Cattaraugus County Homes for Sale

Cattaraugus County Homes for Sale

Cattaraugus County, located in the state of New York, offers a charming and picturesque setting for those looking to settle down. With its rich history, breathtaking landscapes, and friendly communities, it's no wonder that homes for sale in Cattaraugus County are in high demand.

Whether you're searching for a cozy cottage in a small town or a spacious family home in the countryside, Cattaraugus County has a wide range of options to suit every taste and budget. From traditional colonial-style houses to modern, energy-efficient designs, the real estate market in this area has something for everyone.

One of the standout features of Cattaraugus County is its natural beauty. From rolling hills and lush forests to serene lakes and winding rivers, the county offers a plethora of outdoor activities for nature enthusiasts. Whether you enjoy hiking, fishing, or simply taking in the scenic views, living in Cattaraugus County allows you to embrace a peaceful and active lifestyle.

In addition to its natural attractions, Cattaraugus County is also home to a vibrant arts and culture scene. With local theaters, galleries, and museums, residents can immerse themselves in the rich heritage and creativity of the area.

If you're considering buying a home in Cattaraugus County, now is the perfect time to explore the available options. With its stunning landscapes, welcoming communities, and diverse real estate market, Cattaraugus County truly offers a place to call home.

Newest Cattaraugus County Homes for Sale

7029 Corduroy, Mansfield
$1,980,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ B1724752 MLS
Fresh snow, a day on the mountain and a hot tub waiting under the stars. This is what having a place in Ellicottville is all about! Right next to HoliMont, 7029 Corduroy brings together the warmth of a mountain getaway with the craftsmanship and thoughtful extras that make every season something to look forward to. Locally sourced beams, rich hickory floors and barnwood ceilings set the tone for gathering with friends, settling in by the gas fireplace and making a weekend last a little longer. Custom solid-cherry cabinetry crafted by local Amish artisans and a beautiful quartz center island make the kitchen a natural gathering spot, from breakfast before the slopes to dinner after a day outdoors. Beautiful views follow you from the living and dining areas to the primary bedroom, keeping the mountain setting close throughout the day. Five full bathrooms and a half bath provide room for everyone to get ready, with beautifully tiled curbless showers adding a special touch. Downstairs, a second gas fireplace, kitchenette and separate laundry make hosting even easier. Skiers and mountain bikers will appreciate the heated, insulated gear garage with custom racks and a workbench, plus ski rooms on both levels and benches for gearing up or kicking off the boots. Then comes the best part: your own hand-hewn cedar Russian-style svitz and a brand-new Royal Spa hot tub. Soothe tired muscles, take in the views and stay out for the stars! Generous decks/patios extend the living outdoors, with a custom drainage system helping keep the finished area below dry. Even winter arrivals feel easier with a snow- and ice-melt driveway. Behind all that mountain charm are insulated concrete form construction, extensive insulation, geothermal heating and air conditioning, a standing-seam metal roof and locally milled larch siding. Remote heating and fireplace controls let you prepare for your arrival, while municipal water and sewer add convenience. Ski, ride, gather, relax. A home made for enjoying Ellicottville/HoliMont with so many reasons to stay another day. Picture holiday dinners, snowy weekends and summer nights with your favorite people. This is where new traditions take root.

7029 Corduroy, Mansfield
64 Brooklyn Street, Portville
$119,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1724839 MLS
Opportunity awaits in the Village of Portville! This 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers approximately 1,368 square feet of living space on a generously sized lot of nearly half an acre. While the property is in need of repairs and updating, it offers plenty of potential for those ready to bring their vision to life. Several improvements have already been made, including a newer front portion of the roof, approximately 3 years old, along with a boiler and hot water tank that are approximately 10 years old. Whether you're looking for your next renovation project or a property to make your own, this home offers an opportunity to build value through improvements. Bring your ideas and explore the possibilities!

