Wyoming County Real Estate

Wyoming County Real Estate

Wyoming County, New York: A Hidden Gem for Real Estate

Located in the state of New York, Wyoming County offers a unique blend of natural beauty, small-town charm, and affordable real estate options. Situated in the western part of the state, this county is a hidden gem for those seeking a peaceful and picturesque place to call home.

Wyoming County is known for its stunning landscapes, including rolling hills, lush forests, and picturesque lakes. Outdoor enthusiasts will find ample opportunities for hiking, fishing, boating, and wildlife watching in the county's numerous parks and recreational areas. Letchworth State Park, often referred to as the "Grand Canyon of the East," is a must-visit destination with its breathtaking waterfalls and scenic vistas.

In addition to its natural beauty, Wyoming County boasts a rich history and a thriving community. Charming small towns like Warsaw, Perry, and Attica offer a welcoming atmosphere and a range of amenities, including local shops, restaurants, and community events. The county is also home to several historical sites, such as the Arcade and Attica Railroad and the Wyoming County Historical Society Museum, which provide a glimpse into the area's past.

When it comes to real estate, Wyoming County offers a variety of options to suit different preferences and budgets. From cozy cottages and historic homes to spacious ranch-style houses and new construction developments, there is something for everyone. The cost of living in the county is relatively affordable compared to other parts of New York, making it an attractive destination for those looking for a more affordable housing market.

Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat, a place to raise a family, or a close-knit community to retire in, Wyoming County, New York, offers a unique blend of natural beauty, rich history, and affordable real estate options. Discover the charm of this hidden gem and find your perfect home in Wyoming County.

Newest Listings in Wyoming County

4044 E Hillside Road, Eagle
$1,299,900
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1724643 MLS
Discover a beautiful countryside property offering an exceptional combination of privacy, natural beauty, recreational opportunities, and exciting possibilities for future country living. Uniquely situated on both sides of Hillside Road, this property features substantial road frontage on each side, creating an attractive opportunity to enjoy the land as one expansive parcel or have the potential for multiple country properties. Both sides of Hillside Road offer their own distinctive appeal, with a scenic mixture of open fields, wooded acreage, and natural wildlife habitat. The generous road frontage provides flexibility for potential building locations, offering buyers the opportunity for another dimension of versatility, subject to applicable subdivision and building approvals. For the serious whitetail deer hunter, this property offers excellent habitat and an inviting combination of wooded cover, open fields, and natural travel corridors. Established ATV trails provide convenient access throughout both portions of the property, allowing hunters to reach strategic locations while also creating opportunities for hiking, trail riding, and exploring the land. The presence of mature trees, diverse vegetation, and open fields contributes to the property's appeal for both deer and turkey hunting. Food plot locations are already established, and connected by the ATV Trails. A pond adds another attractive natural feature to the landscape, enhancing the property's recreational appeal and peaceful country setting. Whether enjoying the changing seasons, watching wildlife, or spending time outdoors with family and friends, this property offers an abundance of opportunities to experience the outdoors. This was at a former period in time a large farm with approximately 100 acres of hay fields, that could be rekindled back to production with a little tractor work. There is a duplex home, a barn and a mobile home on the property. The seller makes no claims or warrants to their condition as an estate sale. All gas, mineral, and oil rights owned by the seller will convey with the sale, and there are no gas wells located on the property.

4044 E Hillside Road, Eagle
2246 Wethersfield Road, Java
$269,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1724570 MLS
Exceptional value and space in the highly desirable Attica School District! This 1,700+ sq. ft. ranch features 3 spacious bedrooms, 1 bath, and a bright open-concept layout anchored by a huge living room with cathedral ceilings. The updated kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and living area, perfect for daily living and entertaining. Enjoy peace of mind with modern exterior updates, including low-maintenance vinyl siding and a brand-new metal roof (2025). The main-floor laundry room offers incredible versatility with ample space to easily convert into a home office, pantry, or a second full bathroom. Heating is fully versatile with a pellet stove, oil forced-air furnace, plus a coal stove in the basement (currently unused) for ultimate peace of mind. Outside, the oversized, extra-deep 2-car garage provides excellent parking and storage, while the private yard boasts a stamped concrete patio, a barn with a loft, and a fenced kennel area ready for pets or livestock. Exterior bulkhead (Bilco) doors provide access to the full basement. A truly unique property with endless potential—schedule your tour today!

2246 Wethersfield Road, Java
Steele Avenue, Arcade
$89,900
R1724345 MLS
Commercial vacant land in the Arcade Industrial Park. Almost 2 acres, one of the last lots left! Sewer, water and Arcade Electric available. Zoned commercial. Come and build your new business here!!

