Cattaraugus County Real Estate

Cattaraugus County Real Estate

Cattaraugus County: A Hidden Gem in New York

Nestled in the western part of New York State, Cattaraugus County is a hidden gem for those seeking a peaceful and picturesque place to call home. With its beautiful landscapes, charming communities, and rich history, this county offers a unique blend of natural beauty and small-town charm.

Cattaraugus County is located in the state of New York, just a short drive from Buffalo and Rochester. It is known for its diverse geography, which includes rolling hills, deep valleys, and scenic waterways. Outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty of opportunities for hiking, fishing, camping, and skiing in the county's numerous parks and recreational areas.

The county is also home to several vibrant communities, each with its own distinct character. From the historic village of Ellicottville, known for its quaint shops and ski resorts, to the bustling city of Olean, with its thriving arts scene and vibrant downtown, there is something for everyone in Cattaraugus County.

In addition to its natural beauty and charming communities, Cattaraugus County is steeped in history. Visitors can explore the Seneca-Iroquois National Museum, which showcases the rich Native American heritage of the region, or take a stroll through the charming village of Little Valley, with its beautifully preserved historic buildings.

Whether you're looking for a peaceful retreat or a place to raise a family, Cattaraugus County offers a unique blend of natural beauty, small-town charm, and rich history. Discover all that this hidden gem has to offer and make Cattaraugus County your new home.

Newest Listings in Cattaraugus County

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1714227 MLS

Discover easy, low-maintenance living at 119 Green Valley Estates, located in a well-managed mobile home community just 10 minutes from Ellicottville’s ski slopes and a short drive from the casino in Salamanca. This beautifully maintained, move-in-ready home features two decks—one on each side—with wired lighting on the left deck for year-round enjoyment. Inside, the fully equipped kitchen flows into the dining area and step-down living room, where an attractive stone gas fireplace creates a warm and inviting gathering space. Large, newer windows fill the home with natural light. The spacious floor plan includes a primary bedroom with a private bath, two additional bedrooms and a second full bath. A large storage building provides plenty of room for seasonal deck furniture, skis, bicycles and other outdoor equipment. Offered fully furnished, this turnkey property is an affordable option for a year-round residence or Ellicottville-area getaway. Where else can you find a furnished three-bedroom, two-bath home offering this much value?

119 Green Valley, Great Valley

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1714209 MLS

Three Floors of Character at the End of a Seneca Heights Cul-de-Sac The street ends at your front door. That's the first thing you notice: no through traffic, no hurry, just a private little pocket of Seneca Heights where the pavement runs out and the yard begins. And what a yard. It's genuinely larger than what this neighborhood usually offers, the kind of space that makes you start sketching out garden beds and fire-pit corners before you've even walked inside. Step in and the floors tell you someone has cared for this house. The hardwood has been recently refinished, and it glows. There's a formal dining room, a real one, the kind that makes a holiday dinner feel like an occasion, and it opens directly onto the back deck, so the party spills outside without anyone crossing the kitchen. When the weather turns, the natural gas fireplace takes over, and the whole house settles into that warm, close, mid-winter comfort that no supplemental heater has ever managed. The kitchen is a legitimate retro gem. Bold, original, full of personality, a space with a point of view. Keep it as the conversation piece it already is, or make it your own later. Upstairs, you'll find two bedrooms and a fully and tastefully remodeled bathroom. One of those bedrooms began life as two, and a previous owner opened it up into a single generous space, a nice bonus for anyone wanting room to stretch out, and an easy path back to a fourth bedroom for anyone who'd rather have the door count. It also has a surprisingly great view out of the windows that might remind you of a Hallmark movie. Then the third floor, which is the real surprise: a private top-level retreat with a large walk-in closet, ready to serve as a primary suite tucked well away from the rest of the house. Add the attached one-car garage, Magnano Park just around the corner, and downtown close enough to walk, and you have the combination that almost never shows up together: character, location, and the practical stuff that actually makes a house livable

107 Garfield Court, Olean

The Parkwood: A Name Olean Already Knows You can build a bar. You can't build a reputation. This one came with the building. The Parkwood has been a fixture on East State Street for years, and it's still going strong with wings and pizza out of the kitchen, live bands on the weekends, and a room that fills up for Bills Sundays as a home base for the Bills Backers of Olean. The regulars, the name, the rhythm of a good Friday night: all of it is already here and already working. That's the piece no amount of renovation money can buy. What sets this property apart is everything around the bar. A huge side deck opens the place up all summer. A large private parking lot plus street parking on top of it means a sold-out show, a fundraiser, or a packed watch party doesn't run into the wall that stops most downtown taverns cold. There's room here for the big night, and room for the crowd to park. Then the investment side. Five residential units convey with the sale: three apartments directly above the bar, plus a separate duplex included in the package. That's six income streams under one closing, with the flexibility to pour the drinks yourself or keep the bar leased and simply collect. The capital worries are handled where it counts. A new roof is going on the bar, and the duplex roof is fairly new, too. Investment highlights 6 income streams: the Parkwood on the main floor plus 5 residential units Established tavern with a real local following — wings, pizza, live music, Bills watch parties Huge side deck built for warm-weather crowds Large private parking lot plus street parking — rare for a bar of this type New roof on the bar this fall; duplex roof fairly new Owner-operate the bar or lease it out and hold a stabilized six-unit property Come see the Parkwood and make it your own.