64 Brooklyn Street, Portville
9 2nd Avenue, Franklinville
$55,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1724103 MLS
Spacious Home with Endless Potential! Located in the heart of Franklinville, this property offers generous square footage, high ceilings, and a versatile layout with plenty of possibilities. The main level features a bedroom, full bathroom, kitchen with dining area, convenient laundry closet, and access to the attached two-car garage and basement. The upper level offers three additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, spacious living room, and a second kitchen. With its flexible floor plan, abundant living space, and convenient location, this property presents a wonderful opportunity to make it your own. Bring your vision and explore the possibilities!

9 2nd Avenue, Franklinville
3869 South Nine Mile, Allegany
$215,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723713 MLS
Welcome to 3869 South Nine Mile Road! This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom ranch combines comfortable one-floor living, extensive recent updates, and a fantastic Allegany location. Situated on a spacious 0.62-acre lot in the Allegany-Limestone School District, this move-in-ready home offers an attached garage, a generous yard, and an extra parcel across the road bordering the Allegany River! Step inside to discover freshly painted walls and ceilings in every room, beautiful hardwood floors, and abundant natural light from vinyl replacement windows. Recent improvements include an updated bathroom, new hot water tank, new oven and range hood fan, new entryway flooring, and new window shades, with bedroom shades planned for installation. The welcoming floor plan features three bedrooms, a spacious living room, an eat-in kitchen, and convenient first-floor laundry. Additional highlights include 200-amp electrical service updated in 2024 and an updated water softener. Outside, low-maintenance vinyl siding, gutter guards, a concrete driveway, and an attached garage make everyday upkeep easier. Enjoy the open yard or head across the road to the additional riverfront parcel, an appealing spot for fishing, kayaking, or simply taking in the scenery. The location puts you approximately 3 miles from St. Bonaventure University, 12 miles from Allegany State Park, and 19 miles from Ellicottville, with convenient access to shopping, dining, outdoor recreation, and year-round activities. Whether you’re looking for your first home, downsizing, or seeking a Western New York getaway, this thoughtfully refreshed ranch is ready to welcome you home!

3869 South Nine Mile, Allegany
5707 Ashford Hollow Road, Ashford
$190,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1724457 MLS
Step back in time with this VERY charming older home, full of character and possibilities! Featuring 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, a wraparound covered porch and a 1 car garage with electricity. This property offers plenty of potential to retore, personalize and make your own! Inside, you'll find a cozy kitchen and a spacious living room with a woodstove to keep things warm on those chilly days. Water heater was replaced in 2019 by previous owners. Conveniently located only a short drive to Ellicottville and Springville, this home offers the opportunity to bring new life to a property with plenty of character. Come see the possibilities for yourself!

5707 Ashford Hollow Road, Ashford
422 York Street, Olean
$329,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1724483 MLS
Welcome to York Street Country House, a 1929 classic tucked at the foot of a forest-covered mountain on one of Seneca Heights' most picturesque streets. With over $75,000 in recent upgrades, this 2,934 sq. ft., 4-bedroom, 3-bath home has been lovingly restored to keep its old-world soul while adding the comforts you want today. Original doors and hardware, gleaming hardwood floors and beautiful built-ins greet you the moment you step into the entry hall. Gather around one of two wood-burning fireplaces, one in the formal living room and one in the den, or host dinner behind antique French doors in the formal dining room. Morning coffee belongs in the sun-drenched sunroom, now finished in brand-new Italian travertine. The kitchen keeps its charming 1950s vintage character with new Marmoleum checkerboard floors, fresh countertops, and all-new appliances, including a gas stove, dishwasher, and washer/dryer. The main floor bath was fully renovated in 2025 with a soaking tub, a marble-topped antique vanity, and Currey & Company sconces. Main floor living is easy here. The primary bedroom with two closets, a second bedroom and two full baths, including that beautiful new one, are all on the first level. Upstairs are two more bedrooms with closets, a renovated third full bath, a large walk-in closet on the landing, and a full walk-in attic. The basement adds even more storage. The big-ticket items are done: updated plumbing and wiring, a newer furnace and hot water tank, a 9-year-old roof, updated windows with custom plantation shutters, fresh paint throughout, and new carpet in the stairwell and upper guest bedroom. The two-car garage has an electric opener. Outside, mature trees, lush perennials, and a newly fenced backyard (complete with a dog door) create a private, peaceful retreat. Homes with this much character and this many updates don't come along often. Schedule your showing today!

