Cattaraugus County Homes under $400,000

Cattaraugus County Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Cattaraugus County, New York, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Southern Tier region. Known for its stunning natural landscapes, this charming county boasts a rich tapestry of history, outdoor adventures, and a welcoming community spirit. With its rolling hills, lush forests, and sparkling lakes, Cattaraugus County is a paradise for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike. Whether you enjoy hiking, fishing, or simply soaking in the beauty of the great outdoors, you’ll find endless opportunities to explore and unwind.

For those considering a move to this picturesque area, Cattaraugus County offers an impressive selection of homes priced under $400,000. This affordability makes it an ideal destination for first-time homebuyers, families, and retirees seeking a peaceful lifestyle without breaking the bank. You’ll find charming single-family homes, spacious townhouses, and even cozy cabins that perfectly complement the county's rustic charm.

Living in Cattaraugus County means enjoying a slower pace of life while still having access to modern conveniences. The county is home to delightful small towns, each with its unique character and local shops, restaurants, and community events. Plus, the vibrant arts scene, including local galleries and theaters, ensures there's always something exciting happening.

With its affordable housing options, stunning scenery, and a strong sense of community, Cattaraugus County is not just a place to live—it's a place to thrive. Explore the homes available today and discover the perfect spot to call your own in this enchanting corner of New York!

Newest Cattaraugus County Homes under $400,000

3466 Celeste Drive, Allegany
$329,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1728637 MLS
Welcome to 3466 Celeste Drive in Allegany, a classic two-story brick-and-wood home set on a beautifully green, tree-lined lot with rolling hills on the horizon. With roughly 2,358 sq. ft. of living space, 4 bedrooms, and 2.5 baths, everyone has room to spread out. A covered front porch welcomes you in, and the tiled foyer opens to a sun-filled living room with large windows overlooking the front lawn. The formal dining room is ready for holiday dinners, and the kitchen offers warm wood cabinetry, generous counter space, a gas range, a dishwasher, and a window over the sink. The heart of the home is the long open kitchen and family room, where wood floors and wainscoting lead to a brick hearth with a wood stove insert, the perfect spot on a snowy evening. Sliding doors open to the large covered deck, where morning coffee comes with a view of the hills. A main floor laundry room and a half bath with a marble-look vanity add everyday convenience. Upstairs, four spacious bedrooms all offer generous closet space. One features its own private bath behind a sliding barn door, finished with a tiled walk-in shower and built-in bench. A second full bath with a glass-enclosed shower serves the rest of the floor. The full basement is a hobbyist's dream, with plenty of room for a workshop and storage. The attached two-car garage adds even more workspace with a wall of shelving and a workbench. Hot water baseboard heat keeps the home comfortable all winter. Outside, the expansive yard is framed by mature trees and evergreens, with a storage shed and plenty of open lawn for gardening, play, or simply enjoying the quiet. Aerial views show just how private and peaceful this setting is. Homes with this much space, privacy, and views like these don't come along often.

3466 Celeste Drive, Allegany

212 N 6th Street, Olean
$169,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1728865 MLS
An inviting covered porch, beautifully renovated interior, and a private bathroom for every bedroom make this 3-bedroom, 3-bath Olean home a standout! Freshly painted siding and porches create a welcoming arrival, while natural light, soft neutral finishes, and new wood-look luxury vinyl plank flooring bring warmth and continuity throughout. The renovated kitchen showcases white cabinetry with contrasting hardware, granite countertops, a subway-tile backsplash, and stainless steel appliances approximately two years old. Tall pantry cabinets provide abundant storage, while a movable island offers flexible workspace for cooking and entertaining. A separate dining room features a contemporary light fixture and a comfortable setting for everyday meals or special gatherings. The inviting living room is complemented by a distinctive staircase with stone-look detailing, a substantial wood handrail, and dark metal balusters. A cleverly designed pet nook beneath the stairs adds personality, while a dedicated office provides space for work, hobbies, or creative pursuits. Each bedroom has its own full bathroom, offering exceptional privacy and convenience. Charming upstairs ceiling angles add character, while a first-floor primary bedroom option provides flexibility. Updated bathrooms include coordinated fixtures and vanities, with a double-sink vanity in one bath. Second-floor laundry simplifies daily routines, with the option to add first-floor laundry if desired. Extensive improvements extend behind the finishes: new drywall, fully replaced and upgraded electrical, replaced plumbing upgraded to PEX, a newly added third full bathroom, replacement windows, and updated steel entry doors. The furnace is approximately eight years old, and the water heater is approximately five. Outside, enjoy a newly fenced backyard with a circular, stone-bordered seating area, a double-door storage shed, and space to relax or entertain. Off-street parking accommodates two vehicles side by side, and exterior hot and cold water access adds convenience. With substantial updates and memorable details throughout, 212 North 6th Street is ready for its next chapter!