659 E State Street, Olean

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1713718 MLS

Welcome to easy living in Aristo Terrace, a desirable 55+ community in Arcade! Situated on one of the most sought-after lots in the neighborhood, tucked toward the back with peaceful views of the grounds, this spacious 3 bedroom, 2 full bathroom ranch-style manufactured home offers over 1,300 square feet of comfortable first-floor living. The welcoming front deck is the perfect place to relax, read or host guests outdoors. Inside, you’ll love the open concept layout featuring a spacious living room with room for a large sectional and seamless flow into the formal dining area complete with a built-in hutch for added storage and charm. The galley kitchen offers abundant cabinet and counter space, a pantry and all appliances are included! Convenient first-floor laundry is located near the rear entry alongside the electrical panel and forced air furnace. Thoughtfully designed for privacy, two bedrooms and one full bathroom are located on one side of the home, while the spacious primary suite occupies the opposite wing. The primary bedroom easily accommodates a king-size bed and features TWO closets plus a private ensuite bathroom with generous countertop space and storage. All bedrooms offer excellent closet space! Attached outdoor shed provides additional storage for seasonal items and tools. Home runs on Arcade Electric!! Hurry, you don't want to miss this one!!

41 Sunset Lane, Yorkshire

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ B1712670 MLS

Set among the trees on Four Wheel Drive, this distinctive 6-bedroom, 6-bath Ellicottville mountain home offers approximately 4,071 square feet of living space across multiple levels, combining generous accommodations with the warmth and character of a true ski-country retreat. From the moment you step inside, the architecture makes an impression. The dramatic great room is the centerpiece of the home, featuring soaring ceilings, oversized arched windows, beautiful wood flooring and an impressive floor-to-ceiling stone wood-burning fireplace. Exposed beams and natural wood details enhance the mountain atmosphere, while the expansive windows fill the space with natural light and bring the wooded surroundings indoors. The kitchen offers abundant wood cabinetry, generous counter space, an island and breakfast seating, with an easy connection to the dining and gathering areas. Multiple living spaces throughout the home allow everyone to gather together or find a comfortable place of their own. With 6 bedrooms and an extra sleeping room, this home sleeps 14 people comfortably. A dedicated ski-entry area provides plenty of room for skis, boots, coats and equipment, an especially valuable feature in a four-season mountain home. This ski in/ski out chalet makes coming and going for a day on the slopes easy while helping keep outdoor gear organized. Outside, multiple decks extend the living space and provide several places to enjoy outdoor dining, summer evenings or the changing colors of fall. The distinctive geodesic hot tub dome situated on the deck creates a unique additional outdoor gathering space and adding even more personality to this one-of-a-kind property. Located at HoliMont and convenient to the Village of Ellicottville, Holiday Valley, dining, golf, hiking, mountain biking, festivals and year-round recreation. 11 Four Wheel Drive puts the Ellicottville lifestyle within easy reach. Whether you're looking for a ski-season home, weekend escape or a place to enjoy Ellicottville throughout the year. Fully furnished. This chalet had 2 additions over the years, so square footage was calculated using CubiCasa. Floor plans attached in MLS.

11 Four Wheel Drive, Ellicottville

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1712571 MLS

THE POSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS, LET'S START WITH OVER 2000SQFT, 4 BEDROOMS, 2.5 BATHS, LIVING ROOM, DINING ROOM, FAMILY ROOM, AND A SEMI FINISHED BASEMENT ALL ON ABOUT 19 ACRES.

11795 Main Street, Perrysburg

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1713719 MLS

Sold as is Cash only. A good fit for investors or a starter home for someone with contracting skills

