appointment today! Please remove shoes.

5105 W Lake Road, Chautauqua
$259,900
R1628876 MLS
Own Your Business, Own Your Building! Opportunities like this don’t come around often! This beautifully preserved brick row building sits proudly in the heart of historic downtown Fredonia—where charm, foot traffic, and opportunity meet. The main level features a fully equipped, turn-key restaurant space that’s been thoughtfully renovated and is ready for your vision. Whether you’re an established restauranteur tired of renting or an entrepreneur ready to bring a new concept to life, this is your chance to own the walls that house your business and start building long-term equity instead of paying someone else’s mortgage. The restaurant includes everything you need to hit the ground running: a new Hood & ANSUL system, grease traps, gas lines, freezers, flat top, sinks, tables, and more—making this an easy transition for any operator. Current tenant is open to discussions about continuing their lease, offering built-in income while you plan your next move. Above the restaurant, the second and third floors host a spacious 3,200 sq ft loft-style apartment—a stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bath setup with soaring ceilings, a fireplace, built-in bar, and bonus room for an office or studio. It’s fully rented to college students through the 2025–2026 school year, providing steady, reliable income that helps cover expenses while you grow your business. With its prime location, strong rental history, and classic Main Street appeal, 36 W Main Street is more than just a property—it’s an opportunity to plant roots, grow your brand, and invest in your future.

36 W Main Street, Pomfret
$12,900
R1627412 MLS
Village of Fredonia treed building lot tucked in on a dead-end street!

00 Middlesex Drive, Pomfret
$79,995
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1623200 MLS
Have you been looking for an affordable home in the Falconer School District, wanting a home in a quaint little town? This may be the one you've been looking for. In todays world finding a move in ready house for under $90K is a rare occurrence. This 4 bedroom 2 bath home has had many updates already done for you, including the kitchen, new water heater, high efficiency furnace, vinyl siding, newer vinyl windows and new metal roof. All this And conveniently located to many things, grocery store is just a few blocks away, along with a restaurant and a park. Close proximity to I-86 making it easy for travel.

572 Route 394, Poland
$49,900
R1623411 MLS
An exceptional opportunity to acquire nine contiguous parcels totaling approximately 0.7 acres at the prominent corner of North Main Street and 7th Street in Jamestown, NY. Zoned Vacant Commercial, this property offers excellent potential for a wide range of development projects in a high-visibility, high-traffic area just minutes from downtown. Two of the parcels, located across the street from the main group, are paved, level, and currently used for parking, providing immediate functionality or income potential. The remaining seven parcels are grassy, offering a versatile footprint for future construction, landscaping, or green space. With tons of frontage on both North Main and 7th Street, this site is ideal for commercial or mixed-use development, live/work concepts, or long-term investment. Conveniently located near public transportation, local businesses, and essential services, this property presents a strategic opportunity in the heart of Jamestown’s active commercial corridor.

N Main St N Main Street, Jamestown