212 N 6th Street, Olean

1027 Eagle Street, Freedom
$220,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1727853 MLS
Welcome to 1027 Eagle Street in Freedom, NY, where comfort, charm, and peaceful country living come together beautifully! Situated on 1.15 acres of beautifully maintained lawn and landscaping, this inviting 3-bedroom, 1-full-bath modular ranch offers 1,260 square feet of comfortable single-level living. Step inside to discover a warm and welcoming interior featuring attractive flooring, charming country-style accents, and inviting living spaces. The spacious kitchen offers plenty of cabinetry and room for everyday living, while the comfortable living room provides a wonderful place to relax and unwind. One of the three bedrooms is currently being utilized as a craft room, offering flexibility for a home office, hobby room, or additional bedroom. The full, insulated and heated basement is partially finished, providing valuable additional space for recreation, hobbies, storage, or future possibilities. Additional conveniences include a new hot water tank, water softener, and crawlspace attic for extra storage. Outside, you'll fall in love with the beautifully maintained 1.15-acre property, offering a spacious lawn, attractive landscaping, and plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. Relax or entertain on the back deck while taking in the peaceful surroundings. An attached one-car garage and two additional storage sheds, measuring 10' x 12' and 8' x 6', provide plenty of space for vehicles, lawn equipment, tools, and outdoor essentials. With its welcoming atmosphere, functional layout, generous outdoor space, and wonderful country charm, this property offers so much to appreciate. Come see all that this lovely home has to offer and imagine making it your own! Property is being sold AS-IS.

1027 Eagle Street, Freedom

41 Sunset Lane, Yorkshire
$49,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1728566 MLS
PRICE IMPROVEMENT!! Can you live anywhere more affordable!? Welcome to easy living in Aristo Terrace, a desirable 55+ community in Arcade! Situated on one of the most sought-after lots in the neighborhood, tucked toward the back with peaceful views of the grounds, this spacious 3 bedroom, 2 full bathroom ranch-style manufactured home offers over 1,300 square feet of comfortable first-floor living. The welcoming front deck is the perfect place to relax, read or host guests outdoors. Inside, you’ll love the open concept layout featuring a spacious living room with room for a large sectional and seamless flow into the formal dining area complete with a built-in hutch for added storage and charm. The galley kitchen offers abundant cabinet and counter space, a pantry and all appliances are included! Convenient first-floor laundry is located near the rear entry alongside the electrical panel and forced air furnace. Thoughtfully designed for privacy, two bedrooms and one full bathroom are located on one side of the home, while the spacious primary suite occupies the opposite wing. The primary bedroom easily accommodates a king-size bed and features TWO closets plus a private ensuite bathroom with generous countertop space and storage. All bedrooms offer excellent closet space! Attached outdoor shed provides additional storage for seasonal items and tools. Home runs on Arcade Electric!! Hurry, you don't want to miss this one!! Open House SUNDAY 10/11 from 11 AM to 1 PM.

41 Sunset Lane, Yorkshire

6833 Route 16, Franklinville
$330,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ R1728392 MLS
NOT YOUR EVERYDAY COUNTRY HOME! Looking for something a little different? How about 15.17 acres, a one-of-a-kind barndominium-style home, beautiful country views, and a long list of recent improvements? Welcome to 6833 Route 16 in Franklinville, where rustic character, wide-open spaces, and modern updates come together! From the moment you step inside, you'll realize this isn't your typical country home! The dramatic two-story layout, soaring ceilings, exposed beams, and spacious kitchen and dining areas give this home a personality all its own. New ceilings with recessed lighting in the kitchen and dining areas add a fresh touch, while new dining room doors installed in 2025 complement the space. AND THE BIG-TICKET IMPROVEMENTS? ALREADY DONE! A new roof was installed in 2024, geothermal heating and cooling was added in 2023, and some electrical updates were completed in 2025. Additional improvements include basement insulation, new basement windows and an exterior door to the unique usable basement area. A new hot water preheater and tank system installed in 2023. The laundry room and half bath received updated electrical and plumbing, along with a new toilet and sink in 2023. The primary bathroom was also updated in 2023 with a new sink, toilet, and shower. Two outdoor water spigots were installed that same year! NOW LET'S HEAD OUTSIDE, BECAUSE 15.17 ACRES IS SOMETHING TO GET EXCITED ABOUT! Enjoy a beautiful combination of open fields, wooded areas, peaceful country views, and frontage along Ischua Creek. Whether you're dreaming of hobby farming, outdoor adventures, gardens, your own hunting grounds or simply having room to roam, there's no shortage of possibilities here! Two garages provide additional space for vehicles, equipment, storage, or hobbies. THIS ISN'T JUST ANOTHER HOUSE IN THE COUNTRY! It's a property with character, acreage, versatility, and an impressive list of updates. If you've been searching for something beyond the ordinary, 6833 Route 16 just might be the one you've been waiting for! Schedule your showing and come experience it for yourself!

6833 Route 16, Franklinville

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!