Cattaraugus Homes for Sale

Cattaraugus Homes for Sale

Cattaraugus County, located in the state of New York, offers a charming and picturesque setting for those looking to settle down. With its rich history, breathtaking landscapes, and friendly communities, it's no wonder that homes for sale in Cattaraugus County are in high demand.

Whether you're searching for a cozy cottage in a small town or a spacious family home in the countryside, Cattaraugus County has a wide range of options to suit every taste and budget. From traditional colonial-style houses to modern, energy-efficient designs, the real estate market in this area has something for everyone.

One of the standout features of Cattaraugus County is its natural beauty. From rolling hills and lush forests to serene lakes and winding rivers, the county offers a plethora of outdoor activities for nature enthusiasts. Whether you enjoy hiking, fishing, or simply taking in the scenic views, living in Cattaraugus County allows you to embrace a peaceful and active lifestyle.

In addition to its natural attractions, Cattaraugus County is also home to a vibrant arts and culture scene. With local theaters, galleries, and museums, residents can immerse themselves in the rich heritage and creativity of the area.

If you're considering buying a home in Cattaraugus County, now is the perfect time to explore the available options. With its stunning landscapes, welcoming communities, and diverse real estate market, Cattaraugus County truly offers a place to call home.

Newest Cattaraugus Homes for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1712571 MLS

THE POSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS, LET'S START WITH OVER 2000SQFT, 4 BEDROOMS, 2.5 BATHS, LIVING ROOM, DINING ROOM, FAMILY ROOM, AND A SEMI FINISHED BASEMENT ALL ON ABOUT 19 ACRES.

11795 Main Street, Perrysburg

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1713719 MLS

Sold as is Cash only. A good fit for investors or a starter home for someone with contracting skills

730 Bishop Street, Olean

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712454 MLS

9889 Route 16 Machias, is a charming farmhouse, nestled behind the trees creating a private setting while being a stones throw from beautiful Lime Lake. Alongside the towering pines are maples and apple trees. Enter the house into a large mudroom with first floor laundry. Then make your way through the country kitchen with ample cabinet and counter space. The kitchen overlooks into the fairly open concept, living room, dining room. A large bedroom and full bath round out ideal first floor living. Upstairs, is a large bedroom with over sized window for views of the lake. Also upstairs is another full bathroom and unfinished space ideal for 3rd bedroom. Negotiations begin 9/15/26 at 11am.

9889 Route 16, Machias

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1713441 MLS

Welcome to your own private retreat! Beautifully maintained and set on 7 picturesque acres, this unique property offers peaceful country living with plenty of space to relax, entertain, and enjoy the outdoors. A well-maintained pond takes center stage, complete with a dock and approximately 12 feet of water at the end, creating the perfect setting for fishing, relaxing, or simply enjoying the tranquil views. The property also features apple and pear trees and an above-ground pool, adding even more to the outdoor experience. Inside, this impressive home offers three levels of thoughtfully designed living space. The first level features a two-car garage, abundant storage, and a convenient half bathroom. The second level showcases a stunning open floor plan with soaring 24-foot ceilings, an abundance of windows, and beautiful views overlooking the expansive property and pond. Custom-made cherry barn doors add warmth and character throughout. This level also offers two bedrooms, a full bathroom, a main-floor laundry room, and access to a spacious wrap-around deck—perfect for entertaining or taking in the peaceful surroundings. The third level is dedicated to the private primary suite, complete with an en-suite bathroom and beautiful views overlooking the pond. With its combination of acreage, water views, unique architectural details, abundant natural light, and exceptional outdoor amenities, this property offers a rare opportunity to enjoy privacy and nature without sacrificing comfort. Come see all this one-of-a-kind property has to offer!

