Cattaraugus County Homes under $200,000

Cattaraugus County Homes under $200,000

Welcome to Cattaraugus County, New York, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Southern Tier region. Known for its stunning natural landscapes, rich history, and vibrant communities, Cattaraugus County offers a perfect blend of rural charm and modern conveniences. With its rolling hills, lush forests, and tranquil lakes, outdoor enthusiasts will find endless opportunities for hiking, fishing, and exploring the great outdoors.

One of the most appealing aspects of Cattaraugus County is its affordability, particularly for homebuyers seeking properties under $200,000. This region offers an array of charming homes that provide excellent value for your investment. From cozy bungalows to spacious family homes, there’s something here for everyone. Imagine settling into a quaint cottage surrounded by nature or a classic Victorian with character and charm, all while staying within your budget.

The local communities are warm and welcoming, with a strong sense of belonging and pride. You’ll find friendly neighbors, local shops, and community events that foster connections and create lasting memories. Cattaraugus County is also home to several highly-rated schools, making it an ideal place for families looking to plant roots.

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, looking to downsize, or seeking a vacation retreat, Cattaraugus County is a fantastic choice. With homes under $200,000, you can embrace a lifestyle filled with adventure, tranquility, and the joy of homeownership in this beautiful corner of New York. Come explore the possibilities that await you in Cattaraugus County!

Newest Cattaraugus County Homes under $200,000

212 N 6th Street, Olean
$169,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1728865 MLS
An inviting covered porch, beautifully renovated interior, and a private bathroom for every bedroom make this 3-bedroom, 3-bath Olean home a standout! Freshly painted siding and porches create a welcoming arrival, while natural light, soft neutral finishes, and new wood-look luxury vinyl plank flooring bring warmth and continuity throughout. The renovated kitchen showcases white cabinetry with contrasting hardware, granite countertops, a subway-tile backsplash, and stainless steel appliances approximately two years old. Tall pantry cabinets provide abundant storage, while a movable island offers flexible workspace for cooking and entertaining. A separate dining room features a contemporary light fixture and a comfortable setting for everyday meals or special gatherings. The inviting living room is complemented by a distinctive staircase with stone-look detailing, a substantial wood handrail, and dark metal balusters. A cleverly designed pet nook beneath the stairs adds personality, while a dedicated office provides space for work, hobbies, or creative pursuits. Each bedroom has its own full bathroom, offering exceptional privacy and convenience. Charming upstairs ceiling angles add character, while a first-floor primary bedroom option provides flexibility. Updated bathrooms include coordinated fixtures and vanities, with a double-sink vanity in one bath. Second-floor laundry simplifies daily routines, with the option to add first-floor laundry if desired. Extensive improvements extend behind the finishes: new drywall, fully replaced and upgraded electrical, replaced plumbing upgraded to PEX, a newly added third full bathroom, replacement windows, and updated steel entry doors. The furnace is approximately eight years old, and the water heater is approximately five. Outside, enjoy a newly fenced backyard with a circular, stone-bordered seating area, a double-door storage shed, and space to relax or entertain. Off-street parking accommodates two vehicles side by side, and exterior hot and cold water access adds convenience. With substantial updates and memorable details throughout, 212 North 6th Street is ready for its next chapter!

212 N 6th Street, Olean

41 Sunset Lane, Yorkshire
$49,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1728566 MLS
PRICE IMPROVEMENT!! Can you live anywhere more affordable!? Welcome to easy living in Aristo Terrace, a desirable 55+ community in Arcade! Situated on one of the most sought-after lots in the neighborhood, tucked toward the back with peaceful views of the grounds, this spacious 3 bedroom, 2 full bathroom ranch-style manufactured home offers over 1,300 square feet of comfortable first-floor living. The welcoming front deck is the perfect place to relax, read or host guests outdoors. Inside, you’ll love the open concept layout featuring a spacious living room with room for a large sectional and seamless flow into the formal dining area complete with a built-in hutch for added storage and charm. The galley kitchen offers abundant cabinet and counter space, a pantry and all appliances are included! Convenient first-floor laundry is located near the rear entry alongside the electrical panel and forced air furnace. Thoughtfully designed for privacy, two bedrooms and one full bathroom are located on one side of the home, while the spacious primary suite occupies the opposite wing. The primary bedroom easily accommodates a king-size bed and features TWO closets plus a private ensuite bathroom with generous countertop space and storage. All bedrooms offer excellent closet space! Attached outdoor shed provides additional storage for seasonal items and tools. Home runs on Arcade Electric!! Hurry, you don't want to miss this one!! Open House SUNDAY 10/11 from 11 AM to 1 PM.

41 Sunset Lane, Yorkshire

707 W Sullivan Street, Olean
$175,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1728601 MLS
INVESTORS, TAKE NOTICE! Here's your opportunity to own a 4-unit income-producing property with immediate rental income and excellent potential for increased cash flow! Three of the four apartments are currently occupied by responsible tenants, including one 2-bedroom and two 1-bedroom units. Since purchasing the property in 2018, the owner has made interior updates to each of these apartments, making this an attractive addition to your investment portfolio! The fourth unit, a spacious 2-bedroom apartment, has been completely gutted to the studs and is ready for its transformation! Even better, the majority of the materials needed to complete the renovation are already included, such as flooring, cabinets, bathroom and kitchen fixtures and appliances, lighting, and more! The seller had plans to finish the project but has since relocated, leaving the next owner an excellent opportunity to build equity and add another income stream without starting from scratch. With room for rental increases and the potential to generate income from all four units, there's plenty of upside for a savvy investor! The property also offers a large backyard with space for tenant parking and outdoor enjoyment. Whether you're looking to expand your rental portfolio or invest in a property with value-add potential, this one deserves a closer look! Please allow a minimum of 48 hours' notice for all showings to respect the privacy of the current tenants.

707 W Sullivan Street, Olean

228 Main Street, Randolph
$189,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1728394 MLS
Natural woodwork, an updated kitchen, a three-year-old metal roof, recent foundation repairs, and a park-like backyard highlight this four-bedroom, one-and-a-half-bath home at 228 Main Street in Randolph. Enter through the side door into a tiled mudroom and laundry area, which also houses the tankless water heater and forced-air furnace. Straight ahead, you’ll find a convenient half bath and an updated kitchen with a center island and included appliances. At the back of the kitchen, additional pantry and storage space leads to stairs accessing a separate bonus room—ideal for an office, den, art studio, gaming room, or library. The open dining and living rooms feature hardwood floors and a wood-burning fireplace, creating an inviting setting for everyday living and gatherings. A first-floor bedroom with a gas fireplace offers a cozy retreat, while three additional bedrooms and a full bath occupy the second floor. Outside, enjoy a flagstone patio and a picturesque backyard filled with mature trees, offering a peaceful setting for relaxing, gardening, or entertaining. A detached one-car garage and an additional 22-by-28-foot storage barn provide plenty of room for vehicles, recreational equipment, tools, and hobbies. Located in the Randolph School District with convenient access to Interstate 86, Holiday Valley Ski Resort, and Allegany State Park. This home may also be purchased in conjunction with the neighboring property at 232 Main Street; reference MLS #R1692463 for additional information. The neighboring property offers possibilities for renovation into an in-law residence or vacation rental, or potential removal to create a larger yard or space for your dream workshop, subject to applicable approvals.

228 Main Street, Randolph

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!