422 York Street, Olean
12210 Church Street, Yorkshire
$129,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1724353 MLS
Charming 2-Bedroom Bungalow on a Quiet Dead-End Street! Tucked away on a peaceful, tree-lined street directly across from the local fire hall and backing directly to Pioneer High School, this move-in ready gem offers the ultimate blend of small-town tranquility and everyday convenience. Inside, modern luxury vinyl tile (LVT) flooring flows seamlessly across the main living area, complemented by a fully equipped kitchen that comes complete with appliances, convenient first-floor laundry, a beautifully updated main-floor full bathroom, and two cozy upstairs bedrooms featuring brand-new carpet. Built for low-maintenance, stress-free living, the home boasts durable vinyl siding, a long-lasting metal roof, a new water heater installed in 2023, and Bilco doors providing easy exterior access to the crawl space basement. Step outside to your private, treed backyard retreat complete with a concrete patio pad—ideal for morning coffee, weekend BBQs, or relaxed evening entertaining surrounded by mature greenery. Don't miss this opportunity for easy, turnkey living!

12210 Church Street, Yorkshire
209 State Park Avenue, Salamanca
$239,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1723777 MLS
Discover an exceptional combination of space, privacy, and versatility at 209 State Park Avenue! Set on a sprawling one-acre corner lot in the City of Salamanca, this pristine four-bedroom, two-bath home offers a rare opportunity to enjoy expansive grounds with the convenience of city living. An impressive 80-foot wraparound porch sets the stage for morning coffee, relaxed evenings, and gatherings overlooking a beautiful property dotted with apple and pear trees. Inside, a private primary suite provides a welcoming retreat, while a first-floor bedroom and bathroom offer flexibility and everyday convenience. Second-floor laundry keeps household tasks close at hand, and a rear mudroom entry with pantry space provides a practical landing spot for groceries, boots, and outdoor gear. The standout garage takes this property to another level, featuring its own bathroom, workshop, office area, and abundant storage—an outstanding setup for projects, hobbies, and organizing everything you need. A separate barn offers room for outdoor toys, while an additional shed keeps yard equipment neatly tucked away. When it’s time to unwind, the three-year-old pool and sunning deck create your own backyard escape, with plenty of surrounding land to entertain, garden, or simply enjoy the open space. From its inviting porch to its remarkable outbuildings and expansive setting, this property delivers far more than a place to call home. An exceptional opportunity to own a beautifully maintained Salamanca property with room to live, work, play, and make it your own!

209 State Park Avenue, Salamanca
5029 Humphrey Road, Great Valley
$749,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1721341 MLS
AN ABSOLUTE MUST-SEE PROPERTY! Welcome to your private Great Valley retreat, where 138 extraordinary acres create a rare blend of seclusion, adventure, and breathtaking natural beauty. Panoramic hillside views, spectacular fall foliage, rolling meadows, mature woods, and peaceful surroundings make this a truly special escape. The charming two-story farmhouse offers 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and beautiful golden oak natural wood craftsmanship throughout. Relax on the spacious covered front porch and take in the quiet landscape. Inside, a beautiful hardwood staircase overlooks the living room, warmed by a cozy gas stove, then flowing into the generous size dining room and updated country kitchen. The kitchen features plenty of cabinets, a breakfast bar/peninsula sitting area with all appliances included. The back door off the kitchen opens to the covered deck overlooking the endless nature. A full bath completes the first floor. 4 bedrooms, located on the second floor with the second full bath, & convenient second-floor laundry. Primary bedroom with private balcony! The full basement provides excellent storage. Outdoors, the possibilities are endless. Explore wooded trails, rolling hills, a meandering creek with natural swimming holes, a private pond ideal for fishing, swimming, or relaxing by the water. Overlooking the pond, a secluded private cabin offers the perfect getaway for guests, quiet mornings, or memorable weekends. Hunt, fish, camp, hike, ride ATVs, or explore your own trails by 4x4—all from the privacy of your own property. Additional features include an oversized 2-car detached garage, separate parking area, storage shed, a 3-stall barn with rear equipment access. Mature trees, including some planted by the owner decades ago, enhance the setting, while potential timber opportunities add further value. Whether you envision a recreational estate, hobby farm, family gathering destination, or peaceful year-round sanctuary, this property delivers an exceptional lifestyle. Located approximately 10 minutes from Holiday Valley, HoliMont, and the charming Village of Ellicottville for all the needed amenities.