9165 Point Peter Road, Persia

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1712718 MLS

Welcome to this spacious tri-level home situated on a desirable double lot in the Town of Allegany! The main level offers a comfortable and functional layout with a generous living room, formal dining room, and well-appointed kitchen. The kitchen provides plenty of cabinet and counter space, while the cozy living is perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The upper level is dedicated to the bedroom area, offering three spacious bedrooms with ample closet space and a full bath. The lower level provides even more living space with a large family room featuring an electric fireplace plus a convenient laundry area and second full bath. Need additional space? The partially finished basement offers a great area for a workout room, craft space, hobby area, or additional hangout space. Outside, you'll find a new shed with endless possibilities. With electric already connected to the home's main service, this space could easily become a home office, art or paint studio, playroom, or your own private retreat. Add a space heater in the winter and enjoy this versatile space year-round. A second shed provides convenient storage for lawn and garden equipment. Enjoy the outdoors from the back patio, complete with space for a hot tub, or relax under your own pergola with picnic table—an inviting spot for outdoor meals, morning coffee, or entertaining friends and family. A two-car garage provides additional convenience and storage. With its spacious rooms, multiple levels of living space, double lot, and flexible outdoor areas, this Allegany home offers plenty of room to live, work, relax, and enjoy!

3445 Celeste Drive, Allegany

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712973 MLS

This 2 story home is located in the quaint Village of South Dayton in Cattaraugus County - With a little love , attention and putting your finishing touches on this gem, it could be your sanctuary after a busy day. With the eat in kitchen to the open concept to the living room there is space and ease to relax or entertain. Enjoy peaceful evenings in the spacious 1+ acre yard or on the welcoming covered front porch.

63 1st Avenue, Dayton

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712990 MLS

Welcome to 74 Leavenworth Street in Cattaraugus! This inviting home has been thoughtfully refreshed and is ready for its next owner to move in and make it their own. From the moment you step inside, you’ll appreciate the fresh paint, new carpeting, and comfortable atmosphere throughout. The kitchen is designed to make good use of the available space, and the included stand-alone shelf provides additional workspace and storage. The refrigerator and stove are also included, making your move a little easier. The living area offers a welcoming place to relax, and the television and mount are included with the sale as well. Recent updates add both comfort and appeal to the home. A new sliding glass door brings in natural light and provides easy access to the freshly stained deck, creating a wonderful spot for morning coffee, outdoor meals, or simply unwinding at the end of the day. The first-floor bathroom has also been updated with a new vanity for a clean, fresh look. There is also a shower and toilet in the basement, and the included washer and dryer that offer added convenience. With so many useful items already staying with the property, you can settle in without having to start from scratch. Whether you are purchasing your first home, looking to simplify, or searching for a comfortable place to call your own, this property offers an appealing combination of recent improvements, practical features, and everyday comfort. Come take a look at 74 Leavenworth Street and imagine how easily you could make yourself at home here. Open House 9/19/26, from 11-1 p.m.