730 Bishop Street, Olean

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1712198 MLS

Welcome to 98 Wildflower, a well-maintained loft-style condo offering a combination of location, views, convenience, and turn-key ownership in the heart of Ellicottville. Ideally positioned toward the front of the Wildflower complex, this unit enjoys picturesque views toward the Holiday Valley slopes and is within easy walking distance of both the Village of Ellicottville and Holiday Valley Resort. This sought-after unit offers convenient first-floor access with a ground-level patio—perfect for enjoying your morning coffee, relaxing after a day on the slopes, or taking in the surrounding scenery. HOA-provided snow removal includes shoveling the sidewalk all the way to your door, and a complimentary ski-season shuttle provides convenient transportation to Holiday Valley. Inside, the open-concept layout creates a comfortable and inviting space for relaxing or entertaining, with a loft-style bedroom adding character and additional sleeping space. The living area is centered around a gas fireplace insert, converted from the original fireplace in 2019, providing a cozy gathering space and supplemental heat in addition to the electric baseboard system. Recent improvements include new laminate wood-plank flooring and fresh paint throughout in 2022, as well as a new hot water tank in 2024. Offered fully furnished and turn-key, the sale includes the furnishings and décor shown, along with kitchen appliances, cookware, dishes, glassware, silverware, small appliances, linens, towels, bedding, and more. Simply bring your personal belongings and start enjoying everything Ellicottville has to offer. Whether you're looking for a personal mountain getaway, a full-time residence, or an investment property with excellent rental potential, this Wildflower condo is an outstanding opportunity. Enjoy easy access to skiing, snowboarding, golf, hiking, mountain biking, dining, shopping, festivals, and year-round events. With its prime position within the complex, desirable ground-level access, slope views, thoughtful updates, complimentary ski shuttle, and fully furnished turn-key offering, 98 Wildflower is ready to be enjoyed from day one.

98 Wildflower, Ellicottville

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1712454 MLS

9889 Route 16 Machias, is a charming farmhouse, nestled behind the trees creating a private setting while being a stones throw from beautiful Lime Lake. Alongside the towering pines are maples and apple trees. Enter the house into a large mudroom with first floor laundry. Then make your way through the country kitchen with ample cabinet and counter space. The kitchen overlooks into the fairly open concept, living room, dining room. A large bedroom and full bath round out ideal first floor living. Upstairs, is a large bedroom with over sized window for views of the lake. Also upstairs is another full bathroom and unfinished space ideal for 3rd bedroom. Negotiations begin 9/15/26 at 11am.

9889 Route 16, Machias

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1713441 MLS

Welcome to your own private retreat! Beautifully maintained and set on 7 picturesque acres, this unique property offers peaceful country living with plenty of space to relax, entertain, and enjoy the outdoors. A well-maintained pond takes center stage, complete with a dock and approximately 12 feet of water at the end, creating the perfect setting for fishing, relaxing, or simply enjoying the tranquil views. The property also features apple and pear trees and an above-ground pool, adding even more to the outdoor experience. Inside, this impressive home offers three levels of thoughtfully designed living space. The first level features a two-car garage, abundant storage, and a convenient half bathroom. The second level showcases a stunning open floor plan with soaring 24-foot ceilings, an abundance of windows, and beautiful views overlooking the expansive property and pond. Custom-made cherry barn doors add warmth and character throughout. This level also offers two bedrooms, a full bathroom, a main-floor laundry room, and access to a spacious wrap-around deck—perfect for entertaining or taking in the peaceful surroundings. The third level is dedicated to the private primary suite, complete with an en-suite bathroom and beautiful views overlooking the pond. With its combination of acreage, water views, unique architectural details, abundant natural light, and exceptional outdoor amenities, this property offers a rare opportunity to enjoy privacy and nature without sacrificing comfort. Come see all this one-of-a-kind property has to offer!

9165 Point Peter Road, Persia

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1711806 MLS

Located in the City of Olean, this multi-unit duplex features off-street parking and two currently vacant apartments, giving the new owner flexibility when selecting tenants. Interior will be in need of some repair. The roof was replaced in 2021 by the previous owner. The lower unit offers 2 bedrooms, a double living room area, a small kitchen, and a bathroom located toward the back of the unit. The upper unit includes 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, a living room, and a small kitchen. Centrally located with convenient access to local amenities, this property offers a practical option for rental use or owner occupancy.

813 W Sullivan Street, Olean

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1712671 MLS

407 Deer Crossing offers the Ellicottville location and slope views buyers are looking for, directly across from Holiday Valley and just a short distance from the Village. This spacious townhouse has approximately 1,725 square feet with 3 bedrooms, three full baths, laundry and accommodations for up to 10 people. The multi-level floor plan has classic ski-country character, featuring a dramatic living room with soaring ceilings, warm wood accents, a stone fireplace and sliding doors leading to the deck. The open loft above adds to the chalet feel, while the dining area and kitchen overlook the main living space, making it easy to entertain. Multiple sleeping areas provide plenty of room for guests, including a loft bedroom with skylight and an additional bunk room. The lower level adds another inviting living and entertaining area with a brick fireplace, built-in bar, another sleeping area, full bath and walkout access. Step onto the deck and take in an outstanding view of the Holiday Valley slopes—a setting that is just as impressive in summer as it is during ski season. With multiple levels of living space, two fireplaces, outdoor space and one of the signature views in Ellicottville, 407 Deer Crossing is ready for its next chapter as a four-season getaway close to skiing, golf, dining, shopping and everything Ellicottville has to offer.

407 Deer Crossing Road, Ellicottville

Start Your Search