5029 Humphrey Road, Great Valley
3033 W State Street, Allegany
$225,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1723543 MLS
This property is located within a block of major commercial properties that include Walmart, Home Depot, BJ's Wholesale Club, Tim Horton's, Starbuck's, Applebees, Aspen Dental and several other national chains including new national chains currently under construction. This a great investment with the possibility of acquiring the three neighboring properties totaling approximately 1.60 acres one of them being a corner lot.

3033 W State Street, Allegany
608 Irving, Olean
$115,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1716644 MLS
Welcome to this inviting recently updated gem offering comfortable living and plenty of potential! Featuring 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and a half bath/laundry room off the kitchen. This home provides a great combination of charm, function, and flexibility. Many of the updates include a new furnace, hot water tank, radiant heating, new electrical panel, all new plumbing, siding and a new porch! Enjoy the partially fenced in backyard which offers plenty of room for gardening, outdoor activities, or even future expansion. The new 2 car garage, that needs a few finishing touches, completes this home. Inside, there's opportunity to make the space your own and create the home you've been looking for, just add your TLC. Conveniently located close to shopping, restaurants, hospital, and major expressways, making everyday commuting easy. A great opportunity to own a home with a generous lot, and room to grow!

608 Irving, Olean
144 Main Street, Randolph
$75,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1723864 MLS
Historic character and renovation potential meet at 144 Main Street in Randolph, NY. Known as the Sheldon Residence. Thaddeus Spencer Sheldon (1818–1868) arrived in Randolph in 1836 and operated a store that served as an exchange for goods produced by area farmers. This circa-1850, one-and-a-half-story, three-bay Gothic Revival home showcases wood-frame construction, board-and-batten siding, and a cross-gabled roof with ornate wood vergeboard at the eaves. There are new wood details in the garage ready to be installed. Tall windows with decorative wood head trim and wood shutters add to its distinctive architectural charm. A new metal roof is already in place, setting the stage for bringing this historic property back to life. Offering over 3,000 square feet, the spacious interior was last used as a flower and gift shop. Some hardwood floors remain in very good condition, while portions of the upstairs have been gutted following water damage. No utilities are currently on or functioning within the home. Renovation is needed, providing an opportunity to restore its character and explore future uses, subject to applicable approvals. Situated on a nice corner lot along the Amish Trail in Cattaraugus County, the property includes a driveway, attached garage, and access to on-street parking. Its Main Street location offers convenient access to Interstate 86, routes toward Ellicottville, and nearby Allegany State Park. Bring your vision to this distinctive piece of Randolph history. Whether you’re drawn to a home with historic character to restore and make your own or envision a distinctive setting for your business, the Sheldon Residence offers possibilities worth exploring. Could this piece of Randolph history be the right opportunity for you? Buyers are encouraged to independently investigate potential historic preservation grants and rehabilitation tax credits. Eligibility and funding availability are subject to applicable program requirements and approvals and are not guaranteed.

144 Main Street, Randolph
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!