74 Leavenworth Street, New Albion

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712845 MLS

WHEN LOCATION, LUXURY, AND LIFESTYLE MATTER, THIS TOTALLY RENOVATED CONTEMPORARY OVERLOOKING PLUM CREEK IS A RARE ELLICOTTVILLE OPPORTUNITY! IDEALLY POSITIONED DIRECTLY ACROSS FROM THE HOLIMONT ENTRANCE AND WITHIN WALKING DISTANCE TO THE VILLAGE, THIS EXCEPTIONAL HOME OFFERS THE PERFECT COMBINATION OF WORLD-CLASS RECREATION, MODERN COMFORT, AND AN UNBEATABLE LOCATION. ESSENTIALLY COMPLETELY REBUILT AND BEAUTIFULLY TRANSFORMED, THIS STUNNING CONTEMPORARY HOME OFFERS A BRIGHT, OPEN FLOOR PLAN DESIGNED FOR TODAY'S LIFESTYLE. THE BEAUTIFUL NEW KITCHEN FEATURES BRAND-NEW APPLIANCES, GRANITE COUNTERTOPS, AND A SEAMLESS FLOW INTO THE SPACIOUS LIVING AREA, WHERE A GAS FIREPLACE PROVIDES A WARM AND INVITING FOCAL POINT. WITH THREE BEDROOMS, INCLUDING THE CONVENIENCE OF A FIRST-FLOOR PRIMARY BEDROOM SUITE, AND TWO FULL BATHS, THE HOME PROVIDES COMFORTABLE AND FLEXIBLE SPACE FOR FAMILY AND GUESTS. SITUATED ON A HALF ACRE OF LEVEL, USABLE LAND, THE PROPERTY OFFERS EXCEPTIONAL ENTERTAINMENT OPPORTUNITIES. A PLETHORA OF PARKING MAKES INVITING FAMILY AND FRIENDS EASY AND CONVENIENT. STEP OUTSIDE ONTO THE EXPANSIVE NEW DECK AND ENJOY BEAUTIFUL VIEWS OVERLOOKING PLUM CREEK. THE BUILT-IN BENCH RUNNING THE LENGTH OF THE DECK CREATES THE PERFECT SETTING FOR MORNING COFFEE, AFTERNOON RELAXATION, OR UNWINDING AFTER AN EXHILARATING DAY ON THE SLOPES. THE EXTENSIVE RENOVATION INCLUDES A NEW METAL ROOF, NEW HEATING AND AIR CONDITIONING, NEW ELECTRIC AND A NEW HOT WATER TANK. FULLY FURNISHED AND MOVE-IN READY, THIS HOME OFFERS AN INCREDIBLE OPPORTUNITY TO BEGIN ENJOYING THE ELLICOTTVILLE LIFESTYLE IMMEDIATELY. JUST MOMENTS FROM HOLIMONT AND A SHORT WALK TO THE SHOPS, RESTAURANTS, AND ENTERTAINMENT OF DOWNTOWN ELLICOTTVILLE, THIS IS MORE THAN A HOME—IT IS A TURNKEY RETREAT IN ONE OF WESTERN NEW YORK'S MOST DESIRABLE DESTINATIONS. WHETHER YOU ARE SEEKING A LUXURIOUS PRIMARY RESIDENCE, VACATION HOME, OR YEAR-ROUND ESCAPE, THIS EXCEPTIONAL CONTEMPORARY DELIVERS THE LOCATION, SETTING, AND MODERN UPDATES YOU HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR!

6924 Route 242 W, Ellicottville

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712441 MLS

Here's your rare opportunity to own a turn of the century timeless country classic!! This stately victorian farmhouse was built in 1900 and sits on almost 22 acres of gorgeous woods overlooking your private pond. A newly built pavillion in the side yard provides a place to entertain or relax in the shade, while you watch the birds, frogs and fish play around the pond. A 2 car garage gives you room for atv's, yard tools, snowmobiles, and tree stands for the fall deer season to use in your wooded back yard. Original hardwood floors & natural woodwork enhance the updated bathrooms and kitchen. A full dry basement holds the furnace, water heater and water filter with plenty of room for storage, a workshop or both. Though it does need some TLC the owner has priced it accordingly and will seriously consider all reasonable offers!! Lots of bedrooms for family and friends make this a perfect ski house, hunting camp or summer picninc spot, all just a mile from Griffith Sculpture Park and just 10 miles to the slopes of Holiday Valley and Holimont, not to mention the always active and exciting Village of Ellicottville. The house plus the second vacant land parcel are selling together totaling 21.45 acres and can not be sold separately. Grab your charming piece of the countryside now and thank me later!!