Steele Avenue, Arcade
146 W Buffalo Street, Warsaw
$169,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1723795 MLS
Discover timeless character and abundant space at 146 W Buffalo Street in the Village of Warsaw. This five-bedroom home offers two full baths and plenty of room for a large or growing household. Built circa 1850 and situated on approximately 0.21 acres, the property blends historic charm with opportunities to personalize and make it your own. Enjoy convenient access to village shops, dining, schools, and community amenities. Bring your vision and explore all the possibilities this spacious Warsaw home has to offer!

146 W Buffalo Street, Warsaw
5566 Oatka Road Unit 7, Warsaw
$635,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1723601 MLS
Welcome to your dream home! This stunning, nearly new 4-bedroom, 3-bath ranch, built in 2022, offers the perfect blend of modern comfort, thoughtful design, and peaceful country living on 5 picturesque acres with panoramic views. Used primarily as a seasonal second home, this property has been exceptionally lightly lived in and feels like new! The spacious interior features impressive 10-foot ceilings throughout the main living area and in-floor radiant heat, also heat pumps with AC and heat for year-round comfort. The generous primary suite offers a private en-suite bath dual vessel sink; 6 feet jacuzzi tub and an oversized walk-in closet. Bathrooms feature beautiful ceramic tile shower surrounds extending to 10 feet, complemented by glass doors for a sleek, modern finish. The fourth bedroom provides added flexibility for guests, a home office, an apartment, guest suite or additional living space (currently being used as an art studio). Room to expand and grow with the new total square feet measuing 1,952 (previously was at 728 sq feet)! Step outside to enjoy the brand-new patio complete with an outdoor kitchen, perfect for entertaining while taking in the breathtaking views. The grounds are just as special, featuring fruit trees, established flower gardens, and beautiful wildflowers surrounding the home, creating a natural, picturesque setting. The insulated garage has finished walls/ceiling with AC and heat. This exceptional property offers the feel of a brand-new home with the space, privacy, and scenery you’ve been dreaming of. A rare opportunity to enjoy modern living surrounded by nature!

5566 Oatka Road Unit 7, Warsaw
3239 Route 39, Eagle
$110,000
R1722887 MLS
Discover the perfect blend of convenience and country living with this nearly 10-acre buildable lot in Bliss, NY. Ready for your dream home, cabin, or recreational getaway, this property already features a drilled well, septic system, and electric service-saving you time and money as you build. Over half of the property is wooded, offering privacy, natural beauty, and abundant wildlife, while the open areas provide excellent building sites and room for gardens, recreation, or additional improvements. Whether you're looking for a peaceful rural retreat, a hunting property, or a place to build your forever home, this versatile parcel offers endless possibilities. Enjoy the tranquility of the countryside while still being within easy driving distance of nearby towns and amenities. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a nearly 10-acre ready-to-build property in the heart of Wyoming County. Please do not walk the property without your agent. It is owner occupied.

3239 Route 39, Eagle
3428 Garry Road, Eagle
$109,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1722977 MLS
*Your Own Country Retreat with a Private Pond and Over an Acre of Land!* Looking for peaceful country living, a weekend getaway, or a place to make your own? This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home at 3428 Garry Road offers a beautiful natural setting, a picturesque pond, and plenty of room to relax and enjoy the outdoors. Situated on approximately *1.15 acres across two parcels*, the property features a spacious wraparound covered porch overlooking the grounds—perfect for morning coffee, summer evenings, or simply taking in the scenery. The expansive yard, mature trees, and detached two-car garage provide plenty of space for outdoor activities, hobbies, storage, and entertaining. Inside, you'll find a comfortable living room, eat-in kitchen, two main-level bedrooms, and convenient laundry facilities. The home is livable and offers an opportunity to make cosmetic improvements and personalize the space over time. Recent improvements include a *metal roof installed approximately two years ago*, well servicing in 2023, and a water filtration system. A natural gas-powered backup generator provides additional peace of mind, while the walkout lower level offers useful storage and utility space. Whether you're looking for an affordable primary residence, a peaceful weekend escape, or a country property with room for your own ideas, this home offers an appealing combination of natural beauty, practical features, and potential. *Offered at $109,900. Come see the views, explore the grounds, and experience this unique setting for yourself!*

3428 Garry Road, Eagle
7212 S Division Street, Pike
$80,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1722701 MLS
Welcome to small town living, this house is located on a side street in the village, It comes with Public water connected, It has three bedrooms- 2 upstairs one downstairs. It has two full baths, one on first floor also has area for laundry. It has an open kitchen adjacent to a living room with a door to the back porch and back yard. Back yard has a small garden shed. Vinyl siding, and upper roof is metal. Take a look at this one!