7144 Prill Road, East Otto

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1712668 MLS

Mountain character, room to gather and a location that puts the Ellicottville lifestyle close at hand. This distinctive 5-bedroom, 2.5-bath chalet offers approximately 2,676 square feet of living space across three levels on a .73-acre setting with views toward HoliMont. The heart of the home is the open main living area, where soaring cathedral ceilings, exposed wood beams and an impressive wall of windows bring the outdoors in. A stone gas fireplace anchors the great room, while the adjoining custom live-edge bar creates a natural gathering place for family and friends. The updated kitchen offers abundant beautiful cabinetry, expansive counter space, stainless appliances, farmhouse-style sink and a large center island with additional seating. The flexible floor plan provides plenty of space for both owners and guests. A main-level primary bedroom adds convenience, while additional bedrooms and living areas are spread throughout the upper and lower levels. The loft overlooks the main living space, adding another spot for relaxing, working or simply enjoying the chalet's dramatic architecture. Public water, sewer and natural gas are connected. After a day of skiing, golfing, hiking or exploring Ellicottville, come home to your own private retreat. Enjoy the sauna, relax in the hot tub or step outside onto the spacious deck surrounded by the wooded hillside. The property has also been marketed as being approximately one mile from HoliMont and about 1.3 miles from the shops and restaurants in the Village, putting recreation and downtown Ellicottville within easy reach. With its warm wood interiors, vaulted ceilings, wall of glass, stone fireplace and generous entertaining spaces, 6862 Niles Road delivers the classic Ellicottville chalet experience with the updates and amenities today's buyers are looking for. Whether you're searching for a four-season getaway or a place where family and friends can gather for years to come, this is a property designed to enjoy Ellicottville in every season.

6862 Niles Road, Ellicottville

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712436 MLS

Move quickly on this one! Village of Allegany in wonderful neighborhood! Three bedrooms/2 baths with attached garage, great backyard, full basement. Tons of room with a great room, sunroom and living room to boot. Make this your forever home. Desirable dead end street so light traffic. Allegany schools!. All offers due Thursday at 1:00.

2 Upland, Allegany

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1697588 MLS

OUTDOORSMAN WELCOME TO THIS TWO STORY CHARMING CHALET PERCHED ON A HILLTOP 1309 SQ. FEET WITH 51.9 COMPLETELY WOODED ACRES WITH SPRAWLING LOWER DECK, SOUTH WESTERLY VIEWS, COVERED UPPER DECK, SWIMMING POOL, KNOTTY PINE INTERIOR, TWO STORY 34X28 BARN/GARAGE/WORKSHOP, SHED, FREE GAS, AND THE VIEWS YOU NEED RIGHT NOW, TOWN OF OLEAN, CLOSE TO THE CITY LINE...Only two owners, this property is currently a part-time residence, gently used, like new and beautiful inside. Well thought out and planned for comfort on both levels. Everyone from all ages and family pets will just love it here! From the driveway enter onto a decked tiered walkway. Entryway laundry with cabinets and storage closet, beautiful bright kitchen with oak cabinetry, higher cabinets and built-in pantry drawers for all of your storage needs, tile countertops-well done, your family or guests can join you at the built-in bar. All the views you are looking for out every window. Vaulted ceilings throughout make these space feel grand. Living room and dining room to front deck with 2 sets of sliding glass doors with the best breezes and views. First floor bedroom with large closet connects to full bath with tub. First floor living space is open to the lower level with beautiful pine stairs and wrought iron railing. Open the french doors to lower well-maintained sprawling deck, and heated swimming pool. Split the basement space for family room/gym/office or make it a gathering space for everyone with comfortable furnishings. Corner woodstove will keep your basement and upper level comfortable. The basement bedroom/guest bedroom has large closet and ensuite bath with stand up shower/storage. Ultility room is fully equipped with mechanicals for the home with added storage/shelving and freezer space. Maintain your driveway and live here year around or enjoy for three seasons like the current owners do. It will be difficult to say good bye but it is time for new owners to reap the enjoyment and rewards this property has to offer. And did I mention the view? All wheel drive better, 4 wheel drive best. Please no drive-bys. Preapproved buyers only please. This is a must see!!

2982 Buffalo Street Ext., Olean

Start Your Search