7212 S Division Street, Pike
3864 Hollow Road, Orangeville
$299,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1722684 MLS
Welcome to your private retreat on 7 wooded acres in Varysburg. Step inside through the spacious kitchen, finished with warm maple cabinets, featuring plenty of room to cook and gather. Just off the kitchen is the dining room, where a glass door leads out to a large wraparound deck. The living room invites you to settle in around the wood-burning stove and its stone surround that runs floor to ceiling. A first-floor bedroom offers single-level convenience, complete with an attached bathroom featuring a large spa tub. Upstairs, a loft topped with skylights makes a bright, flexible space, joined by two more bedrooms, one with a walk-in closet, and a recently renovated full bathroom. The basement adds even more, with a two-car garage, a full bathroom, and laundry. Outside, the wraparound deck overlooks the trees and makes a great place to entertain, and two sheds provide extra storage. A tankless hot water heater serves the home, and the metal roof, skylights, furnace, and A/C were all installed just two years ago. Private and wooded, close to Letchworth State Park and less than an hour from Buffalo.

3864 Hollow Road, Orangeville
3919 Wing Street, Eagle
$675,000
6 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1722438 MLS
If you’ve been looking for space, privacy, and a simpler way of life, without sacrificing comfort, this 50.58-acre property delivers. The 3,324 sq. ft. custom-built home offers 6 generously sized bedrooms and 2 full baths, with large, open living areas designed for everyday life and meaningful gatherings. The spacious kitchen flows naturally into the dining area and living room, creating a warm central hub of the home. Downstairs, a substantial basement provides abundant storage. Step outside and the property truly opens up. Wide fields, wooded areas, and a newly dug pond with shed create a setting that feels private, usable, and deeply connected to the land. Whether it’s gardening, outdoor recreation, animals, or simply enjoying the quiet, there’s room here to live at your own pace. The outbuildings add incredible versatility: Barn 1: 2,176 SF (32’ x 68’) - Ideal for equipment, animals, storage, or workshop use. Barn 2: 5,000 SF (50’ x 100’) plus 300 SF addition - High ceilings, concrete floors, overhead doors, and a ~14’ x 80’ one-bedroom, one-bath apartment. Over 6,400 SF of greenhouse space, operational and ready for continued use, hobby growing, or homestead expansion. Unlike many rural properties, this one offers both scale and functionality, ample living space, substantial barns and shop areas, and acreage that supports a truly self-sufficient lifestyle. Whether you envision gardening year-round, working on projects in a true shop space, raising animals, or simply enjoying wide-open skies and quiet evenings, this property offers the space and infrastructure to make it happen. Note: The actual square footage differs from public record. The source of the actual square footage is from the building plans.

3919 Wing Street, Eagle
24 Park Road W, Castile
$230,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1721076 MLS
Welcome to 24 Park Road West! Situated on over 1.5 acres in the Village of Castile, this beautiful cedar-sided storybook home is full of character, charm, and potential. Thoughtfully built and well cared for, this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home offers a spacious and versatile layout with two generously sized living rooms, a formal dining room, and a charming room overlooking the backyard that would make an ideal home office or study. Outside, you'll find a sprawling yard with plenty of room to enjoy, along with a detached 2-car garage. Additional highlights include central air conditioning, on-demand hot water, and mostly updated thermal-pane windows. Beautiful hardwoods under the carpet. Tucked away on a quiet road, yet conveniently located near schools, Letchworth State Park, and village amenities. With its timeless character, beautiful setting, and endless possibilities, this is a special property ready for its next chapter! Square footage is 200sq ft less due to the unfinished, not livable closet space in one of the bedrooms upstairs.

24 Park Road W, Castile
1950 Folsomdale Road, Bennington
$449,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1721329 MLS
Escape to the Country! Nestled on 3.5 picturesque acres less than 10 miles outside the charming Village of East Aurora, this 2450 sq. ft. log cabin offers the perfect blend of rustic charm, comfortable living, and endless possibilities for a country lifestyle! Step inside to discover a warm and inviting open floor plan featuring a spectacular great room with fireplace and soaring ceilings, a spacious dining area, and a fully equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances, reverse osmosis & radiant floors. The thoughtfully designed first floor also offers a primary bedroom with private en suite bath with radiant floors, convenient first-floor laundry, and an additional half bath and a pellet stove as additional heat source. Upstairs, you’ll find four additional bedrooms, including one walk-through bedroom, and a second full bath, providing plenty of flexibility for family, guests, or home office space. Outdoors is where this property truly shines! Enjoy 3.5 acres of beautiful countryside complete with a stocked pond, chicken coop, four outbuildings, and established gardens with irrigation. Whether you’ve dreamed of raising chickens, keeping goats or ducks, growing your own produce, or simply enjoying the peace and privacy of country living, this property offers an incredible opportunity to create your very own homestead. With room to roam, space to grow, and nature at your doorstep, this one-of-a-kind property delivers the lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of—all within a short drive of East Aurora’s beloved shops, restaurants, and amenities. Country living with convenience, character, and endless potential!

1950 Folsomdale Road, Bennington
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!